Looking for a place that sells pizza by the slice? I was too...Passing through the Stuart area, I was thrilled to stumble upon Benny's Downtown Pizza, a gem that conveniently offers pizza by the slice! The staff was friendly and refreshingly unassuming, which made the quick visit even better. My plain and margarita slices, along with my boyfriend's buffalo and BBQ slices, were all absolutely delicious and perfectly seasoned. The texture was spot-on, delivering a satisfying, nice crispness with every bite, and the temperature was just right--tasty but not scalding hot. This five-star experience means I will definitely be back for more of the best slice pizza downtown! read more

Great Pizza! Buffalo chicken pie was great as well as the regular pie! Calzone - amazing! My new spot. Can't wait to check out the rest of the menu! Super friendly staff too! read more

Pizza is awesome! Quality ingredients. Something you don't see much more of. Cook takes pride in his work and definitely looks the part with his dough covered apron. Not a place you want to dine in at but definitely a place you want to pick up for take out. read more

Pizza is great. Pasta is always Al dente, sauces ate delicious and portions are generous. Service is friendly and the food is always ready when they say it will be. Nothing to not like! read more

Pies have always been great and the service has been the same. It's my go to place and I highly recommend

Palm City location. Well, at first the garlic rolls looked amazing. The taste was a different story. It was if the knots were swimming in fake butter or margarine. Not for us. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Garlic Rolls (12) - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

We have been loyal Downtown Benny's customers for years. now that they have switched to AI answering system and using a 3rd party delivery system, it's been a nightmare ordering from them and not worth the hassle. One time the pizza was came cold but it didn't keep us from ordering again. YESTERDAY's order never came and I was charged. I finally got ahold of a real person and the manager said there was nothing they could do for me and next time not to order through AI. WHAT?!?!? That's there entire system now. The manager not making the situation right was the cherry on top. DO NOT BOTHER with this place. read more

Best buffalo wings in town. Pizza kinda a burnt on the bottom but still pretty good! Our go to pizza joint

Staff are always friendly and welcoming. Food is amazing! Eat here at least once a week.

Very average pizza, nothing bad about it. Ordered the supreme pizza and it was good... Thanks for making pizza in ours small town. read more

Never ever had a bad pizza! I get light garlic, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, & pineapple! The best pizza ever, they always say delivery in 45 minutes! Always early, hot, I know I'm only down the road from them in jensen, but excellent pizza! Love them, won't order from another pizza place, they are great! read more

Penne Ala vodka was the main event for us, but the pepperoni side of our pizza was a close runner up. Me being a plain cheese kinda of girl it wasn't bad, but it was about average for how pizza goes. The deal on the Large pie was pretty great, I think it's a large pie for price of a small on Mondays & Tuesdays. Initially thought we could dine in for service, but it's more of a hole in the wall kind of joint. There is seating available outside and a couple of chairs inside for quick service. Staff were friendly and helpful, and incredibly patient with us as we decided what we were hungry for! Thank you, and happy eats!! read more

See all

Tried Benny's today for the first time. It was quite the pleasant surprise. We got the white pizza which is my usual choice regardless of where I go. The dough was so flavorful nice fairly thing crust cooked to perfection. I feel like I've made a real discovery and it's great to know a non chain is providing this quality food. This for sure will be the beginning of many meals there. read more

In my family I am the calzone expert because I don't enjoy pizza -too messy to eat. I travel often and my go to comfort food is a calzone so I have had the opportunity to compare many restaurants's offerings around the USA. I love Downtown Benny's. Close to home, small local atmosphere. My favorite is Italian sausage, spinach & mushroom. A small easily feeds two if one wants to share! Crust is seasoned with garlic / yum!! read more

terrific food, great service, wonderful conversation! I will be back! I was informed the chicken Caesar wrap is exiting the menu, but it was so good that I'm sure the rest of the menu matches! read more

I've literally run past Downtown Benny's (when I could run, different story) many times and have been very curious. I'm no stranger to Brooklyn pizza and kind of kept Downtown Benny's in a list I'd like to try. Yesterday was that day. This review is during COVID-19. I and SCW reviewed the menu and made our decisions. Standard test of good pizza is for us Margarita and plain cheese. We ordered both for pick up. The shop itself reminds me of Brooklyn eateries. Small but packed with needed items. However Benny's is spotless unlike so many of my experiences with actual Brooklyn restaurants. Huge plus. Staff wore masks and I could tell they were doing a decent volume of business. Brought the pizza home (without eating it in the car.....go me) and unveiled it for SCW. Hence the pictures. Then after daubing grease off a few slices (not a judgement just a calorie reduction effort) we had our first bites. OMG delicious. The cheese pizza is flavorful and not salty like most pizza in the area. The margarita pizza was outstanding. Fresh bits of garlic in the sauce were a great surprise. I will certainly be back. Do yourself a favor and enjoy some great pizza. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

See all

This review is for the Palm City location of Downtown Benny's Pizza. The smell in the neighborhood is amazing and we were so excited to try the pizza. We went into the ice-cream shop by mistake but quickly realized it was a few shops down. There are plenty of tables outside and for a good reason...there are only two booths inside and it's cramped. Upon arrival we were greeted by the 3 adults preparing the food and pizza. You can see the kitchen through glass partitions so it's kind of nice. The pizza maker, Vinny was quite the character. He has a bit of a potty mouth so hold your kids ears. (nothing terrible but swear words are a spewing) We decided on a gorgonzola salad with balsamic dressing and a pepperoni pizza. The salad was fresh and colorful and actually quite delicious even though we had to ask for another plate to share it. We were served some garlic knots too, but they were pretty buttery and we knew we'd be eating a lot of bread (pizza) so we didn't eat them. The pizza arrived pretty quickly and it looked and smelled delicious. We let it cool for a few minutes then we dug in. The bottom of the pizza was quite charred but still edible and the toppings were adequate. The pizza is very very thin and looks great. All in all the pizza wasn't bad but wasn't good enough for me to want to rush back and spend nearly $50 for. I will say that we brought the leftovers home and they heated up rather well on a pizza stone. We added some Mikes hot honey and parmesan cheese and it was pretty good.T he drink selection is in a reach in cooler and there are pepsi products and Dasani water which is my least favorite. I don't think I'd rush back to Benny's simply because it lacked real pizza flavor. Side note: As the adult women were ringing up the register, cleaning up a table and serving take out items we notice that one of them picked up 2 slices of pizza in her bare hands and hand carried them over to the pizza guy without any gloves or utensils. It was for someone's order, not themselves. That was a huge turn off. read more

See all

We order from here on a weekly basis. One of our favorite spots. The use of Door Dash makes the experience awful!! Placed an order took over an hour to get. The app said the order was delivered and never was. Come to find out it was still at the restaurant. Go back to the old way!! So much better. Three stars for customer service!! read more

ordered a chicken parmigiana stromboli it had no sauce inside so it was chicken with cheese ...called them about it and got a response of you should of told me you wanted sauce inside ...excuse me but what is chicken parmigiana...never order from them again ...wouldn't do nothing to solve problem either not good customer service read more

I ordered 11 pizzas for the guys I work with, for Father's Day. Dean was very helpful and his team made sure my order was ready to go at the time I requested. The guys at work were pleasantly surprised and thought the pizza tasted great! They're a tough crowd. Lol Will definitely order for Dean and his team again! read more

I have tried this place a few times. Its average at best as far as flavor. However they don't clean their ovens, or they put corn meal on the bottom of the pizza and let it burn. Please see pics. ( disgusting) So I gave up on them. Flavor is not there anyway. Fantinis is absolutely the best try them. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Looks like burnt dust. Prolly burnt corn meal or they just don't clean the oven. Pics don't lie. Every time I order its like this. - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

See all

We ordered a bunch of pizzas for a family reunion. We had them delivered and they arrived hot! The pizza was amazing. Crust was just right, the cheese and toppings were excellent. Can't wait to order it again. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - a row of pepperoni pizzas - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

Many blame the water as a reason why good pizza can't be made in FL. Well the Myth has been busted by Downtown Benny's Pizza ! Walking in for the first time my wife and I were quickly greeted by the friendly staff and taken back by the aroma of the pizza aroma in the air. After heading back to our hotel and trying the pizza first time, my wife and I barely said a word to one another. We were in disbelief to have stumbled across this hidden Gem! We went again this past weekend and everything about the pizza was just good as the first time!. If it wasn't for the tiny hotel fridge, I would have ordered a 2nd Pie to bring with me back to Broward County! read more

See all

Pizza is always exceptional!!! Friendly service and they make sure you have it nice and hot

Want a " NY " style slice? This is the right place! Great pie, good garlic rolls and their Philly cheese steak too. This place has good customer service and pies made to order. read more

Alright Downtown Benny, I cave. I'll write a dang yelp review just for you, my first one. First of all I'm from Seattle so I don't even know what good Pizza is. Second of all I don't eat a lot of pizza, it has never been a favorite. I don't know what the heck is going on over there in that restaurant but since I moved into town (1 month ago) I have eaten more pizza from you guys than in my entire collective life span. There's is something different with that cheese of yours too, it's has flavor! And I eat the crust! This is unheard of for me. The sauce is perfectly seasoned and the ratios are right. Nice people too. Did I say that I even eat the crust!? Anyway, really great job and I wish you much success. Now stop making me fat ;) read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Large Cheese (well done) - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

I have had pizza here in the past and it was good, therefore I ordered a chicken cutlet parmigiana hero to go. When I unwrapped my dinner I was a but surprised at the size of the sandwich, a bit on the smaller side. I took a bite and tasted the warm sandwich, crispy bread on the outside and soft inside....and the sauce and cheese was flavorful. But I didn't taste any chicken. I opened up the bread and was mad...the chicken cutlet was cut in strips! The kind I would expect on top of a salad- NOT in a cutlet sandwich. I was ticked off enough to go back to Bennys and bring in the sandwich and ask if this is how the hero is normally made. The cashier replied it is cut this way so it "can fit on the bread". I have had chicken cutlets many times in my life and never ever was expected to swallow that excuse. I took a picture so you can judge for yourself. As for me and my family, we will NEVER be a patron of Bennys again. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Chicken cutlet hero - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

First time here as my son was participating in a bowling tournament across the way at Jensen Beach Bowl. The pizza was fantastic and full of flavor. The owner was super nice and friendly. This place has a homey feeling environment. I highly recommend this place if you love pizza. read more

I got a Benny's Special large pizza dElivEred for the first time tonight. No problem with ordering. Paid cash on delivery , but they can also take cards when ordering. Pizza was good. Good size. Basically thin crust. Fresh ingredients. I look forward to trying other menu items Cost was $20.11 Delivery I think was free. I tipped of course. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Benny special - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

I've tried every pizza place around Port Saint Lucie and Stuart. This is absolutely the best place if you want good pizza We've ordered from them four or five times so far and there's no reason to order from anyone else. Great ingredients and pizza makers!! read more

Pie was kind of dry and flavorless. I ve had good pizza from them before, but this time the 2 pizzas were a dud.

Literally the most plain generic tasting pizza I have had since my grade school cafeteria.. completely stale crust at 2:00pm paper thin. I'm not sure what cheese they use but it was terrible. 42$ for two large pizzas. First time Trying the palm city location but absolutely disappointed read more

Best Pizza here in Palm City! Delivery was A+. Definitely our go to Pizza place here.

Very good fresh pizza, have tried them a couple times and so far they have not disappointed. Grandma's style pizza was delicious !

We ordered while staying accross the street at the Psrk View Motel. Amazing food... all hot and fresh. Very very good read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - My view of Downtown Bemnys pizza from the fire pit and lovely tiki hut at yhe park view efficiency and suites. - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

They started off Much Better. Prices have gone up substantially and quality of pizza has gone down substantially. Lost our business and they're kinda of at a broken down location but think they can charge similar to the higher rent location pizzerias, No doesn't work. read more

Was told at the end of the night that this is what happens and it's not burnt. It should scrape right off. It did not. read more

Downtown Benny's Pizza - Was told at the end of the night that this is what happens and it's not burnt. It should scrape right off. - Soup Near Me - Jensen Beach, Florida

Ordered the Monday special well done. Came out perfect, I definitely enjoyed the sauce. Garlic bread was delicious. Delivery was quick, less than 20minutes. read more

Are you ready for this??? I don't think so. Run, don't walk to Downtown Bennys everything they make is great,, Chicken pesto pizza is by far my favorite.. I can't get enough. When my family comes to town. They place their extra large order right when we hit the Stuart exit Yesterday I already had dinner made and when my niece came into town. First words was downtown Bennys And it never disappoints.. Thank you Benny.. read more

Stopped in tonight as we were seeing Christmas lights and I had to use the bathroom. I came out and decided to grab some slices. The pizza is so good! Big slices and they were cheap and delicious. I got the meat lovers and eggplant parm. The eggplant parm had big dollops of ricotta and great tomato sauce. The staff was friendly and I definitely plan on coming back. read more