Wanted to try something new, so I stumbled upon this place. Pretty chill little shop in the plaza…read more I ordered the margherita pizza with garlic knots and it was really good. Would definately come back and recommend this place for sure

Took my family for dinner here when they were in town. We each had slices of what they had out for…read morethe evening, all of which were delicious. My sister had a calzone and oh my goodness it's made for a giant! The staff were helpful in describing what they had available and were a great help at making sure everything came out at the same time. The pizza shop is well taken care of and clean. It does get a little loud, but for great pizza, it's worth it

Ordering was simple, pizza was done on time.....maybe a little too done on one of them…read more The pizza had great flavor and was a nice change from typical pizza.... However, not our favorite and was a bit pricey. We love NY style pizza but this was just a bit off. We will try again another time to see if maybe they just had a bad night.

Read a previous review and made the Perfect road trip stop. Delicious flavor. It's not as thick as…read moreI imagined a "pizza pie" to be but it still was delicious. We got a weird name pizza... nasty something lol the dessert .. large for 2 people (good price ). Had the sweetest young waitress too.

Great pizza! Friendly service! Nice atmosphere! They even have special sauce made in SFs on the…read moretable. And I was impressed with their frozen ready to eat selection in their freezer. Will come back again.

The epitome of 5 for me…read more We're just in Sioux Falls for a few days, so I can't speak to how it compares to other options but... 1. The pizza was excellent. Not "good for the price," but objectively good. We had the BB-Coo Chicken, highly recommend! 2. The girl who made it was super personable, like she truly enjoys the place. Great communication when I called to order and accurate because when I showed up to pick up, there was less than a minute left. She was charismatic and enthusiastic, even while she never stopped working. 3. I was only in the place for a minute. It's small but sooooo cool! Old school video and arcade games. If your husband grew up in the 90's, and you send him for pickup, he may take a couple hours. Great pizza, tremendous experience and service. The kind of place I'd go out of my way to return to if/when I'm anywhere near Sioux Falls.

My husband and I actually stumbled onto Tomacelli's completely by accident while cutting across the…read morewest side of Sioux Falls on our way toward downtown. And honestly, those accidental discoveries sometimes wind up becoming your favorite places. We were absolutely famished that afternoon and wanted something different from our usual stops when we noticed this little pizza place sitting quietly inside a fairly non-descript strip mall. At first glance, you might not expect much. Then you walk inside. The atmosphere immediately drew us in. Warm, casual, inviting, and filled with the kind of local neighborhood energy that makes you feel comfortable almost instantly. It had personality. Not manufactured "corporate chain pretending to be cozy" personality either. Real personality. Thankfully, the food completely lived up to the vibe. We ordered a large specialty pizza loaded with all the trimmings along with a smaller pepperoni pizza because my husband and I have fully embraced the philosophy that ordering "too much pizza" is not actually a real problem. It is simply future happiness. And because we apparently cannot order pizza without wings, we added a small wing order as well. The pizzas were absolutely fantastic. The crust had wonderful texture and flavor, the toppings were generous, the cheese was gloriously hot and melty, and everything arrived piping hot exactly the way pizza should. Even the smaller pepperoni pizza impressed us. Sometimes simple pizzas reveal the quality of a place better than overloaded specialty combinations do, and Tomacelli's absolutely delivered on both. Now the only small critique we had involved the wings. My husband and I personally tend to prefer traditional deep-fried buffalo wings over baked-style wings. That is simply our preference. However, even with that bias, the wings here were still flavorful and enjoyable enough that we really did not mind very much once we started eating them. And honestly, the biggest compliment we can give this place is simple: We kept coming back. Even though we live on the east side of Sioux Falls now, we still happily make the drive across town because local gems like this are worth supporting. More importantly, the consistency has remained excellent every time we have visited. That matters. Any restaurant can accidentally have one great night. The places that keep earning loyalty are the ones that continue getting it right over and over again.

Good Dough! For not too much money!…read moreSave it for the Casino!!! Don't forget to sing the place, they'll even hand you the marker! Whole pie with Chad A. and he even got his money back in the back! Hint hint! The cheese is right, the toppings are a'plenty and they have the right amount of sauce! Even the drinks are appropriate! The conversations got intermingled and new friends made! It was hot and served with a cheeky smile! She was cute! I'll be back soon! They didn't forget to ask us about the big game either!

This place has a great staff! Always giving back to the community. Partners with the local schools…read moreand Universities. Men of real FAITH! From Big Poppa's BBQ Truck to a new Sioux Falls staple! Did I mention the fact that the pizza is better than every other pie on Minnesota Avenue! Check out the lunch special that has two slices and a free drink! You favor taste over convenience, you will be rewarded with a new place to enjoy a slice and a conversation.

The deep dish pizza is phenomenal! Every bit as good as Chicago favorites! I went to school in…read moreChicago and this pizza is great!! It is amazing and I believe one of the best pizzas in Sioux Falls! Love it. I will add pictures! Please try it! Btw today special the medium 2 topping deep dish was only $19.95. An amazing price. Go get one you will not be disappointed!

Food and service are excellent . I had a create your own pizza and had the perfect pizza. I wish…read moreI had this restaurant in my hometown!!!

The service was great. They listened to everything I wanted. The restaurant itself is clean and…read moreyou're able to see all the ingredients go onto your pizza as they build it and I believe it's best to eat your pizza fresh. so eat there and my pizza was simply amazing. I love the way the flavors come together I took off the ham, Canadian bacon and substitute it for actual bacon with the cream cheese base, which I was unsure about at first, but I'm very glad I did it because it is amazing! I'd rather have crushed pineapples than the big chunks but I still like to pineapple so it's all good . And with that hot honey. Drizzle on top. Yum Yum I'll be getting it every time I go to Sioux Falls.

Ordered two pizzas tonight, a custom 2-topp and a specialty. Pizza makers followed the special…read moreinstructions accurately with attention to detail. Pizzas came out fresh while I waited. Sadly, I got home to discover that one of the pizzas in our order was mistakenly switched out with another customer's. Even more sadly, the missing pie was the special preference of our 4 year old, who, being already sick and exhausted, promptly began weeping at the surprising absence of his anticipated pepperoni pizza. To our good fortune, manager Chris was professional and accommodating in making things right. In the end, lo and behold! we had a frozen pepperoni pizza buried in our chest freezer, so the evening ended rather satisfactorily! We'll certainly be returning before too long!

Driving through SD and looking for a quick bite, we came across this spot with good reviews and…read moredecided to give it a try. We walked up to the counter to order and chose to dine in. The place is fairly small with some seating available and was reasonably clean. The staff was friendly when taking our order, and it seemed to be a popular spot for pick-up orders. Our food came out pretty quickly. The pizza was decent, but I was secretly hoping for something that matched what we had on a previous trip to UT--it just didn't quite hit the same. The food was just not to our liking.

yummy and kaitlin is the best server!! she is a very hard worker!!! rockstar girl for sureread more

Great Pizza. We think it's the best in town. We love dining…read morein and carrying out too.

I ordered ham and pineapple got pepperoni and sausage. They closed in 20 minutes by the time I got…read morehome and they wouldn't even answer the phone call. Worst place to get a pizza in Sioux Falls. I recommend a highly against it. No accountability for their mistakes no way to get a hold of them. They just let the phone ring and ring

I'm a Godfather's fan, but this location was over-priced and under-staffed…read more The small (10") classic combo on original crust ($17.69) was enough for two because of all of the toppings and cheese. The mini (6") ham and pineapple pizza ($5.89) worked for my mom. They had a nice dining area with background music, a buffet bar and a soda dispenser, but the dining area and buffet bar were closed - most likely due to a staffing shortage. I only saw one employee, who was working hard to both man the counter and prepare pizzas on a somewhat busy day. This resulted in slow service at the counter. If I didn't love the pizza so much, I'd be going with two stars.

I haven't had a Godfathers pizza in way too long. His place is Sioux Falls and have ordered from…read morehere in the past. It was great today. I have my favorite pepperoni, Italian sausage, extra cheese, extra mushroom and black olives and thin crust. Took one bite and went ballistic tasty spicy just fantastic. I recommend this as far as you can go. Almost forgot, fantastic personal.