First time here !!! Well we were out junkin and antiquin'. Kiddos were getting hangry. We have heard about Gambino's due to advertising all over the internet, social media, and some radio commercials. So we decided to give it a try on a Saturday. Service was welcoming and friendly. Food: salad bar, I am not about to turn down a wilted lettuce salad bar. I could just blame the humidity and heat outside. Salad bar needs some help and a little more tastier variety in veggies, which could be the humidity playing with the foodie emotions in me.. I am not really sure. We didn't do the buffet. New places for us, we will order off the menu firstly to see if the buffet in the future will be a go. There's another Gambinos in Gore, OK. So two places not far from us could be a hit/miss... -pizza hadn't arrived while typing this .. so I'll hold my thoughts for a moment.... I like the pizza sauce... it's tangy !! The pizza sauce doesn't have the usual zest to it, but this is good. I go off the pizza sauce. The toppings are a plus. So the toppings hit the mark. We ordered one pepperoni and one deluxe which is the "supreme"type. Both pizzas are the thin crust made to order. Not bad!! Not bad for our first step in and sit down. Y'all give it a try. read more

Gambino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Checotah, Oklahoma

It's basically the same great pizza that was served at Godfather's Pizza restaurants in the 1980s and 1990s. Great crust, generous toppings and made with fresh dough daily. read more

Good service, asked what pizza you want on buffet when you walk in. Pizza mediocre. Slim on toppings including cheese.

Give it a 5 for good food but you have to ask for pizza to be put out. Service was good.

Ordered the Mobsters large pizza,Saturday and Manicotti,It was ready in thirty minutes or less,and it was one of the best ones I ever had,My husband devoured the Manicotti and I can't wait to try that myself next time!Will b a future patron no doubt about that. read more

Plenty of seating. The pizza was delicious. Very friendly staff. (Hope you enjoyed our haiku review) read more

Always great service and food! We love Wednesday night buffet! Thank you for always making it a great experience!

Pizza is good from here. Stopped in and they were having their buffet. Salad bar was fresh. Pizza was slow to come out and variety was poor for buffet. read more

Absolutely delicious food and very clean, modern environment. The Mobster pizza is the proper amount of toppings and cheese. When you get it with the Sicilian crust it is delectable. And nowwww... the best BAVARIAN CREAM dessert pizza I've ever had. If you crave something sweet, creamy, with the streusel, this is IT!! Prices are worth it read more

Gambino's Pizza - Bavarian Cream Dessert Pizza (mini 7") - Pizza Near Me - Checotah, Oklahoma

See all

Pizza isn't great crust was too bread-like for my taste, service was excellent however.

Great sauce, cheese, and bread.. what more could you want? Highly recommend to swing in here. The buffet was really good to.

Was in Checotah for antique shopping and stopped in for lunch. It's in an older building downtown, but is well lit and decorated tastefully All American/Italian decor on old brick walls. Really cute!! They have an all you can eat salad bar and pizza with drinks, garlic bread, bread sticks, and ravioli! The price was just under $7.00!! I thought very cheap for all you get. I asked if they had a veggie pizza with jalapeños coming out since I didn't see it on the buffet, so they made one and brought it to my table! How's that for service! The salad fixings were fresh and the ranch dressing tasted like the home made buttermilk kind! Really good! The pizza is really good too! Quite surprised by the whole experience! The staff was so nice and courteous. Small-town friendly! I'll definitely be back!! read more

Best pizza I've had in quite some time. Cheapest prices around as we fed a family of 5 adults for under $35! Atmosphere was old brick town feeling with memories everywhere for my FIL. Fried ravioli, salad bar, dessert pizza and great old school crust on a variety of pies! read more

Absolutely delicious!!!! Love the Hawaiian pizza and Gambinos now delivers to my neighborhood. I will definitely be a repeat customer!

The pizza was good, but the service needs work. My husband, my mom, and I went into Checotah to eat after working on Airbnbs we own in the area. Gambino's closes at 9pm and we got there about 7:50pm. We ordered a couple of small pizzas and a calzone. The salad bar was empty but the girl at the cash register said she would refill it. We got there at the same time as a couple of other families. My husband was trying to make small talk with her and mentioned they were busy on a Saturday night. She made a snide remark saying "yeah, right as we are closing". After we ate, we wanted to order a dessert pizza. My husband went to the counter about 8:45pm and asked if it was too late to order a dessert pizza. The young girl said "well I can't refuse your order anyway, so what do you want?" The dessert pizza took about ten minutes to cook and we were still out the door to leave by 9pm. The girl clearly showed her irritation with us and the other families. It's a Saturday night in an area where people visit in the summer because of Lake Eufaula. We were anxious to try this restaurant and list it as a recommended place to eat in our Airbnb. Unsure we will be doing that now. I understand the girl was young, but she should learn how businesses and customer service work. There was no need for her attitude and it ruined the experience for us. read more

The food isn't TOO bad. And it's a pretty good place to have a date as long as there isn't too many people in there.

Cute decor and great ambience. We had the Italian pizza, which I loved. Saw the salad bar after we'd ordered and was sad that I didn't get a salad because it looked great. Very affordable for such good pizza! read more

I had high hopes for Gambino's Pizza but now I look down at my pathetic pizza the calzone not bad the dessert pizza pretty good but their everyday run-of-the-mill Pizza static I think licking cheese off the bottom of my shoe might have enough taste to cover this pizza up I do not suggest it the price for two medium pizzas almost $30 that's called overpriced calzones are a bit pricey but that's the best thing they do have next to the dessert pizza and if you expect a good Buffet CiCi's pizza is in Tulsa Oklahoma but they're still not good read more

Nice clean restaurant. Not a sit down to order place but staff was very nice and helpful. A good salad bar with several options including a one-trip for $3.99. The pizza was very good with three types of crust. We will return. read more

My family went here today. Very nice place. I like the old brick wall. My grand daughter said she wanted cheese pizza. They didn't have any on the buffet. The gentleman said he would make one and put it on the buffet. A little bit later he didn't just put it on the buffet he brought the whole pizza to our table and gave my grand daughters all the cheese pizza they wanted before taking it to the buffet. He went above and beyond. Excellent service!! read more

First off this place is very clean, always good when you have little kids with you. We ate the buffet and the pizza was really good. Also, the cook saw me walk in with two kids and started making a fresh half cheese half pepperoni pizza and walked it out to us to make sure the girls got what they wanted. You will not be disappointed if you eat here. Buffet is way better than pizza hut's. read more

Visiting from out of state. Great pizza and service. If traveling through stop and eat you won't be disappointed.

I'm fairly well traveled around the country and my favorite food is pizza! I'm telling you right now, Gambino's is one of the best pizzas I've ever had from East to West coast! Fortunately for me, I live in Tulsa and I guarantee I will be coming back to the little town of Checotah just for the pizza! Thank you! read more

if you're considering this pizza place and your staying in KOA DON'T. They gave a price 39 Dollars for two large pizza. Then they told us it would cost 50 dollars because we are in a KOA. Hour in 20min go by still no pizza!!!! We call and they claim they never got the order. And we're very RUDE read more