Ordered a pizza over phone. Said it would be ready in 20-25 mins. Perfect timing in my mind to grab…read moreas that's the time I would be driving through town. I get here 25mins after placing my order and they are just putting it in the oven! I've got a 3 hour car ride or better once I've got the pizza and we were going to eat it in car. So now I'm sitting at Casey's..... waiting on a pizza. Also no compensation or even an apology. I got an excuse of oh we have been so busy.

Food is usually OK, but definitely not as good as it used to be with the former owners... I felt a…read morebit uncomfortable when I went in to order, like there was a sense of frustration and/or urgency in the employees... just not the same quality pizza that was there before!!!

Best in town, hands down! The homemade crust is . There's never a trip to Watertown for our family…read morethat doesn't include at least one order from Empire Pizza!

We found this place Superbowl Sunday 2026. One of the few places in town we found open. We had…read morethe duck bacon wonton which were delicious. My Tennessee hot chicken sandwich was crisp and juicy, the bun grilled to perfection. My sister's burger was also very good, cheesy and gooey. Lots of fries with the sandwiches. The server was lacking a bit too busy watching bad bunny halftime show to bring plates for appetizers. But overall was a good experience and I'd definitely go back again.

Very slow service, very few customers yet it took 45 minutes to get food. When food arrived sliders…read morewere burned bad and buns were stale and dry. I only finished one they were so bad. Wife and daughter's sandwiches so bad they didn't finish 1/2. In fact my wife couldn't even bite through her BLT. I have never really had a good experience there, a couple times it was just ok. Instead of trying to be upscale cool maybe start with decent food and reliable service.

We stopped to have lunch on way to SF. Waitress , Emily, usually works bar, served us with a smile…read moreand cheerful attitude. I order a pizza with capicola ham and pineapple. Sooooo good! Sister had chicken strips which she loved. Restaurant has old world charm. Worth the short journey if the interstate.

Dempsey's is a Watertown stalwart for places to go eat and catch up with people. This place has…read morebeen around for a bit and everyone is familiar with the quality of the food and specifically their pies. During the stint back in Watertown I didn't make as many trips to Dempsey's as I normally would but the quality of the food hasn't dropped. It's always nice when you walk in you can smell pizza being baked in their oven (s). I usually land on their Dempsey's Classic that has Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Green peppers, Black Olives, Baby Bella Mushrooms. I usually ask for them to add another 3 mins of cook time for the extra crispy and ensure the middle of the pizza is fully cooked. They have a variety of other unique pizza's to taste but I usually go with their Classic. They also have a variety of their own in-house brews that's always changing along with their standard taps. If anyone is ever visiting Watertown definitely add Dempsey's as a go to place to try out.

Walked here with my mom. Took only 20 minutes for food to arrive, but I didn't get any plates for…read moremy pan pizza!! I had to use napkins, but it's greasy as a McDonald's stovetop, so it practically made the napkin invisible. Ambience looked like an old 70's Pizza Hut, which was pretty swagger. I didn't love but I liked.

Just had food delivered to my residence by a woman named Amber. Upon arrival I am visibly signaling…read morefor the delivery driver to come over, as it can be difficult to locate if the driver hasn't been here before. This woman then pulls into the parking lot, gets out, starts talking to my neighbor which isn't a big deal until she tells me yeah hold on one minute while she exchanges contact information with my neighbors. I understand people want to network and connect, but maybe that could have waited until I had my food (which I had already paid for, $4 tip to go less than a mile, still arrived 5 mins late.) After approximately another 5 minutes of not seeing her, I leave my residence to locate where Amber had disappeared to with my food in her arms while entering the opposite housing complex from where she seen me. When I go over to where she is and I get my pasta and wings from her, without a receipt. She is visibly fidgeting and appears to be under some sort of influence. When I arrive to the other complex I ask "Hey, can I have my food?" She replied with "uhh yeaah?" as though I interrupted her conversation. Meanwhile she's holding my dinner hostage to talk to the neighbors. She hands over the food and I leave. This behavior is concerning because she was operating a vehicle in an area with children present and were still playing outside. Never had any issues prior to this.

We don't go here anymore. Too many times we have gone and there is lukewarm or cold pizza out on…read morethe buffet. We try to wait until they put fresh stuff out, but they tend to just leave whatever is out on the buffet there until it is gone. You and up eating the old stuff on the buffet, because fresh food never comes. Discouraging. I have also seen them add new salad on top of old empty salad containers. Very unappealing.

Excellent food. Excellent service. Very clean. Plenty of space for a gathering. Refills on…read morebeverages; and their buffet has great choices.

I said before I have a number of reviews, but seldom have low star reviews. Unfortunately, this is…read moreone of them. Food quality and taste is similar to gas station food. Cheese bread...or Italian Fries....as the young kid at the counter called them have some funky sweet glaze on them. Sweet and salty!!! How can breadsticks be messed up?... it's crust and cheese. Ranch dressing is food service. Combo pizza, very plain tasting and have been sitting there for a while similar to the QuikMart. I get it, I'm in Aberdeen, South Dakota. Certainly not the Mecca for pizza. But I would not spend my money here again

Everything was great except for my server who according to the receipt was Mariah she was very rude…read moreand laughed once she got my order wrong

The pizza shack has some of the best pizza! We tried it…read morewhile visiting some friends and enjoyed it very much. Since then everyone that we've shared it with has also enjoyed it. So far, we've had, Supreme Bacon Cheeseburger Jalapeno Popper Chicken Alfredo Barbecue Chicken Hawaiian We have yet to have a bad one!!! The burgers are good also. French fries are crispy not soggy and portion sizes are good. I want all great food at a good value!

The ladies behind the counter are very helpful and friendly. They make you feel like your a local…read more Oh and I forgot the burger I ordered was great.