Amazing and unique vintage furniture like I've never seen anywhere else - wild old signs, vintage…read morefurnishings and architectural pieces galore!! It's like Brimfield for the other 51 weeks of the year :) I love this place!! My wife and I are flying back to NY for the Mary Randolph Carter book signing on Saturday and we can't wait to check out the new inventory too!! Check out the pics of some of their inventory on Facebook - simply amazing stuff: https://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Hudson-Mercantile/596920753717378 Need a 12-foot sign that says 'A-OK' ? Or, hand colored, poured concrete molds of Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum's heads to use for bookends in your loft? Guess where you can find both? This place rocks!!

From the owner: A unique and unusual collection of antique and vintage furniture art and accessoriesread more

If you have a mini vacay in Woodstock or you're a local like I am and want to find some unique…read morefinds, don't pass up the chance to indulge in some thrift retail therapy at the long-standing Castaways on Mill Hill Rd. The space isn't huge- but the options are almost endless and exciting here. If you're the type who loves vintage at thrift prices, you'll bring those vintage finds back to life. I recently found two white quartz(?) bookends at $6ea that may seem small- but they're heavy AF. Prior to that, I've found small catch-all trays or other items. The staff is always friendly and willing to answer any of your questions about anything. So whether you want a nostalgic vintage cardigan, a vase, tea set, this or maybe that, Castaways is one of the best thrift+ vintage shops in Woodstock that won't disappoint you.

I am a long-time customer at Castaways. I've always enjoyed the environment, the noninvasive yet…read morehelpful nature of the staff, as well as the selection of clothing and jewelry. Normally I would give the store five stars. However, my most recent experience shopping there was less than pleasant. In fact, it was notably strange. Upon entering the store my friends and I were greeted by an employee that I had never seen before. She gave us a rundown of the store while we were looking around and I politely told her that we had been there before and didn't need to be told where and what things were. That was excusable. However, the experience got stranger. I was looking through a box and found a loose pair of pantyhose that I was thinking about purchasing. The employee entered the other room where my friends and I were Coincidentally, I picked up my bag and the pantyhose and went over to another section at the same time she was entering. In doing that I think I may have set off a shoplifting alarm in her head. Without asking, she picked up the pantyhose next to my bag and told us that she was going to put them up front. I protested because I wasn't sure if I wanted her to do that. She proceeded to tell me in somewhat of a scolding tone that she was going to bring them up front (regardless of my protests) and that they should have been left in their packaging (there was no packaging). After this encounter, she kept her eye on us consistently. I tried on two dresses and she interrupted my conversation to ask me a question about the dress I had on. She also asked loudly if anyone was in the dressing room as I was clearly changing in there. I found this whole experience strange and frankly invasive. I also felt singled out because of some unfounded (and obvious) suspicion. I do enjoy Castaways and I have been a long-time patron. However, I am reluctant to go in the store again because I would not like to have another encounter like the one I had today.

This consignment boutique is a treasure trove of reasonably priced items! You can find anything…read morefrom vintage fur coats to cute, inexpensive gently used houseware, costume jewelry, bags, clothes, shoes, and more! I stopped in on 12/18/25 because I was in the area with time to kill. They were having a sale and on top of that all Christmas items were additionally marked down! I found enough plastic ornaments to make a holiday wreath I saw on Pinterest! They were ten cents each! I also scored beautiful cream wool placemats with the word Noel embroidered in silver metallic thread and surrounded by beads! The staff is so friendly, helpful, and happy! We came here once before to see if we could find six cocktail glasses and were rewarded with a big selection of sizes, styles, and price range! We will definitely be back the next time we need something! I grew up thrifting and now my daughter has grown up thrifting as well! Highly recommend Treasures Consignment Boutique!

Treasures is indeed a treasure. I needed a sport jacket for an event and found the right item in…read morethe right size at the right price. This in comparison to a couple of other thrift stores I shopped that had a smaller selection and less well organized... at Treasures each jacket was marked with the size, a huge time saver. On impulse I also bought a spice rack organizer which leads to a cautionary tale about shopping at thrift shops. After a good amount of time trying to assemble it I realized that pieces were missing. Hopefully this was an inadvertent error on the part of the donor in gifting what was essentially a worthless item. Can't blame Treasures because they can't be expected to open and examine every $10 item. Still 5 stars in my book. Also: they have a Dutch auction system where certain things get markdowns on predetermined dates. So if you want to take your chances, you may get that desired item even cheaper.... or, it may be sold out from under you. But that's Saratoga for you.

Such a nice guy who runs the place. So patient with his customers and all around so genuine. Cool…read moreold school items and collectables.

Love this place! Nice selection of vinyl records, vintage and retro toys. Very cool. Will be back…read moresoon!

Beautiful thrift store. So many high-quality items. The clothes are clean, ironed, And well…read moreorganized. Staff is very friendly. I happen to hit their end of summer sale. Everything was priced at two dollars Banana Republic, Talbots, Ralph Lauren. Some were even new with tags... All their merch looked new.

This boutique is well laid out, and the displays are attractive and outstanding. I felt like the…read moreclothes I was donating would be treated we'll and put to good use.

There's a bad selection of items, the items are overpriced and the costumer service is terrible.read more

Great consignment shop with wide array of items. Friendly, knowledgeable staff. From household to…read morebric a crac, jewelry to coats!

I've been a loyal customer with an account with this business for the last 10 years. But as of the…read morelast two years the feeling and image has changed. Last 5 times I've gone in to consignment - appropriate nice items (seasonal, clean/used once/ name brand/ unique) I have been turned down. With a little snarkiness from cashiers each time. My items are just as good or better then flannel shirts missing buttons with holes And safety pins. I feel befuddled... buying a pair of Guess shoes with the leather wearing out on the inside..... to make the point! This is the first review I ve ever made .... Please go back to the original conceptual feeling of your business. Buying into only major brands and stock makes this like every place else, and unflattering to people like myself that love coming to your store for something unique and politeness.

Pretty cool place. A good deal of the clothing is over priced and lots of retail merch mixed in. Be…read moreaware of their consignment policies-they are far more in the favor of the store.

I brought 12 items to consign that no longer bring me "joy" including an original watercolor and…read morea collectible NY Yankee Don Mattingly figurine. My family was not interested in any of the items. Mary, one of the owners, reviewed the items and accepted them all to put on sale in the shop. 50 percent of selling price goes to the consigner. Mary and her partner Jennifer are knowledgeable about the secondary market, marketing, and customer service. They run a great shop and a well organized website. They have a new larger location on Charlton Road across the street from Charlton Tavern. Check out their website for hours. Best wishes for continued success in their new location! Consign and Recycle!

Nice place to browse although they didn't seem to have too many items. Watch yourself as you walk…read morearound as the floors are old, crack and one spot seemed like it was going to take my foot. Very helpful and friendly staff. Make sure you go to their brew location, I don't think Yelp map is up to date yet with their new location.

wonderful little local shop full of cute and sophisticated clothing and accessories. perfect little…read moresetting too. we love it. and the owner is so nice

One of my favorite "second time around" shops. The inventory changes often so be sure to stop back…read moreon a regular basis. The owner is very creative with her window displays, the prices are very good and its always a pleasure to shop there.