My understanding is this place recently moved from Summit, SD to this location. It had been known…read moreas Tuny's. Anyway, once we found it we seated ourselves. The server was prompt and attentive. My husband had the nightly special - taco bar ($15 All you can eat). I had the walleye bites and fried cheese balls ($16) off the menu. I really enjoyed my meal. Husband was satisfied with his. We have an all you can eat tacos back in KC that is just hard to top. The owner stopped by and chatted us up and I noticed he visited each table and thanked everyone for coming in. I always appreciate that. I'd go back if we get by this way again.

Oh my goodness! I LOVE Club Eden. You guys, this your typical small town Midwest joint and it makes…read moremy heart so happy. When we're at the lake, there aren't really restaurant options nearby so when a friend told us about Club Eden (a 20 minute drive from our cabin) we were ALL IN! They have nightly specials, the best service, great prices, and really yummy Midwest food. I ordered their patty melt and tater tots. Oh em gee, there is nothing like a small town patty melt. It *literally* melted in my mouth. It had perfectly toasted whole wheat bread, gooey cheese, a hamburger patty, and grilled onions. Yes, please! It was also under $4. Like WHAT?! The tater tots were also everything that I had dreamed of and more. They have large containers of RANCH and all of the sauces that you could dream of as well. They had whiskey drinks for $2 on special the night we were there and you better believe that the guys in our party were STOKED about this! They also had 0.65 cent wings with 14 sauce choices. Yes, you guys, 14!!!!! You can mix and match which is so cool. The guys were in heaven. The restaurant itself is large, with a big bar, and lots of games! The town of Eden has a very small population and I can tell you that people drive from loads of towns nearby to eat here! We'll be back on our next visit to the lake. Huge shoutout to Cheyanne for making our experience a GREAT one!!

We had the broasted chicken and salad bar. The chicken is excellent and reasonably priced. Service…read morewas very good as well. We were just passing through but hope to come back .

4.4* (out of 5) Food: 4* Atmosphere: 4* Value: 5*…read more Service: 4* Would I go back / Recommend?: 5* (Definitely) Total check/person: $18 07/13/2025 We were looking for a place to stop for brunch after Mass in Webster on our way back home to Des Moines and my in-laws suggested Bitter Lake Lodge's buffet. The building has a modern steel exterior and a modern hunting cabin like interior with a concrete floor (see pictures). Service was prompt and there was a reasonable selection on the buffet line (scrambled eggs, scrambled eggs with veggies and cheese, bacon, sausages, potatoes, biscuits & gravy, pancakes and french toast sticks). The scrambled eggs were very good and the potatoes were good, but they were out after we went through and were not replenished. The sausages were plentiful and the bacon was thick, hearty and smokey. Overall, this was a solid, above average buffet with good service at a good value ($12.99 + coffee / beverage). Other than a desire that they be a bit more attentive to the quantity of food in the pans and replenishing as required, my main disappointment was that black plastic forks were the only eating utensils available. Given the available foods, metal knives wouldn't be necessary - but having metal forks would be appreciated. If you found this review helpful, please show your appreciation with a Like or a Follow.

So this place has been around since the 1950s. Now it's not your typical hole in the wall but a…read morewell-kept hole in the wall/restaurant. The steak comes with the salad bar and your choice of potato. The salad bar was pretty good with a lot of choices. The potato not bad as well. But, that ribeye really hit a home run for me! It's one of the best I've had in South Dakota! You guys really know what you're doing when it comes to steaks. The atmosphere is pretty neat but tired looking. The outside overlooks miles and miles farmland. Very beautiful indeed. Thank you for offering such a wonderful experience. Staff are so nice and professional!

A great spot to get a steak dinner near Pickerel Lake in South Dakota! We typically go to The Lodge…read more(same owner) and decided to venture up to Hilltop for our date night this visit. My husband and I sat at the bar and had gin & tonics, a delicious 10oz sirloin steak, potato, and salad bar! We left full and happy and even had leftover steak to make a yummy salad for lunch. We recommend if you're in the area and in need of a comfort meal.

Good food and good service. I look forward to going back. I've heard they have great steak dinners…read more We just had lunch the time I went. We had a burger and fries.

Awesome food awesome service right off the highway quick I suggest the bacon cheeseburger sub!read more

We had an excellent experience here from start to finish. The food was outstanding -- perfectly…read morecooked, juicy steaks with great portions, creamy garlic mashed potatoes, and bread with butter that honestly beat Texas Roadhouse (and that's saying something). The Smokey Old Fashioned was the perfect finishing touch and one of the best I've had. What really made the night special was getting to meet the owner, who was incredibly kind and welcoming. You can tell they genuinely care about the food and the people who walk through the door. Great food, great drinks, and even better hospitality -- we'll definitely be back.

New Frontier was amazing! I had the pork ribeye and it was hands down the best pork I've ever had…read moreperfectly cooked, flavorful, and seriously memorable. The food was outstanding, the atmosphere was great, and the service made the whole experience even better. Definitely recommend checking this place out if you get the chance.

3 meals out of 3. Zero stars. Bar was meh, food was burnt. Paid for the whole thing. Our second…read morehalf of the party was paying. Claimed we stiffed em and got paid again. Nice

The people here are so kind! I loved my stay! They held a Mother's Day banquet and have banquets…read moreand events for most Holidays. I made many new friends that took very good care of me! I would stay again! The modern day appliances were nice! I especially liked the walk in showers.

Good service, strong drinks. Had fun. The bartender was friendly and she put on the Stanley Cup…read moreFinals for me and my friend. Good time.

Good cold cheep beer and friendly service. There aren't a lot of choices in town to grab a beer but…read morethis place was great for a cold one after a long day on the lake.