One of the best pizza in the GTA... The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside, soft on the…read moreinside--just the way it should be. Their signature pizza sauce is rich, tangy, and layered with flavor, and the toppings are always fresh and generously loaded. If you're into spice, they've got you covered with bold options that bring the heat. The butter chicken pizza and Fajita? Out of this world--creamy, spicy, and totally addictive. The owner clearly cares about quality and community, and it shows in the warm, attentive customer service. You're not just grabbing a pizza--you're being welcomed like family. A definite must if you are around downtown Peterborough...

Best pizza in Peterborough…read more Ordered here a few times now, the donair pizza and poutine is amazing and my favorite! The owner is very friendly and often there, this is definitely a business I feel great supporting!

Ordered online the small lasagna. Was ready within minutes of ordering. When I picked up my order I…read morecould not believe it was a small. The lasagna took up an entire pan tray. Very affordable. As far as the taste, I would say average but very friendly staff, fast, affordable.

on Christmas Eve I ordered on line for two pizzas to be picked up at 5:00 pm. I got my…read moreconfirmation and got on with a busy day ahead. I arrived a little before 5:00 to pick up and found out that the internet was down all day at the restaurant, they hadn't got my order. however without even looking at my online receipt, I was believed and offered an apology and they said they would make my pizzas then and there, and by way of further apology they offered a choice of salad to add to the order free of charge. I might add it was pretty busy at the time. there were plenty of deliveries being picked up by delivery guys as well. I waited the 20 min and noted that the staff were very friendly to the patrons, some of whom seemed to be regulars too. I got the pizzas which were great and enjoyed by all. so thanks to the original spaghetti house , we will be back.

I waited almost 2 hours for my pizza for it to be cold and taste like cardboard..plus I didn't even…read moreget my coke I ordered and paid for. All online. I will never order again from there We all work hard for our money and at least expect a decent pizza I will not refer again or share on Facebook..very disappointed

Just went there for the first time yesterday. I will be going back for sure. Large variety of…read morepizza slices.

$$ Not quite an Italian Pizzeria; highway robbery $$ Good…read morebut not great; no fresh arugula, and a $5 upcharge to have very small cheese and pepper condiments on the table. Our brief discussion with owner was also very disappointing. I'm not going back and I wouldn't recommend you do so either... Perhaps the condiment upcharge can go towards acoustic tile to improve ambiance...

I would contemplate coming to Peterborough just to eat a delicious slice of this thin-crust heaven…read more This place is nestled in between cafes in downtown Peterborough, with a swinging screen door, and a great group of patio tables. Beware - you're not going to get super-friendly service here, or be able to come with a group. It's take out only and things move fast. But don't let that get you down! With delicious options like barbecue chicken, goat cheese with swiss chard, and plain old pepperoni, it kills me that this place is over 3 hours away. I devoured some delicious goat cheese and veggies with an amazing dill and lemon dipping sauce. We sat outside on the patio, which was good because it was super hot inside and there wasn't a lot of space. What space there is is chock full of live-music posters, colourful paint and bar stools. If you're in in, or nearby Peterborough you need to come here.

Pizza. Love the stuff. No matter where i travel, i always seem to find Pizza. Well in…read morePeterborough it was no differnt. Papa Johns is probably the best pizza in town. I know its a US chain, but they got to be a huge company for a reason. Its just good pizza. The crust was good, and not overcoked or too chewy, the toppings were fresh and a decent amount, and the three cheese blend was delish. The delivery was fast, the driver was pleasant, their web site for ordering worked well. Those brownies they have for desert were chocolate perfection. For the two days we were in town this was the favorite meal for both of us. Nothing like going fishing, and coming back to relax and eat pizza while watching the sun go down. Happiness is good pizza.

I love this pizza! They have just the right amount of sauce, with a unique taste - I didn't know a…read morepizza could taste this good ! Fresh toppings, perfect crust, easy ordering, and fast delivery (always before the guaranteed time) makes Papa Johns my top pick and earns my top rating. My only disappoint is that thin crust can only be order on the large..... oh well it is just as good the next day.

Excellent restaurant..food is great Service was great…read moreRestaurant clean and good atmosphere. Recommend highly. Jims pizza is the best

Well. The website says open till 9pm. When we pulled up to park this evening, we were told they…read morewere closing at 8pm. Out of luck. The closing time is dependent on the number of patrons. Another time? Maybe not. Not able to rate as a result.

Great pizza, pretty cheap, they make it insanely quick every time I've ordered even on weekends and…read morestaff is always very nice

Staff is on the ball and get it right every time. Price and quality are good. This is our only go…read moreto pizza place in town.

Was excited to try their pizza as it had high reviews so we ordered through Skip the Dishes a large…read morepepperoni. I found the pizza to be dry, like not enough sauce and the crust was hard. If you want to give Benji's a try, see if you can get it with extra sauce.