We stayed at Summer Creek Inn in June and loved it! The place is beautiful, the room was so nicely…read moredecorated and the linens and bed were so comfortable! The grounds are so lush and they have an amazing waterfall that is so soothing! It's obvious they spend a great amount of time keeping everything so lovely! The homemade breakfasts were AMAZING, so delicious! Nancy is a great cook! We also enjoyed talking with the others guests at breakfast. We found the owners Nancy and Dan to be very friendly, knowledgeable and very engaging! If we make it back to the area we will make sure we stay with them again!

Host and hostess are special and very accommodating. The premises are comfortable and clean. We…read morereally enjoyed our stay and the breakfasts. Well worth the visit.

The room was very nice, clean, and comfortable, and the breakfast was excellent. However, what…read moretruly made our stay memorable were the three outstanding young ladies working here: Mary, Gabrielle, and Yanna. During our trip, we met many wonderful people, but these three stood out above everyone else. Their friendliness, professionalism, and genuine warmth made us feel welcome from the moment we arrived. They consistently went above and beyond and always greeted us with a smile. Comfort Inn deserves tremendous credit for having such exceptional employees. Mary, Gabrielle, and Yanna transformed what would have been a very good four-star stay into a ten-star experience. They are a tremendous asset to your hotel, and we hope their hard work and dedication receive the recognition they deserve.

Guaranteed room rates not guaranteed. When I made my reservation my room was more $$ than the…read morerates shown when checking in. Inquired with clerk at check-in who had an excuse for rate differences. Hot tub was colder than pool. Showers are extremely slippery with no slip resistant mats. Break was your standard meh- dehydrated scrambled eggs, etc no dairy free or gluten free options

What a nice place! When my wife and I first opened the door to our room it smelled clean! That is…read moresuch a reassuring feeling because if you traveled long enough you know what it's like when you stay at a place that smells stale. Ayus (sorry, I don't know how to spell his name) and his wife are so kind! My wife and I didn't have a ride to Rapid City to get our rental car. Ayus and his wife drove us into town to a mechanic to rent a car. When the shop was closed they called their friend who agreed to drive us. I don't know what we would have did if we didn't get that ride. Ayus and his wife keep the place clean. The gardens are well kept and it is a peaceful sitting outside. They always have coffee, snacks, and fruit waiting for when you wake up. It has the feel like you took a walk back in time to the 50s. It was really cool!

Tucked away (and I mean "tucked" away) in Newcastle, you'll find your stay for the evening. Don't…read moreget discouraged if you can't find it right away. It's there. I eventually found it. Of course, I wasn't using GPS like you are, so it took me a bit longer. Tucked away means quiet and quiet it was. Birds chirping were the only sounds I heard when I opened the car door. That's a good sign if you're looking for quiet. I checked in and was given room #13. Yes, it ran through my mind, uh oh, unlucky number 13. But doom and gloom weren't in the cards for me. Quite the contrary. Number 13 was exceptionally clean and comfortable. My host was friendly and helpful when it came to suggesting a place for dinner. Though trying to follow his directions found me at an oil refinery. LoL! Again, no GPS. I eventually backtracked and ended up where I started to. Quick Tip: At your next stop at a store, pick up some cheap double AA batteries and shove them into your suitcase. You'll be glad you did when your remote for the TV doesn't work. No having to go through the hassle of getting dressed and making your way to the front desk or waiting for maintenance to get to your room. Just pop them in, and you're set. As I had to do at The Pines. It didn't take but a minute before I could watch the mindless dribble which spewed forth. Oh, don't forget to pull your batteries before you leave. You'll undoubtedly need them down the road.

This was our first time staying in Hill City and We're glad we picked this location. Its around…read morethe corner from the 1880 Train station which takes you to Keystone. Parking was plentiful at the front of the hotel. As we entered the lobby Sara immediately greeted us with a smile. The lobby was very spacious and inviting as we entered with sofas to the left and tables and chairs to the right. Our room, #307, was clean, spacious and comfortable. It faced the front of the hotel so we were able to see the 1880 train come and go when we were in the room. The hotel offers an excellent breakfast for their guests! Coffee was available in the lobby all day and night. The staff at this hotel were amazing! Not once did I see a staff member hesitate when it came to helping us or another customer. Thru-out our week stay here Mario and Sara made us feel welcome whenever we passed their lobby desk. Thank you! We definitely would stay here again!

1980's motel with few upgrades. Worn furniture. Very limited breakfast, bad coffee, orange juice…read moredispenser put out some kind of weak light orange water.

My hunting partners and I have stopped several times over the last few years. We've had our deer…read moreand antelope processed here. They do a great job at a more than reasonable price. They also have a taxidermist. Rocky Top Taxidermy. I've gotten a European mount done, and my friends have had shoulder mounts. They do an awesome job.

I'll start my review by giving 5 's!!! From the very moment…read morewe arrived for our stay at the lodge during our 5 day hunt trip, we were treated like family. More like kings! Hospitality was over the top. Twyla and Larry the owners of this historical landmark are two of the most amazing people. Didn't think it could get better than the first day until the next day arrived and was amazed to see it would get even better. Breakfast, lunch and dinner was top notch! Amazing!! They truly work very hard to make sure your stay is memorable. You could spend the day just fooling around looking at the amazing sites or stay in the lodge and look at amazement at the fish and wildlife their family have taken over the years in their own backyard. What a paradise. I have made two new life friends and will definitely be returning very soon. Thank you Twyla and Larry for an amazing time Chris B

Very clean, great bedding and spacious bathroom. The a/c was super loud and wifi didnt work…read more We were not informed about breakfast which according to my reservation, was included

I give Sage motel a lot of credit for being the only place in Newcastle that was able to provide…read morelast minute availability. Without the Sage motel, I would have been forced to sleep in my car for the evening in an area that I'm completely unfamiliar with. And the price couldn't be beat! The cons: No pets allowed. No breakfast offered. I did not see an ice machine. Overall, it's not a bad place to stay for a night.

This is our third time staying at the Hilltop and this time our stay was perfect. The rooms are…read morenewly remodeled, bright, airy and clean. The price is amazing, about 30%-50% less than what other hotels in Newcastle are charging. And if you want a hotel room right in the Black Hills, say in Custer (37 mi away), expect to pay 4X as much. Newcastle is right between Devil's Tower (WY) and Mount Rushmore (SD), so it is the perfect location for all your Black Hills site seeing. Yes, this is an older hotel, built in the 40's or 50's and the rooms are small. But they are spotlessly clean. The tub has an 11-jet Jacuzzi, the perfect thing after day of hiking the trails and seeing the sites in the Black Hills. There's a small kitchen area with a table, 2 chairs, a bench, a small fridge (that actually freezes ice!) and a microwave. No phone, but there's TV, WiFi and plenty of plug outlets to charge all your electronics. The only thing this room lacks is hangers, so bring a few with you. If you've read negative reviews about the Hilltop, check the date. It is true that under the former owners the rooms were often not clean and with worn carpet and dark paneling, the room seem closed and dingy. But now, under new ownership, this is an ideal place to stay.

Didn't stay here. Nasty owner. GPS took me to the wrong motel. I was registered with the Sage…read moreMotel 300 feet away. I called a phone number on the door of the Hilltop Inn. The owner of Hilltop said, "You should learn to read." Then laughed and hung up on me. Luckily the owner of the Sage Motel was very kind. The Sage Motel is beautiful on the outside! The Sage Motel has great WIFI and many charging ports. Beautiful king sized bed. I highly recommend driving past the Hilltop Motel to the Sage Motel. Locally owned. Refreshing attitude and service.

Our room looked like it had been converted from a storage room or something. It was really loud,…read morecould hear people running up and down hallways until midnight. Room was also next to where they served breakfast, so at around 6 am you could hear them preparing for the morning meal. Lots of clunking and slamming things. Shower head leaked like a sieve, so it made for an interesting shower. Place was neat and clean, just REALLY LOUD. Things might have been different if it wasn't for that weird room we had? After stopping at the Holiday Inn Express in Mitchell, I looked to see what that room was here....sure enough, it was storage and restrooms. If they try and give you room 125, RUN.

All though the price is on the high end, I have to say I am more than happy to pay it!…read more The front desk woman is amazing, I wish I knew her name. She has a rose tattoo on her right forearm and she has a GREAT attitude. Our boxer dog even took two treats from her. && Kenya doesn't even like treats! The rooms are clean, beds are comfy and I am sure breakfast will be awesome. I would recommend this place.

Terrible experience, in town doing work, fur as didn't work in my cabin she told me two days in a…read morerow I didn't know how to run the thermostat, (I'm an electrician I know how to run a thermostat) my dogs and I ended up getting sick, I went to the hospital where I was treated for carbon monoxide poisoning, the owner is an absolute crook, told me she would prorate my stay costs and refund the money (I gave her 1800) called her a month later and she told me I can kiss her ass .. total crook

I really enjoyed my stay at this cute little place up on the hill. I was fortunate to secure the…read morelast cabin available for the night. The proprietor was super friendly and helpful when I arrived. She was super laidback and made sure I felt comfortable. The cabin was cute with the perfect rustic charm. The price was very reasonable especially given that you get your own cabin. It was not fancy but super comfy and homey. I highly recommend staying here if you find yourself needing accommodations in the area.