The outside of Custard Castle is like going back in time to your childhood of summer nights when you were so excited to get an ice cream treat! The staff was extremely friendly even though they were closing in 10 minutes, the two women who waited on us asked us if we wanted whipped cream, cherries etc, very thoughtful and thorough! They seemed to work as a team which is important at a small business! My hot fudge sundae was everything it should be, cold ice cream melting under hot fudge with a cherry marinating until the end. My boyfriend got a chocolate soft serve with chocolate jimmies and it was loaded with both. So glad we got there before they closed!!! read more

Custard Castle - Hot fudge sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

See all

Since it changed owners, it's not worth it. Very expensive for cheap very small custard & the frozen yogurt was like ice milk. I also got a pup cup. It wasn't a normal pup cup. It was just a little bit of ice cream. No peanut butter no bone that's a first. Especially, for the price. read more

Great ice cream! Love their soft serve dipped in chocolate or cherry hard shell. Really nice staff and reasonable prices. There can be longer lines during prime evenings like Friday and Saturday. read more

Delicious hot fudge sundae! Highly recommend. Enjoy your ice cream outside at the quaint picnic benches.

Ordered a large waffle cone with three scoops got a broken cone and my scoop on top was so small i wouldn't even consider it a scoop they also claim homemade all my flavors tasted identical to box grocery store ice cream read more

We love ice cream. We love soft serve but don't eat it often. Custard Castle is the bomb. Great soft serve ice cream not the plastic stuff like Kohrs and Rita's. Two windows the line moves quickly. Easy to park and very clean property. Split a medium dish of vanilla custard with my wife, more than enough for two. It's our favorite custard stand. read more

I was there last weekend and purchased the exact same items and I was charged less than this time around. Also the cups got smaller. Not my first time buying from here. When I questioned why they were smaller/different I was told they always been this size. Not true but sure - whatever. Last time I shop here. Mr. Bills is more consistent and pricing is true to what you get. read more

The best custard and if you like sugar free. Their hard dipped is by far the greatest. Cannot wait to go back

Rocky p o l o c a r p o is a good man him and his wife run the Custer stand with their daughter and it's great ice cream good place to go fun place to visit living Legacy over 75 years if you're getting ice cream and it's soft serve you better be at Custer Castle from April to October straight up James Ryan us singing marine! read more

SOOOO GOOD get the banana ice cream you won't regret it! Great service, will be coming back! read more

Custard Castle - Banana ice cream with chocolate dip and strawberry ice cream with sprinkles SOO GOOD - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

Always had a great experience at Custard Castle. Friendly attentive staff;great Ice Cream! :-)

Horrible experience everytime! I've taken my kids here several times over past few years ( only because it's close by!) Rude staff, sketchy clientele & so close to highway & noise, it's like having ice cream by the freeway! I now drive 5 miles further to loyds country custard in EHT, so much better, nicer & worth the ride! read more

This is one of my favorite places to get soft serve ice cream from. Their soft serve is very creamy and good. Their milkshakes and sundaes are other favorites of mine. I have been going here for a few summers now. The staff has always been friendly and accommodating. read more

Custard Castle - Vanilla Chocolate twist - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

Custard Castle and Route 322, perfect together... You can't go wrong with anything you order; the soft serve is really creamy, and the hot fudge sundaes are delish. The people that work there always have a smile on their face, are they doing a lot of sampling in the back room? read more

Custard Castle - the front of custard castle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

I always get a chocolate shake...Always I like it thick and very chocolatey (chocolatey that's a word right)? It is so thick They asked if I wanted a spoon? You got to love that "a spoon" Anyway that's how they make them here and I love that. The cones are big and a little pricey, but you get what you pay for. read more

Custard Castle is a bit of a tradition in my family. As we traveled down to my grandparents' house in Ocean City, NJ dozens of times each summer my father would utilize back roads as opposed to the AC Expressway/Garden State Turnpike route. These roads were - and remain - way less congested and more scenic, often just as fast if not faster than the previously mentioned route and can cut back on your toll expenditure. That being said, if you end up taking 322/the Black Horse Pike towards Ocean City or Sea Isle you will inevitably roll by many fun little shops and restaurants (and strip clubs) some of which time have forgotten, many of which are abandoned. One of these is THE Custard Castle. Now that my story is out of the way... The Custard Castle is a fairly standard independently owned (?) ice cream shack with a massive menu of cool treats and even some hot eats. You got your soft serve, hard ice cream, milk shakes, blizzards, sundaes, hot dogs, pretzels, etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. I recently returned and service remains friendly and the ice cream remains inexpensive. I highly recommended getting off the major highway at some point. See the local sights, get some ice cream and have a more relaxed drive down to the shore. P.S. I never would have suspected an ice cream shop from my childhood in the middle-of-nowhere New Jersey would be my 200th review! read more

Custard Castle - West side of the castle which you would see as you head down the shore. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

See all

We love it here, We always look forward to opening season! We always stop here throughout the summer!

Good ice cream, I loved that they have a sugar free option. I paid $12 for a banana split with a medium chocolate & vanilla soft serve w sprinkles. read more

Custard Castle - Chocolate & Vanilla soft serve w/ sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

New Jersey has many custard hut's and ice cream parlors to sample. This is one of the best. Traveling home to Pennsylvania today, I stopped in and ordered a chocolate/peanut butter malt. Best I've ever had. Seriously, if you like chocolate & peanut butter mixes, order one. Be sure to get it with malt powder added. Insanely good. Thank you read more

Amazing ice creams and a lot of choices i got the hand dipped cherry vanilla soft serve and it was awesome but be careful i got the medium thinking that it was not gonna be to much but it was a lot and messing but delicious. read more

Custard Castle - Medium vanilla cherry dip don't get it twisted its alot trust me. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

I get the strawberry smoothie every time and 100% of the time I love it. I can't give 5 stars bc I don't eat anything else. read more

Custard Castle - The taste is just right. Not too bland and not like your sipping a jar of strawberry jam. Strawberry smoothie on point. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me

Omg I love the ice cream here. And the prices are great. Handmade ice cream. And my puppy loves it too. The Miller Crew! read more