This was my first time visiting! With restrictions/limitations on meat during COVID, my wife and I…read moredecided to explore our other (local) options. After looking through the website, we called ahead to see if we could get a whole Fore Quarter Bundle (cuts from the front). I think there was a miscommunication. After doing a walk-in, we were told they also cap in person orders at $300. This meant, we could only get the half version. Still a lot of meat! So this was my take-away for those who might be in a similar situation. 1. Whether you order online or do a walk-in, your order is capped at $300 (obviously this could change). 2. My understanding is that you can also buy your choice of the offered cuts, but you might want to call ahead to verify. 3. Only three customers (not 3 parties, actual counts of people) are allowed in the store at a given time (at least as of 5/16). Yes, there might be a line outside; but I appreciated the current rule so that there was space inside the store. 4. Customers were masked up, but not employees. In fairness, they looked like they were keeping everything clean. 5. I'm under the impression that the beef is Grassfed (grainfed prior to butcher). I'm not 100% on this. 6. You won't necessarily get exact weights for everything you buy, but I believe our bundle was a good market price. Definitely cheaper than even some of the retailers that provide good quality affordable meat. The chuck roast we had (first night!) was good quality. So the short: good value for what you pay. 7. I was impressed with both the variety and quantity. So if you're frustrated with grocery store caps, you might want to check this place out. 8. Regarding the online ordering. It's great that they offer it. But for first timers (like me), I'd probably recommend walk-in. The online ordering may take a week or more to fill. But when you're in the store, you can get an idea of your options. I hope this is a helpful list of things for people in the Indy area looking for a good value. I think this local business gives you options!

the older black man was very aggressive and confrontational for no reaso. I go there monthly and…read morethe owner is usually take care of us with the bundle of meat that we switch out. The employees that work there today was very disrespectful and I never want to recommend anyone at this shop unless you are talking with the owner. I'm going to consult with him about this because i spend a lot of money here and unfortunately I never want to again due to the disrespect I just received today.... spend your money somewhere else due to the non professional staff they have.

Paid $50 for 6 kabobs with 2 of those being a meal with 2 drinks. Didn't have lamb. Didn't have the…read moresauce we wanted and ran out of fries, but didn't tell us until after we paid. They didn't even bring it to our attention. We had to ask. Tried to compensate with a pie which my husband can't eat. He left still hungry. Their communication is rough. Food is good, but we travelled an hour just for them to not have half of what we ordered.

I got the 5 skewer box I chose beef. The meat had a fair amount of gristle and fat on them. They…read morewere over cooked and bitter from the burnt pieces. We got cilantro lime rice, which had no flavor. Sauces had no flavor. Price was high for no more than what you got.

Best meat market around with amazing service! Wouldn't go anywhere else! Love Bill's meat!read more

Purchased 3 lbs of liver on Thursday for a Saturday luncheon for family. A family favorite - liver…read moreand onions! After preparing the sides, the liver was fried and we all sat down. First bite had everyone spitting it out in their napkins! It has a very peculiar and nasty taste so no one ate it. Returned to the store and was told that there would be no refund since it was bought on Thursday and not prepared til Saturday. Then she added that it was cut on Monday and should have been used sooner. She told me to take it with me since they didn't have a way to get rid of it. I told her it was HER problem and walked out. We believe to shop in our hometown and support small, independent businesses. This was a $15 lesson and a ruined family meal.

Service & selection is always top-notch! Old fashioned butcher shop combined with a cheese & meat…read moredeli case. They don't really make any sandwiches but can cut & slice meats to order and have some of the best prepped meatballs and frozen meats around. Just get back the Bison Italian Sausages, please! Next time you are prepping for a grill session I highly recommend Kincaid's, particularly the SoBro location on Illinois Street in the heart of Butler-Tarkington! Cheese & proteins awaits!

I don't know what they put in the marinade for their flank steak but I think it might be crack…read more That stuff is absolutely delicious. We generally get one every other week or so. Don't need to season it out it on the hot grill for a few minutes each side, slice and serve. The potatoes in the picture came from there too because I was running late and didn't have time to walk across the street. One of our favorite local businesses to support.

I bought a prime rib for Easter dinner and everyone remarked that they've never had better - better…read morethan eating out! Excellent service!!

Went here for the first time today. Was introduced to Banter's sausages from my in-laws. Clean and…read morenot smelly at all. Reasonable prices. Fantastic customer service. I am disabled in a wheelchair and they were very kind and patient with me. I will be back. Thank you foe a great experience. -

Shoup Catering was a MUST have for our wedding. We love their food and knew all of our guest would…read morelove it too. We were happy to be invited to their great office space to plan out our wedding day. They lead us step by step through all the options for the cocktails, appetizers, entrees, and cake. The only problem we had was trying to choose between so many great options. Skip to the wedding day, Shoup's showed up in full force! I was amazed with the amount of people the had to help out with the bar and catering. After the ceremony, we got our much needed first taste of our speciality cocktails. (side note: I had asked the On The Rocks staff to try to replicate a cocktail I had at a downtown bar. Kailey somehow got the exact recipe from the bar, and it was PERFECT) We went with the hand passed appetizers, which I would suggest because it let everyone socialize. The best part about being the bride and groom is that you get to go first in line for dinner. Shoup's bought a ton of food and no one went hungry that night. We also appreciated that Shoup's could do our wedding cake in with the package, and it was the best cake I have every had at a wedding. Lastly, go for the late night snack option. We did BBQ sliders. Special shout out to Janna Stillwell our wedding coordinator, she checked to make sure we had everything we needed. She was helping with even non catering related things. I remember commenting to my wife that Janna would have ran through a wall for us if we needed it. Our advice: call Shoup's, pick you favorite things, and let them take care of the rest.

My husband and I chose Shoups to cater our wedding, and we were not disappointed. Janna was the…read moreabsolute best to work with, she even grabbed us at our reception and made sure we ate. ;) We were more than happy with the food, the service, and the presentation. If you want an affordable caterer who will provide delicious, quality food and wonderful service, Shoups is for you! I highly recommend everyone support this local business.

Came here for the first time, was a wonderful experience. They sell chicken, lamb/goat, all types…read moreof fish, and more meats. The store was clean, spacious, and was definitely very hygienic. The two employees upfront were extremely kind and helpful. I asked about their food and they showed me what the different meats looked like, and explained their various pre seasoned and marinated meats that they had ready-to-go. Definitely recommend coming here!

Hours are a little off (closed Monday and Tuesday) and this is the other butcher shop in Avon…read more Walked in, immediately greeted by the owner, she was totally cool with us looking around figuring what we wanted. Any questions we had she immediately responded. Everything looked so fresh we ordered some "better butter burgers" and some premade salads (ham, pasta, potato). Cooked the burgers on the grill to a perfect medium so good. Love supporting our local butcher shop. Gold cleaver is where it's at!

The place is small inside but they pack a bunch to check out. I purchased 2 choice ribeyes, 2…read moresmoked chops, some smoked bacon and shrimp. I am normally a big steak cooker, but wow, were those chops tender and smoked great. The bacon had some SERIOUS smoke on them. i ended up slicing the bacon into finger bites as an appetizer. The next time im back i will of course stop here to get what i need.