Very good pizza. Sonny (originally from Canada) has been living here for a few years. Sonny's pizza…read moreis some of the best pizza I've had anywhere, much less on Isla Mujeres. Delicious. If I remember correctly, they are "cash only." I think you can pay in USD if you want/need to. Parking in the immediate area is limited. The new Presidential (Mayor) building is literally around the corner so the curbs in the immediate area are now all painted red (no parking zones). There was a full row of small vehicles and golf carts parked in a red-zone when we were there. None were towed or got tickets but they had been newly painted in the past 48 hours (April '26). I would suggest finding "yellow" parking in the immediate surrounding area and walk to Sonny's. There is also a Sonny's "south" located at The Joint close to Punta Sur. However, they only have a limited menu of about 6 pizzas. We prefer the original located downtown. Bottom line - Delicious pizza . Worth the visit. Parking is limited. Bon appétit, y'all.

Sonny's pizza is amazing. We stop by for his wonderfully seasoned margarita cheese pizza and…read moreSangria every time we are on Ilsa. Food and service is consistently good over all these years.

Always enjoy the great pizza and courteous service…read more Wonderful aiconditionbandbwide menus choices!

Amazing food and service... Really cool ambiance. We tried this place from recommendation from 2…read moreother people, glad we tried it and looking forward to coming back for dinner before we go.

Who knew I'd come to a little Mexican Island for the most exquisite Italian food. All the pastas…read moreare homemade and it shows. We started out with their meatballs (cut with a fork tender) and mussels (delish). Their Cesar salad was equally amazing and could be shared with 3 people. I had the lobster fettuccine Alfredo, so so good! My husband had the seafood pasta that came out foil wrapped and steaming. Seafood was tender full of flavor. Their ragu meat sauce tortellini was homemade and the sauce was heavenly! Even the pepperoni pizza had great crust and sauce flavor. Size was big! We sat outside on the cobblestone street where they come by and play music, such an amazing experience. Service is friendly! Oh and our wine and cosmopolitan perfect! This is a must stop in Isla Mujeres

The lasagna is the best we've ever had... but the seafood linguini is life changing…read more Most folks don't think of eating Italian food while in Isla, but you MUST enjoy a meal at Mamma Rosa's. Authentic. Delicious. Great service. Good wine list. And air condition!!! DELICIOSO!!

Tasty pizza and drinks. When it's hot out, and that oven is going, it does kind of come at you. But…read morethe second time we went a little later and with the cold drink and breeze, it was fine. The service is great here too.

Excellent pizza, wine, reasonably priced. Don't miss this when on Isla Mujeres. Pizza crust is…read moreflavorful, so many options.

The pizza arrived on time (ordered on Rappi) and was a decent size for the price - I believe around…read more250 pesos or so and could easily feed 3-4 imo. I also ordered a side of pesto and side of sauce and they gave me two pestos so wasn't thrilled with that. Their menu is large but honestly a bit redundant. Many of the pizzas are the same with one ingredient added or switched. They could easily streamline the menu by just doing a small menu of house pizzas and a build-your-own option. Pizza was bad. Just really bad. Sauce was way too sweet, crust was way too bready, toppings were limp and sad. I had to throw half away because I couldn't bear thinking about the leftovers. Would not recommend at all. Save your pizza cravings for when you're back in the states.

We took a taxi to go to El Tigre y El Toro but because there was a few block area roped off, our…read moredriver took us here and waited for us. Very interesting place, wood carving's everywhere, gravel floor, plenty of indoor seating that felt a bit like outdoor. Waitress didn't speak English but got someone quickly who did. Both, very personable, and helpful. I'm a bit of a pizza aficionado (worked in the biz many years and still love it), and found the pizza here as good as most anywhere. Would recommend the adventure into Pizza Casa Jaguar.

We stopped for lunch because we heard they had really good pizza. It wasn't busy and around lunch…read moretime when we came. We were seated quickly and put in an order right away. It was a very chill, fast casual kind of spot, perfect for the day we were having. My friends were not disappointed with the pizza and garlic knots. The portions were huge and looked absolutely amazing. I had chips and guac and shrimp ceviche. Both were big portions, tasty and fresh. Service was good and if you are in the area stop by for some food.

Excellent NY style pizza...hand-tossed!! Had the Italian Sausage and it was excellent! Highly…read morerecommend going if you're on the island! Service was wonderful as well. Would definitely return!

April 4, 2026 - 5 Stars!…read more Our group of 6 went to La Pizzarra based on positive reviews here and on Google. It was great!! It was as good of meal as we had our entire vacation- and the price was very reasonable, especially when compared to resort/hotel prices. It sits on the lagoon so there are really nice views- we prefer to sit outside and it was great. The warm rolls they brought out were delicious We started with 2 pizzas to share, and both were fantastic. We tried the BarBQ chicken pizza and the meatlovers- both really really good We all had pasta for main course. There is one dish that was penne with shrimp and chicken- that was the best. The fettuccine Alfredo was great, definitely better than average. The spicy shrimp pasta was ok- the pasta was undercooked but the shrimp and pesto was tasty. If you're looking for really good pizza & pasta- we highly recommend. We went at/around 7pm and didn't need reservations. Staff was outstanding- very friendly and very attentive

While staying in the Hotel Zone at El Presidente Cancun, I wanted something quick that wasn't…read moreanother overpriced hotel option -- and that's how I stumbled onto this gem. La Pizzarra delivered a thin-crust beauty loaded with quality pepperoni and well-seasoned meatballs. The sauce had just the right touch of sweetness, and the crust held up perfectly -- no flop, no soggy center, just a slice you could fold and enjoy. When you're on vacation and craving something familiar done right, this is exactly what you hope to find. A low-key win in the middle of the Hotel Zone. Highly recommend.

Can't believe no yelpers have reviewed this place yet. It's amazing!!! The BF and I had dinner…read morehere tonight. We started with an Aperol Spritz and a Campari spritz, yummy!!! Shared an appetizer of chicken breast stuffed with spinach wrapped in bacon with chipotle mayo on a bed of lettuce. More yum. But the highlight cannot be overstated :: PIZZA!!! His traditional and mine without cheese. Both equally satisfying. I don't know for sure but they must have a woodfired pizza oven. If not they have still managed to create that authentic Italian thin pizza oven crust texture. We both kept raving about how delicious the crust was, in addition to the sauce and topping. The arugula/rocket I added was so fresh! And they have a chili infused olive oil that is a must to drizzle all over each bite!!! They have a simple but what sounds like delicious breakfast so we'll definitely be back to try that, as well as I'm sure for many more pizzas!!!

EAT Here! Best pizza I had during my 2.5 month visit to Mexico. BEST! There is allot of great food…read moreand service in the area all the way south to Tulum. This is one of the very good ones not to miss. I will eat here every visit .

Amazing service, amazing food, walk in options available, waited about 10 minutes but it was worth…read moreit. The prices are great too, our meal was $50 including tip and we got a few drinks, a salad, and 2 entrees! Definitely recommend for authentic Italian food!

Small place not a lot of seating. Service was fast and friendly. Not many options on wine. Tried…read morethe lasagna with Bolognese. The pasta was soft and tasty. I didn't care for the bolognese part of the lasagna. The vegetarian was more expensive than the meat which didn't make sense to me. I thought the lasagne was pretty pricey in general.

An epic menu with an awesome oven you can smell the goodness as you approach the front door…read moreThe service is always on top and the pasta is just cooked right, the salad selection is awesome plus the appetizers are you must order the Calamari

Awesome Italian restaurant in Cancun. Came here to have something else Mexican food. We were a…read moreparty of 11 came on a Wednesday evening and were seated upstairs patio. Our server was gracious, patient and was on top of everything. Her made sure the table was clear and clean. Food was delicious and can't beat the prices. Definitely would recommend.