I don't leave reviews very often, but this place is so good and everyone is always so kind. There…read moreisn't a better pizza place anywhere around like this. Best pizza in Rochester area and nicest staff. 10/10 all around

I ordered 5 large pizzas and 2 GF pizzas and they were all great! Although the GF pizza had a…read morethin crust - as they usually do - the amount of toppings on was perfect. I order lunch for work and everyone enjoyed them. We go there often - thanks Pizza D Poseidon Systems

This review is for "Locals on the Lake" upstairs from "The Pizza Stop", same building restaurant…read morebar upstairs, takeout pizza downstairs. I'm telling you, the owner loves his business as the quality has not darkened in years... That is rare. So we ordered one of the new menu items (Chicken Parm, char broiled (bc my wife says I have to be healthy) and the meat lovers pizza with ricotta. AMAZING! We can't go there without ordering fresh pizza bc that is nirvana. The Chicken Parm did not need breading! Crusty and juicy, these people know what they are doing! And they make a lot of sauces there, the one with the Chicken Parm, was a perfect compliment to the HOMEMADE pasta and chicken. Drinks were generous and reasonable. Great service! Ya know what, I shouldn't be sharing this gem... Okay pay no attention!

Best pizza we've had since Lombardi's in NYC. Oven baked BUT it had the smokiness of a coal fired…read moreoven. Service was excellent. Laid back feel of a small American lake town.

I ordered pizza yesterday and the crust in the bottom was burnt! The sauce was different that I've…read moretasted before for the sweet and tangy. I don't know if it wasn't because there was enough for I'm not sure. I did get there early so I just had to wait. The place looks clean and it's just dark in there.

Wings were tasty but the pizza was awful. It was doughy and under cooked. The crust was way too…read morethick and the toppings were raw. Very disappointed.

For $21.25, I did think the fish fry would be crispy fresh scrumptious. Nope. It didn't have any…read moretime to sit and wait for me, I was there when it was ready. Soggy.

Great place to go with a. Group- easy seating great selection of pizza!…read moreSuper generous on the toppings! Parking on street Service was friendly

The service was wonderful. Our food was brought out to us and they even offered to pick up our…read moreplates when we finished eating. The dining area was comfy and had various seating options. The food was pretty good but for the price of the subs I wish they were a little bit bigger. The ciabatta bread was soft and fresh; but it wasn't big enough for the meat portion and you were left with a lot of saucy bread at the end. For the price I wish they gave you an additional cutlet on the sandwich. I really enjoyed the flavor of the sauce. Definitely a place to try again, but I do wish they gave you more in terms of portion size.

I agree with those reviewers who said that this nice establishment is a gem of a pizza place. I…read morehave been here once had a wonderful experience. I like me some good Detroit-style pizza and when I found out about this restaurant and their pizza by the slice offerings, I had to check it out. Located in a shopping center, this casual pizzeria is mostly a take-out joint but there is a small dine-in area. They serve pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and salads. They also sell pizza and pasta sauces as well as house-made pasta to be cooked at home. I was interested in having their pizza by the slice, so that's what I ordered on my visit. I got one slice of their Meatball Parmesan with red sauce and one slice of Greek Chicken with basil pesto base. After ordering the food, I noticed a sign for lunch special that included a slice of pizza, a beverage of your choice, and a cookie which was good until 3 PM. I inquired about it (it was about 10 mins. after 3 PM) and the owner/ manager gentleman honored that deal for me. That was great of him. I really appreciated that. I forgot the gentleman's name, but it was good to chat with him about his pizza shop. The pizza was fresh and delicious. I was in pizza heaven with each bite of these pizza, especially while enjoying the Meatball Parmesan pizza. That was da bomb. The Greek Chicken was good too but I preferred the Meatball one better. I had some leftover of the Greek Chicken which I had later on with some pizza sauce later and it tasted great. I really liked The Pizza Shoppe a lot. I highly recommend checking it out. They are very good and I look forward to going back there sometime again.

First time trying Fire in Main... the oven looked promising but the pizza was soggy by the time we…read moregot it home Tasty toppings but crust didn't quite have the chewiness and crispness that we were looking for Meatballs were a bit underwhelming for $18! The place was packed thought so maybe next time we'll try to eat in and see if the quality of the crust improves

We come to this restaurant nearly every week and have never had a bad meal. The staff are all very…read morefriendly and provide excellent service. We never leave hungry and always have a great time.

GREAT pizzas! We tried the buffalo chicken and one with pepperoni & sausage. It was excellent! What…read moremakes this Pontillo's even better is the location! Grab a pizza and walk down to the canal. If you're lucky, you will find live jazz and a bench to eat your pizza on. Also worth noting: if it's hot, do not plan to eat inside--but there is good air conditioning in the restroom.

I ordered delivery from them, last week. It was pretty good pizza. The crust was very chewy which I…read moredidn't hate. We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni extra cheese and light sauce. It was still pretty saucy so I'm glad I ordered light sauce. I wouldn't order from here regularly but it was decent. It was priced around the same as other places I just prefer more. I'm still trying to find my favorite Rochester pizza...

This is a very cool place. Friendly, knowledgeable staff that are flexible on making menu changes…read more Several coffees, including seasonal pumpkin. A complete yummy line of amazing grains bread, donuts, brownies, muffin tops and more. Tuesday is Amazing Grains Pizza day. I'll have to check this out! Paninis, wraps, salads and more. Inside, Outside and porch seating. Easy parking in their lot. Looking forward to going back

Good little cafe spot in Mendon. The food is good, but a tad pricey for what it is. I'm not sure if…read morethere is even a full kitchen. Food took a good deal of time to be made and no free or discounted refills on coffee.

Great food, Great service, Good prices. A nice place to go for lunch.What more could one want.read more

Local homemade delicious pizza! Highly recommend. Thick crust, lots of sauce and cheese!read more

We absolutely love getting pizza from here. The employees are always working so hard to get food…read moreorders out and help people grab quick items from the small grocery section. It's a nice little place to grab hersheys ice cream in the warmer months as well. We are very lucky to have this in our neighborhood.

Let me start by saying how happy I am that I found this little place called Pizza Sangiorgi…read more Everyone that works here, is overtly friendly and accommodating. I can admit that I'm a pain when it comes to ordering pizza and the guys who make them, always make me feel like it's no trouble at all. I'm originally from NJ where there are a few different styles of pizza. My favorite, is a super thin bar pie. Sangiorgi has a special thin pizza on their menu that I ask to make cracker thin. They never disappoint. They use quality ingredients and their pizza sauce is not sweet at all. That's another win for me because I'm not a fan of a sweet red/pizza sauce. The pizza is reasonably priced and it's a very good pizza. If you're not into a cracker thin pizza like me, just order their regular pizza. The friendly and extremely accommodating staff bumps Sangiorgi up one star.