Great Chicago style pizza and the staff was friendly. Great combination and a definite repeat stop in the future. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Chicago style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Can't figure what happened to them. Used to be very good. Don't order anything but the pizza.

I use to love their pizza, but service at the west side location has recently been petty poor. I ordered a pizza, after it being over an hour and a half late, and a phone call to see where it was, and being told it was on its way we waited another 30 minutes and then canceled the order. we live 2 miles away! I have been told by several others that they have had some bad experiences recently as well, but until now I've only had good experiences. Lesson learned. read more

We sat at the bar and ordered a deep dish pizza.( There were not many people in the restaurant so not busy at all. ) We know this takes longer but after 25 min still no pizza. The waitress came and advised the order had not been started yet and offered us a free beer. OK but another 25 min and we see them bring our pizza out to another table in a to go box. Bring it back into the kitchen then out to us. We ordered the pizza to dine in. They throw it on a pan and when we got it it was maybe luke warm. The bartender walked by our empty glasses numerous times, we had to ask for a drink each time. We come to the Green Bay location a lot and this was the worst service we have ever received there. The staff that was on appeared to be bothered that they had to be there. I believe it will be awhile be fore we go back. read more

Service the service was not like anything I ever encountered. I asked if the coffee was fresh and they didn't have any and the way she mentioned she could probably make a pot but no One else was having any. I felt intimidated and didn't have any and she still gott a big top that's how I am read more

The restaurant was not very busy.There was only one other couple there while we were there. We waited an hour for one pizza. I'm not sure but I think the pizza was made incorrectly. All of the cheese was on top and all of the meat and vegetables were on the bottom.So every time you took a piece or bite of your pizza, the whole entire top came off. Honestly, the pizza was not very good. Our waitress was pretty good though...very attentive. Had noticed a handful of very upset customers come in for takeouts. I'm thinking yesterday was not a good day for them. read more

Ordered delivery. Pie was good. Driver was on time! I would order from there again the next time I'm in GB.

We just ordered again from Gallagher's Pizza a couple nights ago while gaming. Nothing adds to gaming night like a hot, well made, delicious pie. The fact that we can order a pie with half her ingredients and half my ingredients is key. That is REALLY nice and highly appreciated. Thanks for that option. I love "The Monster" with the green olives included on it. Something about the salty olives, not too many either, really balances the flavor out. She got some chicken tomato specialty which she absolutely loves. All I know is we enjoyed the rest of the night and hibernated like two stuffed bears at the beginning of winter, ahhhhh... read more

Visited one of the places they have. It was over an hour to get the pizza. We were still charged for the appetizers and drinks. It is obvious the management needs to learn that customer service and eating the bill makes the customer want to return. I seriously doubt we ever go there again. The part that really got me was the manager blamed the server. He was busting his butt and she did nothing to help ease the load but schmooze with customers at the bar! This was with them not being busy too. read more

Haven't ordered in years but got a pizza and onion rings. Both were amazing. Was also delivered over 30 min early. Webster Ave location read more

We were searching for pizza for my grandsons who were extremely hungry. We just wrapped up a week of camping and promised them pizza! I am so glad we found Gallagher's! Pizza came out fast and hot, very cheesy and everyone loved it! We will be back! read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Pizza...what's left of it after five people enjoyed it! - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Went here on 9/17/21 at 5pm with a friend. We decided on checking out the buffet. When we arrived we found they did have outside seating. The inside is big, a lot of room and clean. The staff was very nice and welcoming. There is a small bar area. They also have some tv's on the walls. Since it was Friday I did see the buffet did have fish. Welcome to Wisconsin on a Friday night! They also had some shrimp. The shrimp was great. They have a nice selection at the salad bar. I recommend the stuffed mushrooms. They were out of this world! I had a few slices of the pizza and it was good. Next time I plan to dine in I want to just order up a pizza. The buffet was very good. Friday nights it runs from 5-8pm. Until the next review, Yelp-Steve-O, out! read more

See all

I recommend going to the De Pere location instead. There was no system or hostperson for seating people at this location, and those who arrived after us got seated first. Organization was not a priority. Food was slow to come out as well. Only saving graces were that the food was tasty and the waitress was nice, but you can find both of those at the De Pere location instead. read more

Never again! Told to pick up our pizzas on a Sunday at 533PM. Pizza wasn't given to me until 558PM, and the place was NOT BUSY! Got home, and the pizzas had about 1 1/2" of crust on each side of a 10" pizza, leaving only 7" of cheese & very little meat. Had to be one of the worst pizzas we ever ordered anywhere. We wanted to try a hometown pizza place, and this was a poor choice. Like I said, never again. read more

One of my favorite places to go when I'm craving takeout food! Fast service & super good pizza & pasta!

Want somewhere to go for not only a quick bite but friendly conversation? look no further than this location but be sure to sit at the bar so you can interact with Lily K...as there is no better service than from her! try the buffalo chicken soup on the buffet AND be sure to ask Lily for a chocolate chip cookie from the cooler in the kitchen!!!!!! sooooo yummy! read more

In town for packers game and staying close by in hotel. The desk clerk recommended and glad he did. My wife and I dined in and got food to go for teenagers back in room. Good food and good service. Give it a try! read more

Crust was not cooked all the way and tasted store bought. Cheese was rubbery and the tomato tasted funny. Here visiting this lovely state known for its cheese, seems sad that the cheese was just plain bad. One of the worst pizzas I have had honestly. Maybe it was an off night since this place has better reviews but I won't be back. read more

Ordered an "Artichoke Lovers" pizza on line and was given instructions the pizza would be ready at 6 o'clock. Got there at 6 and was told it would be 8 minutes late. No big deal. Finally received said pizza at 6:30. Told them they should at least try to get order ready on time or do not instruct customer to pick up when you knew it would be late. Manager listened to me and acted like she really didn't care. Got home with artichoke lover's pizza and there was one tiny slice of artichoke. Next time I want pizza, it will NOT be gallagher's....Steve N. read more

I hear a lot of people talk about how greasy the pizza is here. Well to be honest it is. But what people don't remember is that they are eating pizza not salad. This pizza is good but not good for you. The crust is amazing. I am a sausage guy and the sausage here is just what I am looking for on my pizza. It is on the expensive side for a pie but a medium pizza can feed 3 people. They also have a lunch buffet and dinner buffet Monday and Friday that includes more than just pizza for a good price. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Sausage hand tossed crust and boneless hot wings. - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Came here today specifically to try out the lunch buffet. It was alright by my highish standards for over all experience. The buffet included pizzas, pasta, breadsticks, salad, wings, soups, beverage,and cookies. In my humble opinion the bread sticks were the highlight. It was pretty well tended to, clean, and the staff was attentive enough. I have a thing about food service workers and bare all fitness leggings. When I'm eating it's extremely unappetizing to constantly have a "leave nothing to the imagination" hinny at face level cruising by. But I'll be back to try the fish fry. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Last night I went to the under appreciated Italian place, Gallagers. Everyone thinks pizza when you say Gallagers, but it's more than that. I did my Italian Trio (Spag+meatballs, Chicken Parm, and Lasagna) to sample different Italian joints and it was a hit. The entree was enough for 2 people, with plenty of cheese and 2 big hoggie size garlic breads for like $10 per entree. 2-3 beers and 3 entree's cost me $41. I wouldn't say it's as good as Grandma's, or other super classy places, but for the price and what you get, WELL Worth It!!! I loved the flavor and the size of portions. those 3 entries turned into 7 meals when I got home and added in some veggies to TV dinners. The place was clean, workers very friendly and helpful, fun and in good spirits. not heavily traffic, so you get a seat right away. #Favorite Next time you're thinking Italian, think Gallagers!!! read more

Food is always good and the staff tolerating me is an extra bonus...from Mr. Black...

Picked this place for delivery off of Yelp Reviews and it was amazing!!! Loved the thin pizza and cheese bread. Highly recommended!!!! read more

Shout out to these guys! In town from California and wanted a mid afternoon snack. 16" thin crust sausage and onion. Perfection! Super thin crust. Fresh ingredients. And lotsa Mozzarella. Perfectly seasoned. And the chunky tomato sauce completed this Zaaaaa. I polished off half plus one piece. Food Coma time. great job. I'm in town 1 more week. Gonna hit you up for dine in. Ribs. Cheesesteak. And the Italian Beef. Stay Tuned! read more

Absolutely amazing pizza. I was on my was to Island Sushi, but it was closed, and I drove by this place. I've eaten pizza everywhere from Alaska to the Middle East to Australia--this place is now in my top five places in the world. Ordered the hand tossed pizza with anchovies and feta--great crust, fast service, and just a great overall experience. Will definitely be back, and now my favorite pizza place in my new hometown of De Pere. Great price, great food, friendly service. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

We were there for lunch today. Our pizza came quick. Our server was great. Checked up on us and was attentive. Great place, great pizza, great service!! read more

Ordered pizza online, we waited two full hours at the restaurant to pick up our food still had to pay our full tab. They offered refunds to everyone waiting but we opted to not get the refund as they were so unorganized that we weren't sure it would actually be refunded. Staff behind the bar was clearly overwhelmed- "had no idea" when mine or any of the 15 other people waiting for pickups food was going to be ready, did not want to get updates from the kitchen staff "because they're all really upset back there" and every customer was told their pizza was at the front of the line which was not true. All while we were watching them take more online and phone orders! I feel bad for the poor girls working behind the bar because it was clearly not their fault the pizzas weren't coming out, but the entire situation was mishandled and unorganized. read more

Very good pizza, service was ok and extremely clean place! Cheese bread and pizza was excellent, love the sauce.

I have historically been a big fan of Gallaher's and have even posted positive reviews but tonight I had the worst service I have ever received anywhere. I ordered to go at ~6:15. Was told that it would be 45-60min. I showed up at the restaurant at ~7. We were told our pizza was done, we were just waiting on the sandwich which should be about 5 min. We were told the same thing twenty minutes later. At that time I asked about our pizzas being cold or definitely not fresh because we were told they were finished at 7 . They told us they were in the warmer so it should be ok. We finally got our food at 7:30 which was 75 min after we ordered and I immediately noticed the salad was missing. The person waiting on us was rude and said she thought it was cancelled because it was crossed out. We did not cancel our salad. I can only assume it was crossed off because it was not a hot food item so it was not with our pizzas and wrap. She did go back and get our salad. On the way I reminded her it had to have no croutons. She confirmed it would have no croutons but when we got it, it had croutons (they were on the side but I specifically asked for no croutons for a gluten sensitivity). Then I also noticed my fries were missing with my wrap. She told me they were in there so I basically had to rip open the packaging to show her they were not wrapped in the foil with my wrap. Next she said the receipt said no fries which it did not. At this point I walked out so my kids could eat the food we did get. This was not worth the $65 we paid. I will not be going back to this site anytime soon and would recommend being aware of the poor service. The girls were more concerned with calling every other Gallagher's to get onions than they were with taking care of waiting customers. read more

Gallagher's Pizza - Receipt which does indicate fries with my sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Good pizza. Great doughy crust and a good tangy sauce. Lots of toppings to choose from as well. A great pizza experience!

Waited over 39 minutes for a burger and received our appetizer in 5 mins after ordering. Time was a little off in my opinion. The staff was a little all over the place. It felt like a bunch of teenagers not caring what happens. I ordered a southwest chicken sandwich and my wife ordered a hamburger they were both done very well and tasted good. My wife loved the pickles more than anything haha. It was a great time with my wife, even though we would have liked our food a little quicker. I would say stay away from the soda in my opinion it adds 1.99 per person that orders a soda. Remember water is better for you ;) read more

Gallagher's Pizza - It's looks easy to push tables together - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Don't go for the Friday night buffet. Slowest service ever from our server- and the buffet is severely neglected. Fresh pizzas were not brought out for nearly 2 hours. Left empty pizza trays and one tray with 2 little dried up pieces of pizza on it. They should be embarrassed by the buffet and I'm pretty sure leaving those sad and old pieces of pizza that nobody was going to eat for hours are a health department violation. When a fresh pizza is brought out, it's gone in seconds since everyone is so hungry and wants to try to get their money's worth, the fresh pizzas are always weird combinations too. Just stick to pepperoni and sausage. I think they should just get rid of the buffet since they can't seem to handle it. They really need to put one employee in charge of the buffet when it's busy. Also, no game room here either. So if your kids are fussy and getting hungry because they want pizza and the buffet is empty , there's not the area to keep them occupied like the west side location.No idea why our staff member was so inattentive either. Just not a good experience for our family tonight. read more

Our new spot to go for pizza! We are new to town and excited to have found a great tasting pizza place so quickly. Our go-to is the classic - prices are not bad and my kids love the taste! read more

Had Gallagher's after the Packers game while staying at a hotel close by. The pizza was one of the better ones I have had in quite a while. The hand tossed crust was spot on and the deep dish we ordered had to have weighed at least 5 pounds. A true loaded deep dish that is hard to find where I live (Beau Jo's Mountain Pies here in Colorado are the closest comparison I could make). My only complaint is there is not a Gallagher's 3 blocks from my house back here in Colorado... read more

Their sauce is amazing! Every time I visit from Ohio this is always a great place to stop and have a delicious bite. As far as the pizza and pasta, you can't go wrong here! I haven't tried the fish and a few other things. 5stars on any pizza and pasta read more

The customer service is horrible. HORRIBLE. If they showed just an ounce more of respect, I MIGHT have considered ordering again. It's a shame, the pizza was good but the service made me lose my appetite. read more

This is my favorite pizza place! I have only been to the West And East side locations (sorry De Pere!)and super excited they are opening a location in Suamico!! The pizza, Greek Salad and the philly steak sandwich are my favorite go to items. Oh and, this place NEVER messes up my order. I have no idea how that happens! Dead serious. read more

Had the hand tossed pepporoni onion and jalapeno pizza, and bbq chicken. Both are fantastic. A little char on top, which I like but some may say over done. A little extra bbq sauce for the bbq chicken pizza is a good idea read more

This was actually a really funny experience. It was a Sunday at 2:00 PM, not the most busy of times in the restaurant world, but nonetheless Gallaghers was open so one might expect some service. We walked in the door and stood by the reception desk to be seated. There was an employee on the phone in the back area who stared at us and continued to talk on the phone. She didn't say a word to us. No "I'll be right with you", no hand wave, no nothing. We stood there for probably 3 minutes or so. We then walked out the door and ate somewhere else, having never been acknowledged by the woman talking on the phone. I think there were only 1 or 2 other couples eating the restaurant. With this service (or lack thereof), I wonder when their grand closing will be. read more