Great collections!! Came in here yesterday for the first time and was impressed on how many amazing stuff is here. Vintage barbies, magazines, comics and action figures. Will be back soon! read more

Awesome toy/collectible store. I was actually in the area for something else and I noticed the store driving by. I made a point to stop by afterwards and I'm glad I did. They had just about everything . Comics, toys, action figures, sets etc from every genre as well. Awesome shop. I'll definitely be back with a plan on what to buy read more

See all

Fantastic Toyage is truly revenge of the collectibles!!! Located on Merrick rd in Massapequa, every toy enthusiast should visit this nostalgic store!!! The inventory here is awsome, Alex is super cool & friendly!!! I highly recommend!!! read more

See all

Hope your soul is worth the $435 you robbed me of. You accused me of being dishonest... Self project much? I want my money back for the defective Mattel Vertibird you sold to me for $435.00. I bought this to use and enjoy. I can't do either because you sold me a defective item and refuse to resolve the issue. You made me join Yelp just to tell the truth about how you operate. You tried to pass the Vertibird off as "factory sealed cherry mint". It wasn't, you know it wasn't. please do the right thing and make this right. If not...then these posts remain if you make it right, these posts will be deleted and you will be rightfully praised. Thank you. read more

UNACCEPTABLE!! Avoid at all costs. Never coming here again. The guy here charges ridiculous prices for the Star Wars Power of the Force 3.75 action figures, he wanted $15. $15???????? They also wanted $45 for a DC 6 inch figure. We unfortunately wont be coming here again. Either lower your prices or get better ownership. read more

Unfortunately what started as a nice interaction turned sour pretty fast. I noticed a sealed friday the 13th part vii vhs and the gentleman behind the counter told me he didn't have a price on it. I checked ebay myself and the most recent sales for this item went for $40-50. He quoted me $250, to which I responded by showing him the recent ebay sales for the same thing. He priced the item by checking overpriced ebay sales that hadn't sold and were still on the market. He showed me a currently listed copy for around $240 and I explained that this hadn't sold and the value would be based on what it's currently being sold for. Normally that's how it goes, unfortunately he just responded by saying I wouldn't sell this for $40 and became very standoff-ish and seemed offended by it. I would be careful walking into this store if you don't know your stuff! read more

Fantastic selection. A real store/museum. Plenty of value and rare stuff. Shop one of the best collections on Long Island

I'm a comic book collector and have probably been to a hundred comic books stores. One thing I hate is when I go to stores that carries very old comics and toys, they always seem to be dusty. This toy store is the complete opposite. Not only was it awesome seeing so many cool toys that I had never seen before in my life, I was amazed at how clean this store was. All toys were kept in very good conditions. The statues here were so clean that they looked like they were just taken out of their boxes. read more

Bad customer service, lazy unresponsive owner. Items are overpriced. You're better off going online or visiting someplace that values it's customers. Terrible place all around. read more

Lots and lots of toys, comic character statues, model kits, etc. This place is packed to the rafters with toys!! This is not a place for the thrifty toy hunter though, prices are also as high as the ceiling. read more

Fantastic Toyage - Transformers - Toy Stores Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

Stopped in today this place is seriously the coolest place on earth. Such a fashback to the past. The owner Al is honestly one of the nicest guys I ever met. read more

Walked in and was greeted right away. Owner was very friendly and was very willing to assist us. They had a very vast display of all types of collectibles especially star wars and marvel. Was very impressed with their selection. Store was very neat and organized. Will be going back soon. read more

I would love to come back here under one condition, LOWER YOUR PRICES! :(! I want to love this place. I want to love the awesome selection of vintage toys and figures. They have a huge selection of retro stuff. TMNT, Power Rangers, Star Wars, DC Comics, all really nice stuff. Store is clean, the staff is nice and the products are amazing. They really are! But their prices is what stops this review from getting a 5 Star :(! read more

A really cool place! and the guy that works there (I think he's the owner) was hilarious and very helpful. The place has an excellent selection of classic star wars toys. Sci-fi fans and antique toy collectors - this is a place you have to check out! read more

Fantastic Toyage has a wide range of collectibles ranging from action figures to collectible busts/ movie props replicas. Alex, the owner is very knowledgeable and passionate about collectibles. It's always a please to chat with him. Although a little pricey at times, you get what you pay for in a sense. Everything is very nicely displayed and in a way like going to a museum as you can spend some time looking everything over. Definitely a unique shop! read more

Fun to see everything presented so well, but didn't feel welcome AT ALL. All of the vintage Star Wars toys are marked up 600% or more over eBay prices so it's pretty clear the guy doesn't reeeaaally want to sell it. For example, a loose figure in decent condition sells for $30-50 on eBay but it was $275 here. I suppose most of the stuff is here just let you look. Speaking of which, I got snapped at for taking a picture inside the store. I guess they don't want anyone looking, either... :( read more

Honestly so many collectibles in here it's amazing to see but wow so over priced like fuck. It they had decent pricing I would forsure buy but nope. read more

This place has a perfectly appropriate name. It is absolutely fantastic. If you ever could imagine a toy from any movie, series or comic, it's here and in perfect unopened condition. The amount of toys here is awe inspiring. We're in town from Philadelphia just until tonight. We drove past the store last night and decided that we wanted to check it out. Today we stopped by just before 11am. Sadly, we read that the store was closed. We curiously peeked inside after reading that it opened at noon. The store owner came to the door to ask if we needed anything. He told us that he officially wasn't open, but we could come in and look around... My god. It's amazing in here. I've never seen a better collection of toys, especially still in the packaging. If you're anywhere near here and are interested in old toys, do yourself a favor and check it out. You will not be disappointed. read more

Owner is a complete asshole. Don't buy from here. Overpriced and things have been sitting on shelves for over a decade.

This place is amazing. They've got toys from all eras and all types. The owner is a very kind person and listens to any and all questions you ma'am have. Can't wait to go back!! read more

Came here today looking for a sideshow figure for my friends birthday, this place is awesome toys from all generations. I ended up buying 4 figures yup 4 couldn't pass up the limited and exclusive figures. I will sure as hell he back had a great time talking to the guy who works here he was super friendly think his name was Tom or Tony started with a T lmao read more

Wow what an amazing collection! This guy knows his stuff and his store is seriously stocked!

Absolutely ''fantastic'' store. Where do i start? The second you walk in, you are bombarded with incredible figurines, posters, comics, horror mags,models and assorted collectibles,especially star wars memorabilia!! All offered at more than reasonable prices! Alex, the owner, is an enthusiastic individual, a literal walking encyclopedia of collectible knowledge. He buys and sells collections, offering highly competitive and reasonable prices and buy back rates. If you are searching for something, and he doesnt have it in stock, he will go out of his way to satisfy your buying needs and wants. He always greets you with a smile, it's a pleasure patronizing his store, and i highly recommend this awesome comic/toy warehouse. five stars ***** Frank C read more