Honestly I'm SO annoyed and done with this pizza place. Every time I order here my food is wrong like, I've started to feel like when my name pops up they purposely make it wrong. I'm also DISGUSTED at how one of the managers responded to my complaint. Her attitude was foul. My order wasn't complicated at all and frankly I'm never coming here again. read more

Pizza was great! Kali made it perfect, just the way I ordered it. Hot and delicious :)

ordered an Italian sub with sausage and a medium half pep pizza. The sub had no sausage and barely any meat on it at all I was supposed to get a credit and when I went to call to place an order for 3 subs and a large pizza they said there was no credit.. The guy was rude as hell and we order out a lot and so does our family here in circleville so when they stop getting orders they will know why.. They skimp you on the meat and serve burnt pizza anyways.. read more

Good food fast service reasonable prices. Best pizza in town. Very nice customer service.

Delivery Order Delivered in a timely fashion, food was hot and fresh. Gentlemen doing the delivery was polite and kind. Ordered: The Works thin crust with Extra Mushrooms. Thankful they use fresh mushrooms, not the slimy canned ones. Pizza was good as always, nice thin and crispy crust. Big Don with Sausage. Sub was good, but the portion is so small for the price. Very little meat, that's why this go around I ordered the Sausage but of course it's more expensive that way. Personal (7 inch) Serious Cheese. This was for my 2 year old little girl, she seemed to enjoy it! read more

See all

Best pizza. Moved away from Circleville and I crave it. Gotta have it everytime I come back!

The sauce tastes like something similar to generic ketchup & the pepperoni sausage has as much flavor as the canned mushrooms. However the crust was on point read more

The spicy buffalo chicken pizza is EVERYTHING. Couple that with a caprese salad and you have a great meal. I have never had anything bad from this Donatos. I do recommend checking your spicy chicken pizza before driving away though. They have forgotten to add ranch twice but we're quick to make it right. I'd recommend this Donatos to anyone. read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Circleville, Ohio

My husband and I use to order here 2-3 times a week as it is close to our house and easy on busy days. I have to have my sub light baked due to dental issues. I was starting to get over baked/burnt subs so we stopped ordering for a while. We just ordered again tonight and once again the bread was so hard I couldn't even take 1 bite!! So disappointed as we use to love our local Donatos... won't be going back ever and will make sure to tell others not to also read more

Donates will be my go to place for pizza. I ordered a pizza and sub tonight and was wondering where it was as I watch TV. I pulled up my online order and I didn't get the traditional "your pizza has left the building" email. I call and the associate tells me I placed it for pick up not delivery. I asked him if he could change it and he offered to make the entire order fresh and have it delivered to me! Way above and beyond! Customer for life! Thank you Donatos! read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Circleville, Ohio

This is by far our favorite pizza, we live in Louisiana and when we come to Ohio to visit family we can't wait to get the pizza. It's best to dine in and eat. I hope someday Donatos comes down to south Louisiana. read more

We love this Donatos. The pizza is always hot and fresh and the servers are friendly and courteous. I like to order online and dine in, so I can take advantage of the online coupons. Today our server was Billy and he was very helpful and professional. Thanks Donatos! read more

See all

Local pizza chain restaurant that has pretty good pizza and subs. Their pep n cheese has a TON of pepperoni on it and is one of my favorites. Try the Founders Favorite if you like something a little spicy. The subs are really good here too. They do offer delivery if you are not too far from their store and our local store here has a drive thru pick up window which is nice. read more

i just called for delivery the lady anna who answered had attitude from the start she eas extremely extremely rude to me and had the worst attitude and snootyness ever. my order was for almost 60.00 and because of her i canceled therefore donatos lost business and customer read more

I work for a big plant here in Circleville Ohio. About 3 nights ago I order a med Hawaiian pizza with a side of bread sticks, I had a $3 coupon and which made my total 15 something, the driver messed my order and someone else's order up I ended paying 17.81 plus tip and when I call all they do is credit me for the pizza, so I don't get my bread sticks because I brought little cash with me to work and have to pay another delivery charge because their driver messed up? So to be honest I probably will not order from them because they do not take care of their customers! Cristy's pizza always take care of their customers. I feel I shouldn't have to pay a delivery charge because of their mess up. read more

If you like Donatos this establishment does a excellent job. My fav is the original pep and "BAM" it's pretty darn tasty!!The service i've had is always good and their pizza is excellent! so go GETCHA SUM! read more

Donatos Pizza offers some of the best pizza here in town. They never cheat on toppings and it's always edge-to-edge. If you enjoy a thin crust pizza as much as I do, then Donatos is the place you want to go. They offer dying in service as well as drive-thru service for take out or you can come in and pick up your order as well. So stop by to Donatos today and order the best. read more

Third time order wrong in pick- up window. They have you pay first, then look for food. I ask for money back so I can go to another pizza shop and...Send me to wait and this ends up being more than the original 20 minutes for order. Subs not correct- serious concerns about quality of Subs. Been eating Donatos for over 40 years - circleville Donatos a pitiful franchise of this organization. read more

Great food. Local company. The music is a little loud but over this is a great place to eat.

Nice spiced pepperoni covered pizza. Great for OSU games! Nice breadstick and garlic bread options.

Absolutely pitiful. I went here with my family.. They brought my Sub....just my food... everyone watched with rapt interest as I ate my dinner, then they brought my Sister's "wings" ...same scenario...then they brought my Mother and Brother's Pizza. We had to repeatedly get up and find someone, and interrupt them from their conversation with co-workers... to get drink refills, napkins.......You know...the little things. The music was LOUD and would come on and off randomly, creating those wonderfully awkward "screaming over the music and it stops" moments. While there, we enjoyed the show of two irate customers receiving heartfelt "shrugged shoulders" apologies from a manager who only seem to be on the floor when called in for such damage control. The service was deplorable, we were totally ignored, the pizza wasn't bad, but the rest of the food items were terrible. We even had to go find someone to give us our bill so we could flee the place. To top it off? The local fair was going on within eyesight, so it wasn't like they were overwhelmed with business. read more

Tends to be under staffed and overwhelmed late nights. No issues with delivery however. One evening, it took over 15-20 minutes (not joking) to get the attention of anyone (the few were in the back) to be able to pay for my bill. read more