Use extreme caution with this shop. This isn't a one-off complaint--it's a pattern I've watched…read moredevelop. My employer and I used this garage for years for routine maintenance with generally acceptable results. Since they opened a second location, the consistency, transparency, and pricing have changed in ways that are hard to overlook. A company vehicle was returned to us with a stripped drain plug and an active oil leak after service. That's not a minor oversight--that's a fundamental failure. Soon after, I requested a quote for front brakes only on a 2021 Hyundai Palisade and was given an estimate of roughly $1,600. I sourced a complete upgraded brake set myself for $397 and completed the job without issue. Draw your own conclusions from that gap. Most recently, I brought in my wife's Subaru for tires, an oil change, and a noise diagnosis. The tires were installed, but the oil change and diagnostic were completely missed. I was told it "wasn't on the work order" and asked to bring the car back. That's a basic process failure. After returning the vehicle, I was told the issue was front wheel bearings and advised to replace both--quoted at approximately $1,000. I purchased the parts myself for $178, and standard labor time for this job is widely understood to be around 1.5 hours per side. When I asked for a clear breakdown of how that estimate was calculated--parts, labor hours, and rate--I was told their system could not provide that level of detail. That answer alone is concerning. If a shop can't explain how a four-figure repair is priced, that's a problem. At this point, the pattern is hard to ignore: Work not completed as requested Pricing that does not align with commonly accepted parts and labor ranges No meaningful transparency when questioned I have no issue paying for quality work. What I will not accept is unclear pricing, missed work, and answers that don't add up. If you're considering this shop, do your homework before approving any repairs. Take a few minutes to verify parts pricing and standard labor expectations. Without that, you may not realize how far off a quote actually is. Based on multiple recent experiences, I will not be returning.

My son's civic was overheating so I brought it into Route 11 to get checked out. I let them know…read morespecifically what diagnostics had been run at a previous shop before my son left for JMU, but they said they had to run (and charge) for their own diagnostics. I get that, so I agreed with the assumption they could resolve the issue. After review, they advised me the wrong coolant was in the car (which I have trouble believing because I've always bought the same coolant and never had an issue), they advised a coolant flush was needed, they said the fans were not working, and they let me know that there was an unrelated power steering leak. Additionally, they recommended I replace the upper and lower radiator hose. They said these were not an issue, but it was probably about time. I agreed to let them do everything except the upper and lower hose being they said they were fine and not leaking. I also agreed to a dye test which included putting dye in the power steering so they could find a leak. All of this was to the tune of roughly $1,000. A few days later they said it was ready and my son picked it up. I asked him what they said about the dye test and he said they did not say anything about. I called the shop and was told, oh yeah, he should bring it back in a few days so we can see if the dye is leaking. Unfortunately, I only found out about this because I called back in. Then a few days later the car was overheating again. My son takes it back and we are told the issue is the upper and lower radiator hoses. I asked how they were fine a few days ago when they were just a "recommendations" (that I declined), but now they are the root cause of the issue. They told me they watched it and now they see after it's been on a long time the hoses swell and leak. The explanation did not sit right with me, but I'm hours away and my 18 year old son needs his car so I let them do it for another $350. However, unfortunately again, my son drives 4 hours home a few days later and the car overheats. The shop texted me and called me that day asking how it was going and wanting me to come back and get some other work done. I responded it wasn't going well and the car was overheating still. I sent them photos of the coolant under the hood, but they stopped responding. I took it to a shop locally and they diagnosed it as a bad thermostat and the car has run smooth since. I wanted to like this shop as my brother recommended them, but unfortunately I cannot recommend them as the customer service is lacking. I'd advise to find a different shop for your car repairs.

In luray for vacation and my car dies mid trip - recipe for disaster. I call Tom's as soon as they…read moreopen the next morning and they say they can look at it it but they arent sure they can fit in any major repairs that day. I get there, they diagnose i need new plug and coil....within 90 minutes they have the parts delivered and the car fixed. Thanks for saving my trip!

Very good service. Price is outstanding. Did a exhaust repair for $40 and that was 3 yrs ago and no…read moreissues since. Highly recommended

he charge more than the usual I into the tire on the website just between $70-$80 but charged me…read more$169 for the tire. Just the reason is just because I my car wash on the highway and I need to fix the tire that's all and saw the situation like this he take more than hundred dollars more than the price

I am traveling and had a major issue with my car. Thought the alignment was out. Needed help asap…read more Called here and Phil got me in right away. Checked the alignment, not the problem, had tire damage and needed new tires. He ordered them and installed them the next morning. He's my hero! Minimal disruption to my trip all things considered. Got a chance to have a great breakfast and walk around this cool town waiting for my tires. All good!

Tony and Branden are dishonest and do shady work. Tony at…read moreBennett and Butler took $3000 upfront to fix body work on my car and promised I would have the car back fully fixed and painted within six months. After 25 months of lies, I got my car back in worse shape then when Tony and Branden took it and they stole the $3,000. Buyers beware when doing business with Bennett and Butler. Things may not be what they seem.

Our car broke down in Shenandoah National Park and they came to our rescue! They went above and…read morebeyond to give us a timely tow, maintaining constant communication and quality care and professionalism. They also diagnosed the issue in our car and drove 2 hours to get the necessary part for the repair. They stayed open late on a Saturday when no other auto shops were open to make sure that our car was repaired and we could leave town the next day as planned. Extremely kind and generous people who took care of us in a time of need. Would recommend to everyone for excellent care and auto repair service!

Respectful, attentive, and thorough. Twice I've taken two different vehicles to Shenandoah…read moreAutomative (a 2017 Silverado and a 2020 Pilot) with issues that other automotive service centers "couldn't replicate." The techs at Shenandoah Automotive listened to my description of the problem and conferred with a network of other techs to which they are connected and diagnosed and fixed the issues. There may be other outstanding automotive service centers in Harrisonburg or the Shenandoah Valley, but it will be a long time before I find out who they are. I'm sticking with Shenandoah Automative.

They are so helpful and kind. My sons car broke down as he drove to FL from college in PA. Not…read moreworth fixing so we donated it to Make-A-Wish. This repair shop were great to work with and very fair pricing.

Top marks for honesty, hospitality, flexibility and helpfulness. On a cross-country trip, a semi…read morelost a tire right in front of us, shredding the fascia on our bumper. Called from the road and Autobody Pro said to stop right in and they'd check to see if it should be removed or what. Friendly front counter staff and both mechanics got us on our way with a candid evaluation--it'll make it out West, but replace it--and a bunch of strategic zip ties. They refused to take any money. If you're in the Harrisonburg area, Autobody Pro ought to be a top choice for collision and bodywork. Just great folks to deal with.

So writing this review based on my customer service with Stephen. My vehicle was taken to his shop…read morefor possible repairs . It turns out it was totaled, so while waiting for insurance to process the claim, Stephen was a true professional. Alway took my calls , and provided updates. He even mailed my plates back to my home. I appreciate his great customer service skills and true professionalism. Keep up the great work!!

We broke down around 8 pm on 81 and hobbled into Woodstock and got a hotel and called them early…read morein the morning and they fixed us up (alternator) and we were on our by 4. Very pleased.

Great service, very friendly and knowledgeable. I'll continue taking my vehicle here to get…read moreinspected.

This a review for the service Dept. I have bought several auto's here and The last one I bought…read moreneeded inspection and oil change so I waited on it. It took a long time 1 1/2 hr. Then the Service desk lady said it was done. But needed new tires and that mine were pretty bad. Well how did it pass inspection then. She said it barely passed. She offered to sell me some budget tires for $80 ea. Which is too cheap for good tires on my SUV. So I went to a tire dealer I deal with often in Harrisonburg. And he said my tires were fine. He could have sold me $600 to,$800 set of tires, but was honest. So now I wonder if they even changed my oil and Actually inspected it. Lost confidence. Probably my last service trip.

Bought 8 Subarus from them always satisfying service and sales. Since 2007 only car I've owned and…read moreonly one I'll ever buy