Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    First Choice Property Management

    1.0 (5 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Services - First Choice Property Management

    Property management

    First Choice Property Management Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - First Choice Property Management

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of A M.
    0
    1
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - First Choice Property Management

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Muse Realty

    Muse Realty

    (39 reviews)

    I estimate I lost about $25,000 by deciding to have Muse manage my rental property. Over the six…read moreyears I was with them, all three of the tenants they had supposedly vetted, simply stopped paying and/or trashed my house. After realizing in year three how much money I'd lost up until that point (only $11,000 then), I tried to fire them, only to learn that, due to shady contract language, I had to boot out the current tenant in order to get rid of Muse also. Knowing what I know now, I should have kicked them all to the curb then. Instead, my losses were as follows: 1) The first renter just quit paying. It took two months to get him out so, after the deposit, I lost a month's worth of rent that Muse said they sent to Collections but is now too old to get back (around $1,300). 2) My second tenant started having problems paying and, by the time they got her out, they told me she had caused damages totaling around $6,000 - half of which Muse forced me to pay for. Muse also threw away the washer and dryer the renter had broken even though both appliances were covered under warranty and could have been replaced for free, adding another roughly $1,700 in irretrievable losses. 3) After booting the second tenant, I realized Muse had not been increasing rent with every lease renewal as they should have been. At this point, that came to a little over another $5,000 in losses. 3) My third (and final) tenant wrecked my house, leaving behind $14,000 worth of damage. Some of this included such simple things as never replacing the air filters (which meant I had to replace all the ductwork) - something Muse was supposed to be checking for during every six month inspection. I should have walked away on day one when Tami accused me of leaving poop in one of the toilets during the first showing. My mom and I had spent 13 hours the day before making it spotless. Turns out Tami hadn't bothered to check, nor to notify me, that they were letting people into my house, unsupervised, and that one of the potential renters had decided to use the facilities. Things like that have had me working on this review for the entire six years I was with Muse as it was the only thing I felt I had any real control over. I will say that Deborah and Ke'Arah did consistently respond and always made me feel like a valued customer. Everyone else however, bullied me, refused to take responsibility for blatantly obvious errors, or simply ignored me when they didn't feel like responding. The one good thing to come from Muse Realty's continual decline in service over the years was that it forced me to look for another agency. I'm happy to report that I found one that is actually competent and keeps me in the loop. I strongly recommend others look elsewhere as well. Your pocketbook and your sanity will thank you.

    I had the most amazing experience with these people. I had some issues that even they had never run…read moreinto before and they went above and beyond to make me feel comfortable and just taken care of. They were so professional and they ended up helping me get into a better situation than I was in. I ended up getting a bigger house for less money. Thank you to everybody on their team.Corrina,Lane,Tammy,Anna,John, Amanda Beth, Deborah. You guys really are the best!

    Albright Realty

    Albright Realty

    (8 reviews)

    *VERY LONG POST * On Thursday, December 16th, Albright Realty were supposed to send maintenance to…read morecome and fix a major leak in my home. Any time we would try to use the bathtub or shower, there would be a major leak down into the kitchen. (Mind you, I had to put in about 4 requests to get this taken care of.) 4 Caucasian men came to my home on 12/16/21 saying Albright had sent them to check and repair the leak. I am a 5'3 woman and it was just my dog (who's small) and myself here, so we were upstairs for the most part because 1. he gets excited around a lot of people and I didn't want him to get in the way or get hurt and 2. again, I was here alone with 4 large, grown men, so I didn't really feel that comfortable just being down there (and they made a mess, had stuff all over my couch, and there was nowhere to sit). After a while, I realized my dog was getting hot and went downstairs to get his water bowl. As I'm walking down the steps, I notice the tissue paper in the gift bag with my mother's Christmas present looks like it's missing, so I check the present and it's still there unopened with the tissue stuffed at the bottom of the bag. I then look around and noticed a Christmas gift was missing and nowhere around where it should be. I texter my bf and asked him if he had moved it before he left for work and he said he hadn't and it was in the same spot, which is also where his box of jewelry and other sentimental things were. He asked me to check his box for the diamond earrings his mother had passed down to him (given to her by his father, who passed away last year), and they were missing as well. To make an already long story a little shorter: the maintenance men had stolen the present, the earrings, a gold plated bracelet, about $10 in cash, 2 debt and one credit card, and tried to steal some of my medication as well. We got the gift and medication back, but that's it. We later found out some of the people sent to work in our home are KNOWN drug addicts, and I'm not talking about marijuana! The police were called. Not to mention, the leak still didn't get fixed until the next day. And the hole in my kitchen ceiling where they took my cabinets down to get to leak wasn't fixed until 12/22/21 and my kitchen was in disarray until they put my cabinets back up, which they did a shoddy job of and didn't clean after themselves. I had to keep asking about when someone would come to fix the hole and put the cabinets up; so, to add insult to injury, Albright Realty sent one of the same men who was here during the 12/16 incident BACK on 12/21 (with no notice to me) to fix the hole and put the cabinet back up. I assume because he was in the hospital after getting jumped at Ace Hardware (yeah, I know) by the time the missing items were noticed. But we still don't know what he may or may not know or be involved in regarding the theft. However, he didn't stay long because, as I told the property manager before they sent someone back out, the old cabinet was no longer any good and he said he needed to find a new one and left....with the hole still in my ceiling. The carpenter, Jessie Faile, who was part of the maintenance crew, also tried to insinuate my boyfriend and I stole some of his tools, as if WE were not the victims of theft. This has just all been so traumatic and I've been nervous and anxious since. I don't even think I've included EVERYTHING, but my mind is just still whirling. One of the worst experiences of my life.

    Albright manages a property next door to my home. After a shooting occurred, I reached out to see…read moreif they confict Criminal background checks on tenants. I left 3 messages which they never returned.

    First Choice Property Management - propertymgmt - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...