A great selection at reasonable prices; their sales and store recommendations have been superb…read more Although I've moved out of the area, I still return there monthly.

Excellent staff. Very knowledge. Awesome prices & sales. Located near the ferries as well so they…read moredeliver to them! Fantastic service.

We were happy to find this cute wine store today. Nice…read moreselection, decent prices and they had a nice demo today featuring Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc and a consortium of different brands. We bought Relax Riesling, La Crema chardonnay and Kim Crawford Sauvignon, thanks to the nice lady doing the tasting. Looking forward to them bringing in more Rieslings and maybe a few bottles of Gewurztraminer

Nice shop with a decent selection, not a huge amount of product, but enough. Not cheap, but not…read moreoutrageous, it's Southdown, after all. A previous review spoke of how rude the staff is - not my experience. Every time I go in I'm greeted. I find the guys at Huntington Wine Cellar to be friendlier and more helpful than those at Seaholm down the road, and that's a much bigger store. Huntington Wine Cellar also has Fisher's Island Lemonade, that can be a bit hard to find.

Friendly staff with well organized aisles. I think this will be my new liquor store of choice…read more Really good selection to choose from.

Used Pope for over 6 years. Loyal customer who got deliveries for parties, holidays, etc. Called…read morefor a delivery today and it was a nightmare. Was told no delivery today which is fine, asked about tomorrow. Was put on hold and then told I am now outside the delivery area and would have call back, pay extra, and schedule for next Saturday. I explained I've been a customer for many years and I live in Bellport which is not far. The girl on the phone came back at me stating I am 20 minutes away and could call back during the week to discuss it with 'Jim.' Why in the world would a business talk to a long term customer this way?! Was I supposed to call back and beg 'Jim' to let me buy wine from him. I guess they don't need customers. Called Sunwave and had my delivery within an hour and with a better price!

I wanted a bottle of red wine for dinner and all the other liquor stores in the area were closed…read more(approx 9pm). my husband decided to call this location and even though they were closing as well, they stayed open and waited for my husband to get there. Very accommodating! He also stated the place was clean and very nicely organized. We'll definitely be back!

liquor and wine store set up since 1966 year. working hours…read more M to Thurseday 10-8 Friday to Saturday 10-9 Sunday 12-7 store will keep open daily except Christmas Day . welcome Staff and reasonable price . it's good customer service In Long Island , NYC.

Amazing staff! Great pricing Awesome single malt and wine…read moreselection. I found some really hard to find bottles. Ask for Monica!

I've shopped here a few times now, and every visit has been a great experience. Today I was looking…read morefor wine, and the staff was extremely helpful and knowledgeable, offering great recommendations. The store has a wide selection, is well-organized, and the prices are very reasonable. Definitely a spot I'll keep coming back to, and I recommend it to anyone in the area!

This is my new spot they have everything prices are decent. The service was excellent. The ambience…read moreis nice and big very comfortable. If you need something they have it trust me.

I've come to this store a few times now to load up before parties and stuff. Absolutely love the…read moreselection they have. There are so many options, i was honestly very impressed by the selection. They were willing to get me a case of wine I wanted that they don't usually carry. The staff seemed very friendly and helpful. The owner actually is there in person working with the employees and is an absolute sweetheart. The store itself is organized pretty efficiently and I've found it pretty easy to find what I was looking for. Love this place overall and would definitely recommend it!

My name is Jared and I have a problem…read more.. I can't enjoy Whiskey anymore unless it comes straight from a bottle of 1792 Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey. I was leaving my friends house over in Sayville and as I was walking towards the LIRR, a really clean looking hightop van caught my eye in a parking lot across the street (#vanlife). As I crossed the street, I noticed J & J Spirt Shop and walked in out of curiosity. And again, just for curiosity's sake of course... I asked if they carried 1792 Whiskey. Ok to be honest, I actually asked if they carried "1702" Whiskey but they kindly and politely corrected me (I was exhausted so let's call it a brainfart) and quickly presented me with a bottle. I knew I was running low on the bottle I have at home (it lasted me quite a while folks!) and since the price was quite right, I decided to buy one. I was tempted to buy two because again, at 34.99, it felt like a deal. I've actually purchased the same exact 750ml bottle for $40 pre-tax at other stores. There is also a really cool looking cigar shop next door. Had I not been in hurry to catch my train and had one waiting for me at home, I would have certainly stopped in. When I got home, I popped the bottle in the freezer (this probably goes against whiskey code but I like my drinks cold but without ice) and enjoyed it with my cigar. Cigars and Whiskey... yup it's official... I've become my grandpa! Spark notes version: 5 stars for a really clean, local liquor store that has a large selection with good prices and is run by super nice folks

This is my family's go to spot to get wine or alcohol to have at our family get togethers. The…read morestaff is always friendly and helpful. They have a lot to offer for a store that does not seem like it would fit all of the options they have.

walked in & met new owner Danny. very nice guy & super helpful. what else could you ask for . The…read morestore is walkable for me ....and prices are as fair as any where else. I will continue to shop here. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Open past 5 pm on Sundays. It's all that needs to be said. Really appreciate this wine store.read more