The owner's response does not address the substance of the review…read more A customer was told by the owner, in person, that a piece of seafood was fresh that day. It was not. It tasted old and should not have been sold. The tomahawk issue was about quality, not price. A steak that is overwhelmingly fat reflects poor product quality. The handling of the situation by deflecting to personal integrity rather than addressing these issues is what readers should note.

I saw this small butcher shop and decided to stop in and take a look. I'm so happy I did! They had…read morea great selection of meat, chicken and fish and it was all very fresh. I bought a pound of their homemade tuna salad and was VERY impressed by the taste and quality! It is truly the best tuna salad I have ever had! It's the old fashioned tuna salad with sweet pickle relish and hard boiled eggs. The tuna itself is the white albacore tuna so it doesn't taste fishy or have that "canned cat food"smell. It beat Krogers, Whole Foods and Paneras tuna salad by miles. Highly recommend if you're looking for great tuna salad.

This is a butcher not a restaurant and it's one of the best, they have such good quality meats! And…read moreI really like the guys here. Prices are comparable to grocery store meat but the quality is better. Super clean. Great service,they treat you right .

Very nice. Asked and received answers. Appreciated that they took their time out for me.read more

Normally, this butcher shop makes sandwiches but put up a sign that said no sandwiches till after…read morethe holidays. It is a standard butcher shop with lots of quality meats and cheeses in display. Can't wait to come back and try their sandwiches No sandwiches so I took away a star

I love this store!!! All their meats are so fresh and delicious, unlike supermarket cuts! Meat…read moreStore offers custom cuts too as well as a vast selection of deli meats, cheeses & salads. There are also fresh frozen meals! I highly recommend this place! Very friendly staff too!

I don't think I can say enough great things about the Brookville Butcher! I apologized in advance…read morefor taking my sister there for a visit. I told her that if she purchased the cheddar brats that she would end up dreaming about them after they were gone. She called me a few days later after preparing them to tell me that I was right. The meat is affordable, the work area is extremely clean and they such a great variety of fresh meat. It feels like you're rewinding 30 years and going back to an old school deli. I have tried the hamburger mixed with bacon and cheddar, the cheddar brats and the ham salad. Whoa that ham salad it's not your cheap typical processed ham salad. From the freezer case I have also purchased the prepared lasagna they make in small individual servings that you can just pop in the oven yourself and it was great. There's such a cool variety of breaded mushrooms, hot wings and stuffed chicken breasts in the frozen section and things that you could take home for special occasions, parties or just when you want some special items that you typically won't find in a "normal" grocery store in bulk quantity. They also have freezer packs for set pricing where you can go in and buy a certain number of steaks, pork chops, pounds of fresh sausage or pounds of hamburger altogether in a package brown sack that you can just take home and stick in your freezer. I've also started purchasing gift cards here for family members and they always called to tell me thanks at least more than once because it's such a special experience.

Love it. Top notch meats and people and groceries! Butchers friendly and helpful and assortment of…read morestuff is great.

Im super weird about ground beef, I don't like it most of the time but I was craving a burger so I…read morestopped in. The meat looked fresh and so I grabbed 4 burger patties. I cooked 2 that night, they made the most delicious cheeseburgers and used the rest to make tacos the next night. Everything was delicious! This is my new to go spot for meat!

Rib Roast we ordered for Easter dinner was excellent. Pricey but great. We have reordered from…read morethere and each time the meat was delicious. Just ge prepared for the price.

Good meat products and friendly service. The breakfast sausage meat was well seasoned. The…read morebreakfast links were my favorites. Store had many marinades and rubs. Quite a good wine selection also. Nice experience.

Let's talk about how Matt handled a dying cow on his farm. Clubbed it in the head, walked away…read more Several hours later, it's still alive. Wouldn't shoot it. I have no interest in shopping somewhere that can't even treat their animals humanely.

If you're looking for humanely raised and quality poultry and pork you are in the right place…read more These farmers genuinely care about the quality of life they give their animals and it shows on the dinner table. The chicken is fresh and free of any unnecessary additives. Taking the farm tour was neat and I highly recommend it. You'll learn how animals that are able to roam benefit not only themselves but also the soil. Hopefully these guys lead the way in the future of farming. Check em out!

From the owner: We specialize in pastured chicken, thanksgiving turkeys and woodlot raised pork. We sell at farmers…read moremarkets, through local delivery groups which are open to anyone, and allow on farm order pickup with a preorder twice a month. Details are on our website.

This place is absolutely amazing. I love sausages, and the Hungarian Butcher makes the best I've…read moreever had. So far I've tried the spicy smoked Hungarian sausage, their brats, and a custom made South African sausage. All were top notch. They also have other select meat cuts as well, which I'm sure are just a flavorsome. I'm so happy Columbus has a place like this to add diversity to the city's food scene.

Extremely over priced and lack flavor, really miss the ole ohio meat market downtown theyhad the…read morebest sauce meat

This has been high on my list of places to visit for a long time. It didn't disappoint and was a…read morespecial place. It was smaller than I had imagined but it packs a mighty punch. The food - A lot of variety of sandwiches to choose from. My Turkey sandwich was packed with meat that overwhelmed the regular slices of bread. I had to add to it to bring flavor to it and would recommend adding thicker slices of bread to it. The baked were good. Loved the variety of fruit options, frozen items, fresh meat, and other things to try out. Garden section - Didn't know this existed in here. A variety of plants and flowers to choose from. Customer service- It was top notch from the counter and front store cashiers. Everyone was nice and on point. They kept lines moving which I appreciated too. So this is on my store rotation to try new things here!

We pulled up to a line out the door. Seems like a good sign if that many people are interested. As…read morewe wove our way to the front of the line, several items in the store caught my attention. Several of the sauces look worth a taste. We arrived at the front of the line, and the line remained out the door. We ordered a corned beef on rye and a roast beef on white. We found our new favorite sandwich place. Total was $15.90 paid in cash. The bread was delicious. The meat was delicious. The veggies were fresh. The cheese was flavorful. We'll be back on a Thursday for the ribeye sandwich. We'll be back for the burger, the pork chop, and the ribs. There is a menu full of items we want to try because the deli sandwich was great. Highly recommend!

Looking for a butcher shop near us without astronomical pricing. We understand the difference…read morebetween the butcher shops and large chain stores with quality and are open to paying some extra. With this we ended up at Smith Family Farms Market on Saturday and purchased 3 beef filets for grilling on Father's Day. The service was great and the people were very friendly and helpful. BUT, the best part was the steaks. These were by far the best steaks we had grilled in a long while. They melted in your mouth they were so tender. I braised them over high heat for 1 1/2 to 2 minutes on each side. Then grilled them for 8 minutes on each side. They were very thick and turned out beautiful with slight pink center (temperature was about 150° - 155°). As said they were so tender.. We've found a new go to. Our thanks to the people at Smiths for making our Father's Day meal special!!!

This review is for Either Friday or Saturday Oct 8/9, 2021…read more I will say we tried them because they had 5 stars, but sadly only 19 people have reviewed the place, so either they have had more who do not use yelp or others do not leave reviews, which may have made up a difference, for as long they have been in business. I usually like to look thins up before trying local business, especially family owned one's out. I am giving two dates because right now I do not recall which date my partner went in to give these folks a try. Since moving down here we have been looking for a new butcher to shop at as our business was with another local butcher where we lived, so we were could frequent the butcher over store products as 9 times out of 10 butches product is fresher and better depending where you go. So like stated we wanted to give this location a try for the first time. Due to my current health situation with esrd, we tend to not go My partnered had picked up some jerky, a pork shoulder, and Italian sausages. So overall the jerky was ok, and everyone makes their jerky different, but I personally did not care for it, in cased asked why, it was too tough than what I am use to from others. The Italian Sausages, I will say I loved, and will definitely get more if and when we stop in again. Now the reason for 3 stars, I based on both the Pork shoulder and how customer service was handled. I would have given an extra star, but issue was not handled appropriately. I understand this is family ran, I understand how a business is to be ran as I had one for several years, I have as well watched a butcher work their business up north where I am from. The way this location handled issues when my partner called in is not customer service like. I am unsure if regulars get better care than new customers is all I am going to say there. My partner phoned in and the following happen: "She informed about the pork shoulder, was told "we have never had that kind of issue here" Rather than I am sorry and own up to the issue as if we were making something up, we got that and a store credit. So the way the pork shoulder was packaged was as follows: Saran wrap like plastic, and then wrapped in the white like paper. When unwrapping it on Sat or Sunday as it was never frozen, it was suppose to be fresh, I asked what the foul smell was, it was the pork shoulder. I am unsure if the meat was just going bad and this is why this was pushed over the tenderloin we wanted or what the issue was. To owners and staff, we may give you a try again in the near future, and then I will update this review, but until then this is my honest review of our experience of our first time with you guys. I wish it had gone better.