I first saw Deer Duck Bistro mentioned in the Good Food Guide Awards 2012 list - they were awarded the Dan Murphy's BYO Restaurant of the Year (though this fact had slipped my mind by the time I dropped in last night, and had to duck back out and down the street to the Chalk & Cheese on the corner). So yes, they are still BYO, and it's still being delivered with the addendum "for the time being".
From Tuesday nights through to Thursday nights, the dinner menu is a la carte. On Friday nights and Saturday nights it's a set menu (with choices still to be made for mains and desserts), though with a couple of "to share" items on the set menu, it's a little alienating for a solo diner. There's also a ten course degustation menu available throughout the week for $120pp - no matched drinks menu available, of course, though you're welcome to BYO attempts!
There are three separate dining areas at DDB: the small front room looks onto the road, the main dining room is down the hallway and through to the back, and there's also a third area, upstairs, used for functions (and overspill on busier nights, I expect). I'd gotten hopes up of sitting at the window in the front room, but I didn't speak up when I was first ushered in, and I ended up in the far back corner of the main room - but that was fine.
I arrived quite early in the night and had the whole dining room to myself for almost an hour, when two other parties arrived. To be honest, although the emptiness may not have been good for business, I'd been enjoying the quiet soundtrack of the Rat Pack and Fred Astaire classics, and my lovely evening was shattered when one of the other parties started noisily discussing The Shire. Really, guys? Could you just... not?
The service was polite and prompt. The menu was appealing and I was pleased with my choices. The menu may seem "horribly pretentious" but I got to experience a new idea the owner had floated with the staff of having one of the chefs bring out the meals, so ingredient details could be given, or any questions could be answered. The fun thing about the quiet night was that sounds carry through the restaurant more than some would think, e.g. "But I'm in my whites, I'm all grubby, I don't look nice!" and "Which way does the plate go on the table?" Having said that, it was actually a nice touch, as long as the chefs have time to do it without impacting their roles in the kitchen.
My three courses were all delicious, but I think the highlight for me was the "textures of carrots" dessert. The name made me a) confused over why carrots were on a dessert menu and then b) giggle, but I like a food adventure and I'm so glad I went there. I won't spoil the surprise.
Now, get thee to Deer Duck Bistro. Park on Grimes St, and grab a bottle of wine from Chalk & Cheese down on the corner if you've forgotten to BYO (heads up, corkage is $10). I'll be heading back soon with friends in tow, to give the degustation a run for its money! read more