Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Edithburgh Hotel

    5.0 (1 review)

    Edithburgh Hotel Photos

    EDITHBURGH HOTEL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    Recommended Reviews - Edithburgh Hotel

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Balhannah Hotel

    Balhannah Hotel

    4.3(12 reviews)
    98.9 km
    $$

    Here are a couple of versions you can use depending on where you're posting. Both keep the key…read morepoints you mentioned. *Version 1 - Google/TripAdvisor style* *Balhannah Hotel - 0 stars* Worst dining experience I've ever had. The food is consistently undercooked. We ordered steak _well done, no blood_ and had to send it back 3 times. Each time it came out raw with blood running across the plate. Staff shrugged and said "steak is cooked with blood coming out, it's natural". Hygiene is non-existent - 0/10. The waitress had her fingers all over the food when she brought the plate out. After all the back-and-forth to the kitchen, we both got sick. It genuinely felt like something was done to the food. The staff stand around gossiping about customers loud enough for everyone to hear. When we raised the issues politely, we were treated like rubbish. To top it off, I received an aggressive, insulting email from the manager/owner saying we are no longer welcome, just for complaining about raw food and poor hygiene. *Food*: Undercooked, unsafe *Service*: Rude, unprofessional, gossipy *Hygiene*: Disgusting - staff touching food *Management*: Hostile and unaccountable Avoid at all costs. Made us sick and then banned us for speaking up.

    This was another one of those delightful country pubs, though it is sort of more like a pub that…read moreyou get in the Adelaide hills, which means that it is in one of the more leafy parts of the city in that it is regional, but not quite. Anyway, they had a nice beer on tap, which I certainly did appreciate, and the service wasn't too bad either. They also have quite a decent sized beer garden, but we ended up spending most of our time in the front bar, which was quiet, and really nice as well.

    Photos
    Balhannah Hotel - One of 2 fireplaces in the main dining room.

    One of 2 fireplaces in the main dining room.

    Balhannah Hotel - Outside

    Outside

    Balhannah Hotel

    See all

    Three Brothers Arms Hotel - Outside

    Three Brothers Arms Hotel

    5.0(2 reviews)
    99.7 km

    This pub was nothing short of awesome, but that had a lot to do with the atmosphere. In a way it…read morefelt a lot more hip and laid back that many of the other country pubs that I have visited, though in a way it did sort of have some British feel about it. Like, it had some awesome beers on tap, the service was wonderful, and not only that but there was a huge beer garden out the back as well. Honestly, I have to say that I really did love this place.

    The Three Brothers Arms is not just a pub. It is a hell of a restaurant, a laid-back pub with live…read moremusic, and a great place to chill. It's hard to pin down the ambiance as the areas of the Hotel differ; all in a good way. The "BAAA" is a great example of rural Australian bars: happy and inviting with live bands often playing. Meanwhile, it's eclectic and relaxed in the penny bar area, and the beer garden has a family friendly vibe. The standout for me on this visit was the dining area. It's relaxed but more restaurant than pub-like; in a good way. The service was very good, the staff friendly and prompt. But the best thing was the food. As long as you are happy to go beyond today's typical Australia pub food, and instead try some gourmet style traditional pub food. I had the slow cooked lamb shoulder with vegetables and light jus, while my partner went for the Mediterranean Chicken salad. Both were excellent, but the lamb was next level. Despite being well satisfied we could not resist the sticky date pudding. And we weee both happy we did not. Great experience all-round. The prices are higher than pub meals, but for that you get gourmet food that you will remember for a long time. Worth the little extra for sure.

    Photos
    Three Brothers Arms Hotel - Outside

    Outside

    Three Brothers Arms Hotel - Stage

    Stage

    Three Brothers Arms Hotel - Displays

    See all

    Displays

    The Duck - View from Venue

    The Duck

    3.5(18 reviews)
    80.3 km
    $$

    Unless you have a car, this is a pretty difficult pub to get to. In a way it is sort of like a…read morecountry pub, though not your typical country pub, but rather one that you would find in England. I wouldn't necessarily call it classy, but it has an atmosphere of being a place for semi-special occassions. They have a pretty decent selection of beers, and the surroundings do make you feel as if you were in the English countryside. Mind you, it is pretty popular, and a little pricier than what you would expect.

    Appearances can be decieving, although this pub nestled in Coromandel Valley would appear to be an…read moreold relic of the bygone era with its red brick exterior, wide verandah, worn floorboards and huge log fireplaces - but the pub is only a few decades old yet retains the "old" pub feel. As the trend for pubs which look like fancy bars and fancier restaurants continues, its nice to walk into a pub with a solid wooden bar, well worn chesterfields in the front bar and fairly simple wooden tables in the restaurant expect the traditional as well; chicken schnittys, fish and chips - the works. The Duck Inn also has a great range of beers and ciders. Adelaide Hills cider has been on tap here since you could tap their kegs and their local range is superb for a small pub. Like most pubs, the Duck Inn does have pokies, but you can't hear them in the restaurant and the noise level in the bar is minimal. I'd opt for the Duck Inn on a lazy day and to sit in the Front bar next to the fire on the big couches with some beer and chips and spend your day doing not quite a lot.

    Photos
    The Duck - Sundae ~ Dessert

    Sundae ~ Dessert

    The Duck - Bar

    Bar

    The Duck - Venue

    See all

    Venue

    Edithburgh Hotel - pubs - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...