Fantastic show. Great buffet. Our family loved Oklahoma. Ado Annie stole the show. Lori and Curly were better than the original movie!

Show started at 7:30pm - we arrived at 5:40pm (doors open at 6pm) but was seated as soon as we arrived. Food was hot and fresh - the server was friendly but not attentive. Theatre was warm but I honestly think it was due to the sell out crowd. Due to the table set up - you felt close to everyone around you. It doesn't make sense that the tables do not face the stage - it makes it uncomfortable. We were seated with ppl not in our party - they were friendly but not enough space. The play was great - live music was a fun edition. Overall a good experience and will definitely come again. We will just be more strategic where we sit. read more

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre - Performing Arts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We went to see Buddy, based on the story of Buddy Holly. The show was amazing! The food was standard buffet. I wasn't a fan of the hot food, but the salad bar and deserts were nice. Book early, if you don't want to have to share a table with someone else. Otherwise, you will. Also, the demographic is an older crowd. I am in my 50s, and felt like a spring chicken. Not that it matters, just for informational purposes only. I did not have one word with our server, yet we had to fill out a survey and of course, leave a tip. I wish the service could've been more personable. read more

What an amazing time! This theater easily is the best regional I have ever seen. I honestly did not feel like I was watching a regional theater production. I have seen a lot of regional Theatre and this just takes the cake, literally of course, because I had cake for dessert! My wife reminisced has when this production was briefly on Broadway and she said it looked and sounded exactly the same! The energy from the performers, music, the sets, the use of projections, and everything else about this production of Buddy was fabulous! I honestly am a huge theater snob and I'm not ashamed to admit it. This theater though showed me that they can be Broadway like regional Theatre in the place where you at would least expect it. Now, with any review comes a little bit of negative. I took the package deal with the Heritage hotel. I appreciate the convenience of walking to the theater in one minute, but the hotel is in severe need of renovating. There are signs that they are renovating and I was told that they are so I am sure once it's done, it will get the TLC it needs. Also, it was nice that they gave you a breakfast buffet at the hotel the next morning with the package, but unfortunately, the food was a huge letdown. We were so hungry after the bad breakfast that we went to Arby's. As for the food in the theater, it was okay. To save money, they recently did away with the prime rib, carving station. I do not agree with that, but if we want them to stay around, I guess they have to do this. The salad bar was very impressive as was the dessert tables, including the ice cream area. There is definitely enough of a variety of food to tickle anyone's palette. It's just unfortunate that some of the food was bland but still edible. I look forward to returning to this theater and seeing some other shows, and I especially like the fact that the menu changes for every show. Hopefully, the Hotel renovations won't take long, and hopefully they will improve the awful breakfast buffet. On a sidenote, I don't think it was fair to have one server doing the entire breakfast buffet by herself she was overworked and running around like crazy. Some other reviews mentioned the small table space. I disagree with that as we were at a table of four and had plenty of room, even with two other people sitting across from us. I wish I could remember the waiter's name, but he was absolutely phenomenal! He assured that we had constant iced tea and water refills and as soon as intermission came, he was out with more. Thank you, Dutch Apple dinner theater for showing us what real regional Theatre is all about! There is a professional theater in our town in New York and I thought they were good until we went to the Dutch Apple Theatre. read more

This place is always a great time. Family owned and great staff. I suggest signing up to their email list and get tickets to a show you like as soon as they are announced. I can't wait to go back again. read more

Visited this theatre first on a field trip with my sons school. Loved it so much, I decided to book a show for my birthday. It was even better! We booked a Thursday night so dinner was served to us instead of a buffet. Food was phenomenal, drinks were super good and staff was amazing! The show itself was incredible, as it was the first time, can't wait to go back next year, already have my tock read more

See all

Always good food, friendly staff and great productions. The food was very hot tonight, the soup was lukewarm. Good selection of entrees, average salad bar. The dinner rolls were greatly downsized as compared to 2025. There was no coffee service, which had been offered for all of the past 15 years I have attended. read more

Took my 10 year old daughter to see The Addams Family show today. We loved every minute of it. Such an amazing show. Our waiter Craig was great and so was all the bus people. The food was just alright. Not terrible but nothing to rave about. The service and quality of the show are worth the trip. We will definitely be back for another show. read more

See all

We have been season ticket holders for years, with another couple. We have wonderful seats, enjoy the food and service, and always enjoy the show. I feel that I must comment on their current play, Fiddler on the Roof. I haven't seen it for many years, but I cried like I always do near the end. The cast was excellent, with beautiful choreography. However, Jacob Medich (Teyve) was phenomenal! His expressions, his eyes, his gestures, all made you love Teyve. He cried, he laughed, he IS Teyve. Don't miss this opportunity to see something very special. Congratulations Dutch Apple for ranking third in the nation for dinner theaters! read more

What an awesome experience! This was our first trip to Dutch Apple, but it won't be our last. The staff and show were great, and we enjoyed the food. read more

Was a little confusing in the parking lot finding it. Entrance is the same as a large restaurant on lower part of the hill while this place was up the hill. An inviting lobby, nice Theatre interior. Positive friendly staff. Waite staff is fast and they seem to help each other move the meal along to be ready by the time the show starts. The food was of a general quality. Good but nothing too special, but as expected. Dessert was rather good, surprisingly. The show was a treat, well done, cute, kept our attention. Rather good actors/singers. Bravo! read more

See all

If you enjoy live theater with fun shows along with plenty of food choices, then you will enjoy yourself here. Most of the time, they offer a buffet, but they also have sit-down service. It just depends on what you prefer. Plenty of time for dinner, dessert before the show starts, but it does go fast as you get soup, then salad, entree, and dessert. You can look up the menu online before you go. It changes, I believe, monthly. Here is one example of dinner at a sit-down meal. Plenty of friendly staff, buy tickets early for best seating. There is an intermission, so you can move around and use the restrooms if needed. You can't really do so during a show. Plenty of parking too. read more

See all

My mom treated me to Saturday Night Fever while we were in town for an event at Sight and Sound. The performance was wonderful! The actors were extremely talented and the guy who portrayed Tony Manero (John Travolta's character) even resembled a young Travolta. Mom and I were part of a tour with her senior center (see what a great daughter I am?!). The staff are probably used to large groups like this, but I was still appreciative of their attentiveness and patience with this group of older ladies. The only complaint I have is that we were really crammed in there. There are probably two too many seats at each table and one or two too many tables in each row. I understand the desire to fit in as many people as possible, but it would be much more comfortable if they could space things out a little bit. That said, the seats were comfortable enough to sit in through the dinner and the entire show. The buffet was a nice spread of greens, meats, and sides. There were two large tables of pies and cakes (including what I suspect are some local favorites - like shoo fly pie). I was quite impressed with the dinner. I tried to stay keto, but definitely enjoyed a couple of bites of some pie. If I lived closer, I'd definitely make Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre one of my regular GNO spots. read more

My wife and I went to Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre for the first time. We saw the show "Waitress". We arrived in time to take in the atmosphere where they have a gift shop. The buffet was full and the food was delicious with a good variety. I had three plates. Another couple were at our table and told us that they frequently go to this dinner theater and enjoyed it every time. We enjoyed it too, so we will be back. read more

The food I would say was just passable. The show and its players were great. Very talented performers

Saw a program here. Generally, like to support local theater. Went around Christmas. Food was buffet was okay. Sat at a table, would have preferred to be in seats for the show. Weird "joke" guy around intermission wasn't someone you would leave your children around. Would look for more a more different venue. read more

What a lovely little theater and a great place to spend a Sunday afternoon in Lancaster. We did the after show (started at 1pm) of Saturday night Fever. Buy your tickets online so you know you have seats and note hat you can switch views for the seat map and pick your own seats. They have ample parking in their own lot as well. For our show - we were asked to arrive I. Advance - 11:30 to eat. They do a buffet of salad, bread and hot foods (need,eggplant, veggies etc). You can go back up if you wanted a little more of something - but they do shut it down so folks are not distracted when the show is on. There is also desserts available - cake, pie and ice cream (Turkey Hill - yum!). All in all ... we were there for about 3 1/2 to 4 hours and had a great time! Tried to get tickets to see Elf near the holidays .. but already have very limited seats. read more

I've been to many of Dutch Apples shows and there has not been one bad show ever. They are all amazing! We always go to the shows in the evening, and we are never disappointed. It's very fun and enjoyable to eat dinner, and then sit back and relax and enjoy the show! The prime rib is my favorite, but there are many other options at the buffet to choose from! The dessert options are great as well; the chocolate cake is my personal favorite, but my family really enjoys the coconut cake as well. The actors performances are so good everytime! So many good dances/choreography, and great singing voices! I can't wait to come back time and time again and see more great shows while being down in the Lancaster area! read more

I love coming here. This is my second trip here. Came this time was just my daughter. We saw the little mermaid and had a fantastic time. The staff is very friendly. The dinner prefer they have available is very good. The last time we went we went on a weekend so there was more options but the Wednesday night dinner was quite good. My daughter was thrilled she loves mac & cheese. read more

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre - Awesome show - Performing Arts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Highly recommend this theatre! Broadway caliber shows in the heart of Amish country, close to NY and Gettysburg. We most recently saw The Sound of Music, but have traveled to see many shows here. The casts are always top notch, and this musical joyfully paid homage to the movie with happy, creative surprises. I love the coconut cake and the service is personal and welcoming. When we left the theatre we were thanked for coming. I recommend getting tickets first before getting any hotel accommodations, because tour buses come from all over to see these shows. We've sat in many different seats over the years and have never been disappointed. read more

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre - The Sound of Music!! - Performing Arts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Love, love, love this theater!!! You can not beat a live show with a smorgasbord dinner that has so many choices. It was my first time seeing a show here after hearing about my sister raving about how great this place was and how amazing the food is as well. She was telling me how its a live show and before the show starts you have about an hour and a half to browse the smorgasbord and pick through the turkey, roast beef, mash potatoes, and cakes, ice cream and pies before you see the show. This theater is also kid friendly and I was able to enjoy it with my daughter. I was surprising my daughter with this night and we ended up seeing A Christmas Carol, a few days before Christmas. I had gone with a party of 10 and we were seated next to each other at two tables that were side to side. We had about 4 young children with us and to my surprise they had also enjoyed the show. When it comes to the food, I would say it was the best food Ive had in Lancaster!! The food was so fresh and hot and there was even a carving station with beef brisket and pork! There was a huge selection of sides, and they had kid friendly items like chicken nuggets which was also a plus!! Cause some of the kids in our group were picky. This may be my new spot when it comes to dinner and a show because I enjoyed this experience so much! I will be returning in June for my 36th birthday with my daughter and sister to see Annie. I look forward to going back to see another show and filling myself to the point my belly is busting through my jeans with scrumptious food!! read more

See all

Good food, great people. I had a wonderful time. The show was great I Bought a purse from the gift shop read more

Amazing show and food! Great service! We enjoyed the Elvis show on New Years Eve! Would go again! read more

We have been here a few times. The shows are always very entertaining and of a good quality. The food however is not very good. The carved beef was very dry and hard to chew. I would suggest some gravy on the hot table. The other food is just average. I do appreciate the ice cream and sundae station for dessert. Good value for the price. read more

Great dinner theater! Every seat is a good one and the show was professionally done. We saw "Singing in the Rain" and it was just like the film. Great performers that sang, tapped and made you laugh. Food is well presented (Buffet Style) with lotsa of desserts. Will definitely come again. Friendly all around service. read more

See all

Travelled to Lancaster for the show. We saw Guys and Dolls. I pretty sure we were near the beginning of the run. There was chemistry between the leads but unfortunately, the lines were read as memorized speeches, not really dialogue between characters. The sets, costumes, choreography, and staging were excellent. The pit was good too. The singing was great nearly all around. Well be back for another show. The buffet was great. The pasta was not overdone. The prime was cooked perfectly and the chef slicing knew what she was doing. The produce was fresh. The desserts were varied and Lancaster traditional. All of the proteins were very tasty. The service was mostly good. Any waiting was due to not having enough people. The server was working her tail off. read more

Saw The Little Mermaid with some friends and the show was top notch. Excellent production, actors, staging, etc. I was very impressed! My 4 year old loved every second. Food was buffet was just okay. Buffets are not my thing. Desserts were very good. Dinner service (servers, bussers) were very good as well. read more

Came here for my daughter's birthday last week to watch the Beauty and the Beast performance. The food was, eh. Not the greatest. Actually not really good at all. It's a buffet. They had cheese ravioli, fish, ham, fried chicken, prime rib, broccoli, rolls...that's mainly what I remembered. The chicken was really weird. The piece my husband decided to put on my daughter's plate was, no lie, shaped like a ball. I didn't finish anything on my plate. They also had desserts, but I didn't even bother tasting them. The best thing I had was the Pinot Nior, which cost extra. The food was, eh, but the service was great. They kept our glasses full (water and wine.) They came by and picked up the dirty plates pretty regularly. What caught me really off guard, there was a stranger sitting at our table. Him and his wife decided last minute to come, so they sat him at our table and his wife at the table behind us. I was not thrilled about this. ESPECIALLY during covid! I mean, they had a sign on their front door saying to social distance...I'd hardly call this social distancing when my husband is rubbing elbows with a stranger because the Theater decided to sit him at our table. I didn't see anywhere on their website where it said this could happen. I mean, we were at a 4 top table...it was my family of 3 and a stranger. Really awkward. The play was phenomenal, the only saving grace of the night. We all enjoyed it, as this was my daughter's 1st play. It was really engaging. Loved all the songs! There were added songs which we really enjoyed too. If we were ever to come again, we would just come for the performance and not eat. If I could rate the performance alone, I would give it 5 stars...but the food was just so terrible and they did not follow covid protocols by sitting a total stranger at our table. FYI...If you're coming for a special occasion (birthday, anniversary, graduation etc) you can let them know and they will include this in their announcements before the play starts. I wish I had known this before going, so I hope this tip helps someone! read more

First time here. We booked online. Our first choice of a two-seat table wasn't available, so we were stuck sharing a table for four. And I mean stuck. The tables were so tight. My wife and I kept bumping elbows. There was a table to the left of us ,on another level, with the people hanging over the rail and over our table. The people who sat with us weren't into conversing much, making it awkward with all 4 of us sitting there for an hour and a half, before the show started. Out table mates were younger than most of the other patrons there and younger people just don't know how to talk. Blame social media. The show Margaritaville was cute. A little slow toward the end but enjoyable. The food disgusting. Except for the deserts. They were fantastic. I would recommend eating desert first. Food was buffet style or sit down. We did buffet. I really wasn't expecting backyard cookout food. Ribs, corn, fried chicken etc. Making things messy and I didn't bring any floss! The other items were disappointing. The prime rib was tasteless. The cod, sitting in butter, gross. Soup OK. The dinner rolls were very good. Sooo. They did have a salad bar as well. Drinks were an extra charge except for coffee and Iced tea which we ordered and never received. Thanks Craig. read more

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre - Small tables with people to the left of us hanging over our table. No room to eat comfortably. - Performing Arts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Excellent performance! We went to see Newsies. The production was fantastic. Performers were very talented. Live musicians which I was surprised about it. Easy entrance experience. Server was very attentive. Leaving the parking lot after the show was a little stressful but expected. I cannot comment on the food as we didn't eat. Buffets are not our thing. Food areas appeared to be clean from what I saw. If we lived in the area we would definitely return for other shows. read more

Rock of Ages ,must see a great experience for the whole family, Get up and dance kind of show . read more

See all

Decent buffet food and friendly wait staff. The Saturday Night Fever show we saw was ok as well. Acting & dancing not on par with NY Broadway shows but very good for PA. Fun time over all. read more

I was there on 12/14 for a matinee of a Christmas Carol. The restaurant is too small and too many tables are crowded into a very small dining area. The buffet line cuts directly into where people are entering for the event so that there is no smooth flow for the diners trying to navigate to and from the buffet. Very poor setup and the venue needs an expansion to accommodate the crowds. Show was good. The food was mediocre and they were cheap with the cod and shrimp. Shrimp were in tiny cut up pieces instead of a whole shrimp. How greedy for $75.00 per person! Will not return! read more

I attended Singing in the Rain yesterday. It was a first class production. All the cast was wonderful. Food was a buffet it was good as suspected but to me a buffet is not my favorite. I did enjoy the food , dessert was cake, pie and ice cream. I will certainly return again. Staff was friendly and efficient. The entire theater is clean and seating is spaced well. read more

I went to see Escape to Margaritaville on Sunday 10/1/2023. The show was excellent and the performers, incredibly talented! The meal was good and our server, Jackie took great care of our party of 8. Looking forward to coming back in the future! read more

Lovely little gem ! We saw the cutest production of "Grumpy Old Men". Helpful and friendly waitstaff and the food was tasty. Reasonably priced and our seats in row B were perfect. read more

Was in town for a weekend getaway. Saw the Savannah Sipping Society. Loved the show, great premise and the actresses were very good. I really got attached to them and their stories. Service was good. Deb was our server and she was great. Very personable, kind and friendly. Food on the other hand was not very good at all. I enjoyed the seafood salad and the honey glazed carrots. Eat dinner before you go. The coconut cake for dessert was very good though. Overall, we had a good time and will probably go back (we live 2 1/2 hours away). read more

Food was not very good at all but the show was really great. We were there for the show so we didn't expect much from the food, but I barely ate anything. The experience was very fun though! I loved how professional the show was. We saw singing in the rain and it was done very well! With actual rain on the stage read more

I have been here a total of 4 visits so far, and have been amazed each time. The buffet is great for what it is worth, and I always enjoy tasting new desserts that I have never encountered prior. There is absolutely no bad seat in the house and no one blocks your view either, which is essential. The productions are always perfect and sometimes I have felt that I prefer this establishment's more than if I had seen them previously elsewhere. This theatre has a cozy feel, which I believe helps you revel in the experience even more. read more

Saw Simon & Garfunkel show. Not a bad seat in the house. Go to the show. Good time & talented artists.