Not sure if it was a one off scenario, but the pizza slices I ordered to go were not very tasty…read more The BBQ chicken had hardly any flavor and I found it hard to believe honestly. Plain slice I tried tasted bland and sauce tasted like it was prepared quickly and missing spices. I hate to give mediocre reviews for local pizza spots, and would really like to give them another chance but for now, it's average at best to me.

We've been a customer of Villaggio for some time and have been satisfied. That just ended tonight…read more In addition to the pie we ordered, we also ordered "fried zucchini" IT WAS HORRIBLE! Burnt and mushy and not placed in a take out container! How can anyone working there let this garbage out the door is beyond comprehension! Never going back there!!

Giving this 5 stars for the grandma and chicken parm square pizza and the super hard working staff…read more We ordered take out on a Friday night and it was very busy so I knew we were in for a really good pizza. The sauce on the pizza was really good and the well done thin crust was so good. They also have a dining area- with servers if you what to dine in. Planning on trying there dinner entrees next time.

We were here visiting and this place was recommended to us. We were somewhat disappointed! We live…read moreon the West coast so always look forward to East coast pie. We tried their Grandma's pizza as years ago I had a fantastic one from another Jersey joint. This one was nothing special. I would venture to try another place next time.

Food was not good, portions are NOT proportionate to price, not good at all!…read moreIn fairness we gave it 2 chances. First experience: We ordered 3 pizzas, I don't think there was a tablespoon of sauce on all three pies combined! Driest pizza I ever ate. The Sicilian pizza had almost zero sauce on it, and the crust was terrible. It was not crusty at all and it had the texture of wonder bread or angel Food cake. Sadly it was terrible. The two regular pies also had barely any sauce, and the crust was mushy and doughy, tasted like a microwaved pita. They charged $25.00 for a small pizza maybe 12-14" or so, and there was a 2" wide crust around the entire pizza. They plop the toppings in the center, obviously they are skimping on toppings and capitalizing on the up charge. 2nd experience: no change, food was not good, dry pizza, dinners were mediocre at best. Just not buying the overpriced hype of this place.

The last 3 pizzas I ordered were totally undrtcooked..raw dough. It is a shame because if cooked…read morelonger would have been fine. Reading reviews this seems to be a recurring problem. Also ordered chicken fingers..$14.99 for 3 small pieces. Ridiculous!!

Great antipasto salad and pie. I think we were the last delivery because the pizza was cold. But,…read moreit was delicious.

This truly is the best pizza in the area...It's a complete bonus that they're always so kind tooread more

We got a really nice pizza delivery the other night. The kids of course wanted plain cheese and…read morethe adults got pepperoni and sausage. The pizza is light, thinner and has a nice sauce with a good salty cheese. The pepperoni didn't make it too greasy. The sausage was very good, they use the crumble kind, instead of slices. The kids loved their cheese pizza. It was destroyed soon after arrival. We used the Slice App and the food came hot and fast. What more could you want?

First time ordering here since we have had our summer house in Barnegat. This was absolutely…read morefantastic, the flavor of the vodka sauce and the thin chicken cutlets were amazing. The food came hot and fresh as well. We also had a roast pork, broccoli rabe, provolone and chipotle sauce panini on focaccia. This was amazing as well, will be ordering from here from now on.

Had a great experience as first timers! The bartender was great, very attentive and made us feel…read morewelcome. Best French onion I have ever had (although it's called something else on the menu). The pizza, which we ordered traditional style was absolutely delicious. Prices were fair. We will be back!

Had a very enjoyable dinner with friends at East Bay Italian Grill on Saturday evening. We were…read morepromptly seated at our reservation time and the restaurant was packed. The service was very pleasant and we were taken care of throughout our meal. The calamari and zucchini flowers are always a treat, as are the Flounder francese, Rigatoni Bolognese and Chicken and Shrimp ala vodka just to name a few. Live music in the background is also enjoyable. Highly recommend you check it out.

Actually it was take out and I felt like their most important customer there was a crowd picking up…read moretake out but the 3 young women working reception were knowledgeable and fast. And the Flounder Franchise was fabulous, the best I have ever had.

Just ordered chicken cacciatore from this location. Not so good the food smelled burnt yet the food…read morewasn't. That includes the broccoli rabe how can that be. And, the chicken was cubes were hard. How can that be it's chicken cacciatore the basing of the chicken should make the chicken soft. Just not good. We had pizza here before and the pizza is great. However, this meal was not up to par.

First time trying this pizza and we were pleasantly surprised. We had it delivered and it arrived…read morehot and fresh. We ordered: -large cheese pizza -large pepperoni pizza -large white pizza Our favorite was the plain cheese pie. Can't wait to try their deep dish pizza next. It was even delivered earlier than expected. Great service. Definitely recommend!

Picked up t bring home. Pizza and mozzarella sticks were great!!…read moreWould recommend and will return when in the area again.

Closed permanently............. was best square around. Shame he decided to close without notice to…read morerun his other in seaside. Good luck.

Ok so the food here is amazing. Waretown needed a good pizzeria & this is it. I ordered a margarita…read morepizza and a vegatble stromboli. Both were really good. The crust on pizza was perfect and it had such a good taste. Also the stromboli was really good too. The staff is very welcoming and friendly so overall I would recommend this pizzeria to everyone.