Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Darby's Pub and Marina

    5.0 (1 review)

    Darby's Pub and Marina Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Darby's Pub and Marina

    Recommended Reviews - Darby's Pub and Marina

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Small Town Tavern

    Small Town Tavern

    3.2(18 reviews)
    4.4 mi

    Unfortunately, this is the first time I have felt compelled to leave a negative review on a place…read more My boyfriend and I had high hopes for our Valentine's dinner at Small Town Tavern. We had never been, but our expectations fell drastically short. I ordered the endless crab legs and my boyfriend had the prime rib, both premium-priced entrees for the holiday, along with specialty drinks. The Valentine's promotion never mentioned that sharing wasn't allowed, and our waitress, although very kind, never stated it either. The issue arose when the manager came over and offered "refills" without clarifying she meant crab legs. Since both of our drinks were empty, we assumed she meant beverages. Instead of clarifying, she just gave us a look that made us feel as if we were stupid, which made the interaction uncomfortable. When we realized she was talking about crab legs, she asked if we both had ordered them. I said, "No, just me" but I also mentioned that my boyfriend had eaten a crab leg or two. In the moment, I didn't realize he hadn't actually even eaten any--he was just helping me crack them open. That's when she abruptly told us we weren't supposed to be sharing. If there is a strict no-sharing policy, it should be clearly communicated in the promotion or at the table beforehand. Being corrected mid-meal, especially in a dismissive tone, took away from what was supposed to be a special Valentine's experience. Clearer communication and a more welcoming approach would go a long way.

    We ordered an appetizer (the famous long cheese stick)...it was so hard....you needed a steak knife…read moreto cut it. The shrimp in a basket was rock solid hard and tasteless (right out of a Costco bag of frozen shrimp) and the chicken was again...hard on the outside and dry on the inside. The asparagus was the width of yarn....and stringy overcoked and the "smashed golden potatoes" were scooped with an ice cream scoop....ala the elementary school cafeteria. Ordered a glass of wine ..asked for it 3 times and it finally arrived mid meal. Good luck to them. No where to.g but up.

    Photos
    Small Town Tavern - Pierogie flatbread

    Pierogie flatbread

    Small Town Tavern
    Small Town Tavern

    See all

    White Barn Supper Club - Steak and chicken combo salad

    White Barn Supper Club

    4.6(19 reviews)
    2.7 mi

    This is the best steak in the area! The potatoes are huge and are a filling meal in itself. I love…read morethe asparagus and the carrots. I usually don't rave about vegetables but these veggies are worth the 5 stars alone. The restaurant is very clean with ample seating. Make a reservation if you have a larger party. I love the staff here. We always have a great experience!

    We were attending a basketball game in the area and wanted to grab dinner, so we stumbled upon…read morewhite barn supper club. It reminds me of an old school mom and pop place - there's a u-shaped bar when you walk in the door with some tables around to the left and a small room to your right with additional tables. It was pretty clear when we walked in that it's a local favorite - we felt like everyone knew we were not local. But that dissipated quickly when a waitress greeted us and took us to a table. They were quite busy on a Friday evening, but the service was relatively quick once we got started. My daughter got the pierogies and I ordered the filet. Each of our meals came with a side salad - and let me tell you, that "side" salad could have been a meal itself. Not only was it large, it was a good variety of veggies and black olives. My daughter also ordered a side of meatballs and they were just okay - there was something about the taste and texture that neither of us liked nor could we pinpoint what was turning us off exactly. They almost tasted stale. The pierogies were delicious, including the browned onions. My filet had a nice sear and was cooked medium rare as I ordered, but it has a bit of an oily coating that was a little off putting. The flavor was good, but I prefer my steak with a little seasoning. The asparagus was overcooked and mushy, but the baked potato was massive and cooked to perfection. The amount of food you get is substantial. I'd definitely go back and try some other menu options or get the pierogies again!

    Photos
    White Barn Supper Club
    White Barn Supper Club - Now that is meatloaf!!!

    Now that is meatloaf!!!

    White Barn Supper Club - Fish sandwich and onion rings

    See all

    Fish sandwich and onion rings

    Darby's Pub and Marina - bars - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...