I was genuinely disappointed to see so many negative reviews for this amazing collectible shop because my experience has been the complete opposite. I've sold several Pokémon cards and other collectibles here, and I felt I was compensated fairly every time. Many of the negative reviews seem to come from personal collectors who naturally place a higher emotional value on their collections. The reality is that collectibles are a market like any other--their value fluctuates based on supply, demand, and current trends. Just because someone paid retail or above retail doesn't mean the market will always support that price. The owner, AJ, is knowledgeable, honest, and transparent about how he evaluates collections. If you're willing to ask questions instead of assuming you're being lowballed, he'll gladly explain the process and how he arrives at his offers. I also took the time to compare buyback offers from other collectible shops, and most either offer significantly lower percentages or aren't interested in purchasing certain items at all. If I had to make a comparison, I'd say many other shops operate like a used car lot, while Collectible N Stuff feels more like CarMax--straightforward, professional, and transparent. AJ is a genuinely friendly, down-to-earth person who clearly knows the hobby and the business. Based on my personal experience, I highly recommend this shop. Five stars! read more

I've visited this business a couple times. Limited slab selection though they have several binders worth of vintage to modern and even Japanese singles. They have a few sealed English and Japanese product from Evolving Skies/OF ETBs to the Chinese Gengar 151 boxes. They also have Magic and sports cards. They have a WILD selection of Pop figures too. In terms of selling, I was told they don't buy Pokemon common or uncommon bulk but they might for V's or better. I did see them buy like 2 bigger than flat rate boxes worth of Sports cards. I was told depending on the item, they can buy 70% cash or 80% trade. In terms of buying, they say they price cards based on how much they also got them for so I've seen 10% below to 20% above TCGPlayer market price. Just like all your purchases, do your due diligence and see if you agree with their comps or if you are willing to buy at a slight premium for the convenience of being able to check out the card and not needing to wait for pay for shipping. AJ was great helping me out. Very personable. No issues getting prices when some cards were unmarked. I also sold some slabs to him, a lot I couldnt give a flying fc while some I know had value but I just didnt have the time to sell. I had to comp the valuable ones in person but he gave me all the time I needed, never rushed me or sounded annoyed and the rest I essentially just used to help me get a better percent on what I valued. Note that the highest valued slab was ~$150-$200 depending on how you comp. We ended up with a 60 or 65% coin flip probably less with the random slabs I added on.. Never did I think I'd coin flip in a shop. I did win, but did I really? Haha. I did get cash which I wanted cause I'll be going on a couple trips but overall still a positive experience for both visits in the shop. read more

AJ was super helpful today offers fair prices will definitely be doing business later on in the future. check out this store it's great!

The service was great and helpful! I appreciated that the pricing was around retail and they were willing to help someone like me who was newer to card collecting pick out what packs would be best value. Overall I appreciated the help and got some good pokemon pulls too! read more

Easy to work with, provided options for purchase. Purchase showed up unharmed. Definitely recommend.

The service was awful once we walked in we were not even greeted the worker was just on there phone and didn't say a thing we were looking for some disney funkos but count even find them due to the lack of help wouldn't recommend read more

Great people great vibes and great selection! Sold some items and paid very strong! (:

Amazing customer service, very attentive and kind. Overall a nice little shop for all niche hobbies. Definitely recommend going to this place if you are looking to collect pokemon cards! read more

Highly recommended collectable shop! Wide selection of Pokemon (Sealed, Raw, Slabs) and other TCG product. Excellent customer service always. Feels like home when I am there! :) Very helpful and friendly staff.More power to you!! Cheers!! read more

I was there this past Saturday 7.26.25. Way over price. A bag of penny-sleeves $6.99. Hobby shops has them at $2. Pokemon pack anywhere from 20-15 a pack. Some PSA pokemon cards way over price. Same for sports card. He had some football retail blaster boxes for double the price of retail. Do not recommend this place. A bunch of thieves. Negative review negative stars if I could two thumbs down. read more

Pokemon collectors, if your looking to get cards at a hole in the wall collection shop like this one, DO NOT go here. It's extremely overpriced, basically the same your gonna get with any scalper online. Save your time and money and try buying at retail in store. read more

Recently worked with AJ to sell him a big portion of my pokemon card collection. He was super easy to work with and negotiate prices on the items i was selling! Its my second time doing a deal with him and would not hesitate to do another. I also picked up a few slabs he was selling at prices I was happy with! read more

Low selection of singles and slabs but everything was priced fairly. I bought several singles and the manager working gave me a good deal on a couple cards. A hidden gem located in a mall! read more

I walked in looking for a gift. When I walked in, the owner was talking to three underage Mexican boys telling them he had called the cops because the items they had brought in were reported stolen and that they couldn't leave and had to wait for the cops. The kids seemed visibly scared. They said they had nothing to hide and that they didn't want any problems. I turned to them and asked them if they were over 18. They said no. I told them they had the right to not talk to the cops and that they should call their parents. Then the owner kicked me out of his store! When I asked why, he said for no reason, and that he had the right to ask me to leave. Just because I decided to inform these minors of their rights! I wouldn't be surprised if he scammed the kids of their items based on some of these reviews! Beware of this place and the owner! read more

Sells Pokemon singles but at x2 market and aren't willing to go for market price . 16 dollars for a 7 dollar card is crazy. Tried to negotiate but the clerk was not willing to budge. I understand overhead costs which is why market price is understandable for most products. But when the market price changes for single cards and the clerks are shown the current market price from tcgplayer, pricecharting and being told that you would rather hold on to a card rather than sell it for the current market price isn't good business. I understand most mark ups are a little over but double is crazy. Many bay area cards shops that sell singles are willing to negotiate if the cards at their store aren't current with the market price, especially if they supposedly checked the price that day which is clearly a lie because I showed your clerk that the price was off. There are scalpers, there are stores that go off market which are scalpers + tax and there are stores like this one that are worse that scalpers. They are one of the reasons why this hobby had become the way it is. No one can get product and when stores have a lot of product, it is because they have insane price gouging. read more

Been meaning to come here for a few months, but it's a 45 minute drive for me which is why I held off for so long. Came on a Saturday evening and AJ was working and dude was super chill and very pleasant to have around while shopping and browsing! They have a good amount of pops and some nice grails as well. For those that are into it, they also have Pokemon cards and I believe I saw a handful of sports cards while browsing. For sure a decent spot to snag pops and I will always make a stop here when I am in the area!!! read more

Took my nephews to this store and they loved it!!!!! Customer service was great!!!! Will definitely be back!!!!!! read more

Great store! Always great conversations with the store owner AJ! There's much selection of the football/basketball cards I like. Prices are always great and AJ is always willing to work the price down. Definitely my go to store!! read more

My husband and I were looking to sell off a good chunk of our funko collection due to focusing on other lines of collectibles and luckily we got in touch with AJ of Collectables N Stuff. Communication with AJ was great and his response time was quick. We were able to come to a deal that made sense for all parties and it was fair. Aj was reasonable and he did not even attempt to low-ball us. AJ even went above and beyond to travel to us to pickup our lots, which is greatly appreciated. He told us "My word is bond" and he totally came through for us on that. 100%! Our overall experience was very positive and I would definitely do business with AJ and his staff again! Definitely check out his store and patronize a small business. I see other reviewers were harsh and gave low scoring for things that have nothing to do with the actual merchandise...Times are tough right now and if we could all just cut these small businesses some slack for trying to stay afloat, we would all be better off! One Love! read more

Would rate 0 stars if I could. Sold this shop my collection in June of 2023. Was told I would receive a couple payments within a week of the full amount I was offered. I did not receive it all. Instead I was told lie after lie until eventually they just stopped replying entirely. Jump to August of this year where they told me they would make it right and that it was an honest mistake. I took their word like an idiot and to this day still don't have the full payment. More and more lies about why it isn't coming. DO NOT SELL YOUR COLLECTION TO THIS SHOP. They will undervalue your collection and not pay you what they agree to pay you. Garbage ownership and communication. read more

Collectables N Stuff - This is the agreement we both signed 4 months ago. - Toy Stores Near Me - Gilroy, California

Staff is super friendly and super helpful sold our collection here with no problem , they also have awesome pops to choose from if ur looking to add to ur collection read more

Came down to this store to sell some funkos that I no longer wanted. AJ helped us very quickly and fairly negotiated the prices. The deal was a positive experience and they mentioned if there was a specific funko you wanted, he could add you to a list if he comes across one. The store is filled wall to wall with funko with several rare grails. If you are looking for something, give this place a shot! What's really cool is that if you buy a few, there is a free funko that comes with it to add to your collection or trade. Will be coming back for sure to at least see what new stuff he has. read more

Best spot to get your collectibles and much more! I don't know how people can hate on this place. Highly recommend this place, the guys here are super chill! read more

Highlight recommend this shop!! Great selection, value, and costumer service! I appreciate doing business with you guys

Took my 4 year old nephew in to check out what they had. The staff was so good and nice to him. He was having staff look for specific funko pops and answering any questions we had. He had such a great experience! He was even given a Pokémon card for free from the cashier. Excited to take him again! read more

Collectables N Stuff - Toy Stores Near Me - Gilroy, California

I will definitely recommend this store to friends the employees are really nice and helpful finding what I was looking for. 10/10

AJ is a courteous employee who does his best to help everyone who comes into the shop with their Funko pop needs! If you are looking for a specific funko pop or sports card stop by this shop because you will surely find what you're looking for. read more

I have to say Aj is a wonderful person. He got back to me right away for a sale . I came into hes shop very nice very organized with a wide variety. He bought 100+ funkos off me while commenting to a sale to me he had several people in he's shop he made sure to greet everyone and answered all questions that where given to him while finishing up with me . Thank you aj your shop is great can't Waite for you to open one in Vegas . read more

Extremely overpriced stuff. Parents, save your money. Look online or on eBay before you buy anything in this store. I do get that since they are a business, they are trying to make a profit, but price gouging (some things were 3x the price online, one card was thousands more than what you'd pay on eBay or anywhere else) and trying to target unsuspecting buyers is a different story. Laughable when I heard some of the prices on some stuff. Read reviews at their other locations before taking your wallet out. read more

A good place to go to and fair prices for what you might be looking for . They have a wide selection on tradings cards and a lot of funko pops as well. read more

pésimo servicio al cliente, muy rudos y no hacen un esfuerzo por ayudar a los que hablamos poco inglés. no los recomiendo.

AJ is super friendly and has gone out of his way to buy sports card boxes from me. He's super friendly and always appreciate the easy deals! Would highly recommend buyer or selling to him! read more

AMAZING SELLER , Gave me what I asked for! He didn't haggle me. I recommended this store 100%

Awesome shop for Pops. I saw this shop the other day at the outlets and had to check it out. I was not disappointed. They have pretty much any Pop you could imagine, collector cards from Pokémon, basketball, and more. The people working the shop were very helping and nice. I highly recommend everyone visit this shop in the gilroy outlets! read more

"Staff wears masks"....incorrectly. Can't support a store that has staff who wear masks incorrectly. Walked in and one of the sales associates had the mask hanging under their nose, didn't seem to care what people thought. Not even going to waste my time here, I immediately walked out without buying anything. I see some reviews here that only focus on merchandise, but service is super important. If it was only about merchandise I'd just go online instead. I think it's a fool's errand to sell your Funko Pops to a local place since you're not gonna get top dollar, but eh, you do you. And lol I thought the name of the store looked a bit off: https://www.grammar-monster.com/easily_confused/collectable_collectible.htm read more

Came into the shop on an impulse not really knowing anything about pops or collectables. However, the manager AJ really knew his stuff and introduced me to what the hype was all about. It's an amazing store with products for everyone from a novice such as myself to experienced collectors looking for a rare find! My experience there was amazing, I'll definitely be back and definitely recommend anyone in the area or from far to make the trip and check out this gem of a place !! P.S. I was able to find a pop that my nephew had been searching for forever! read more

Sold some of my rarest slabs to a great guy!! For a great price would highly recommend and will sell again in the future. 5 STARS!!

This place has lots of goodies! To start off, everything in here is 100% authentic and most are in VERY good condition! They have all kinds of collectibles (hence the name) and competitive prices. The walls were full of GRAILS too! When selling some pops to them, AJ made sure the process and procedure was very clear! He did everything he could to make sure I was comfortable and the store has MANY reps if you need them! They also gave me a pretty good deal. My friend recommended me this place and I'm for sure going to share it with others as well! read more

Great collectables shop! They have an amazing collection of funko pops and other collectables at a competitive price compared to other online shops. They also have great deals if you buy multiple pops. The guy and girl at the register were very polite and professional. Definitely will come back for more. read more

Was looking to sell a few of my Pops and AJ was able to give me a great price. I will definitely recommend to friends looking to sell their pops to check with Collectables n stuff first. They have a big range of pops from a lot of different shows. I saw a lot of different TCG also. From Pokémon to sports. Definitely worth a stop when out shopping in the area read more