Corey is a lovable teddy bear. His baking is full of love that you can taste in every bite. His cakes are beautiful but true reason to pick this bakery for a cake is they are flavorful/ moist with unique choices. I am partial to the cookies he bakes. Don't ask which one. Try them all! read more

Bagels were large and flavorful. Had a nice chew. Cream cheese was of good quality and a portions were adequate. Could have used a little more toasting. read more

We absolutely LOVE Corey's Bakery AND Corey!! He makes amazing cakes that look great and taste delicious!! I always look forward to his services every birthday!! I have attached my son's latest birthday cake!! "67"!!! read more

Corey's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

I wanted to give a shoutout to Corey's Bakery! We wanted a coconut cheesecake and he stepped it up by putting the cheesecake on the bottom and the cream pie on top! Absolutely delicious. This made my birthday so much better. This is our second pie from him and definitely won't be our last! Thank you COREY! read more

Corey's Bakery - Cheesecake coconut cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

Food was good and service was ok too. Great assortment of dishes and drinks was busy They are family oriented read more

Our Huge water Theme birthday cake was Unbelievable !!! Once Again Corey did his Magic! Wish I had birthday every month... yummy!!! All of our friends and guests said the cake was the most deliciously memorable....We Still Talk about it!!! Truly unforgettable taste! read more

Corey's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Corey made our wedding cake back in 2015, and let me tell you - NO cake has ever come close. I've been to big cities tasting some of the most well-known bakeries, but Corey's cake is still always my favorite. Corey made all completely custom flavors for our wedding cake - and all were incredibly delicious. He also completely nailed the design I wanted. Literally - the cake of my dreams! Oh, did I mention that Corey himself is just an absolute delight? He is a warm, friendly guy who truly cares for his customers. First day you meet him, he treats you like family. Now, it would be silly of me to do a review of an experience from nearly 6 years ago. It would be a little irrelevant. Good thing I can tell you I have had more recent experiences, and they have all been just as fabulous. We asked him last year for our 5th anniversary if he could recreate our wedding cake layers. I realized in the shuffle of everything that we only tried 1 layer of the 3 custom flavors we chose. He made 3 small versions of each layer, and they were all spectacular. And even more recently, my cousin just used him for her wedding cake. I have zero idea what the flavor was. I know she walked me through it, and my initial impression of the flavors they chose wasn't very good. Not like they were terrible, it was just personal preferences - flavors I typically don't like. I have NO idea what they placed in front of me last night, but all I can tell you is it was DELICIOUS. Corey has consistently made the best cake I've ever had for the past 6 years. Oh... I should add. My cousin asked for a naked cake, and he did a spectacular job. The cake was stunning. read more

I ordered a birthday cake from here as a treat to myself. I just got the 8 inch champagne vanilla cake. The cakes are on the moderate priced size so definitely for me a splurge but worth it. I saw reviews raving about the vanilla champagne cake. I am more of a chocolate person but wanted to try this spin on vanilla cake. I shared w two of my friends. We all LOVED the cake. Eating my second piece as we speak. Really moist and flavorful. Be careful looking up the location as waze still has it in Palm Harbor but it's in NPR. Definitely worth the splurge. I highly recommend the vanilla champagne. Happy birthday to me with this amazing sweet treat. read more

See all

My daughter and I went in for a tasting. The flavors were a feast for thetaste buds! And the atmosphere was right out of an episode of Bridgerton. We already have a plan for a special birthday cake with delicious flavors. read more

Rude Rude Rude Rude did I mention Rude Also very expensive for average cake. Had coconut flavor in frosting I did not order! read more

When you want something, that no one else has thought of, call Corey! When you want a flavor combination that is not on the "regular" menu, call Corey! If you want something you saw, but haven't found locally, call Corey! Are you sensing a pattern? I have had several cakes created by Corey, ALL were amazing, ALL were different, and ALL were delicious. Corey has the courage to go over and above what others would say no to, Corey says "sure, why not?" read more

I really don't like sweets, I know that's weird to some people but I do love a few and a coconut cream pie is one of them. My husband found Corey's bakery and the reviews were awesome so for my birthday he ordered one and surprised me! When I tell you it's the best coconut cream pie would be a understatement.. Absolutely delicious.. Even with the delay because of the hurricane it was worth the wait! Awesome job read more

was probably the best cake I have Ever had! Corey was so accommodating and personable. His attention to detail was Amazing!!! I will definitely go back again for every occasion! Trust me, you will not be disappointed read more

See all

Cory recently provided the back and cupcakes for our wedding on May 4th 2024. Everyone loved the cake and cupcakes. Our expectations definitely exceeded!! read more

Got my daughters cake from here and it was amazing!! We got the Vanilla champagne flavor read more

Corey's Bakery - W - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

My friend order her wedding cake from here and it was super tasty! I would for sure come back here and would recommend to a friend too!

Corey provided us with the most beautiful wedding cake for my daughters wedding! Not only was the vanilla champagne absolutely delicious, the presentation and design was beautiful. We got so many compliments, there wasn't a single piece left by the end of the weekend :-) read more

Corey made the cake for my husband's surprise birthday party. It was exactly the way I pictured it. And it tasted great. Our guests complimented on how cool it looked and how moist and tasty it was. Thanks Corey! read more

Corey's Bakery - Custom cake made by Corey. - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Amazing! Corey did our wedding cake this past weekend. Not only was it beautiful, but it was delicious!

First I want to say that I had to send my contact at least 4 times and was tired of not getting a response. When I finally got a response, I was excited to sit down for my wedding cake tasting which cost me $25.00. I had no problem with this but assumed the cake would be great because of the fee. Honestly I was disappointed from the time we got there. We came in and prior to getting there was slightly late due to traffic- the sous chef sassed us stating that she lived in that area and cannot understand that we would have traffic. I knew this was bad but still wanted to continue to go forward with the tasting. During the tasting we were asked if we wanted wanted and we declined. We also noticed that the glasses were quite dusty as if they haven't been washed in months. The sous chef was rude and had a very bad attitude about everything. We tried a few flavors which were like vanilla, chocolate and one other flavor which I can't remember. I was informed by the sous chef that I didn't submit photos which I had 3 other times. I showed and emailed photos and everything I wanted was an up charge. I wanted a cake when a stenciled layer which just requires additional icing in that stencil- up charge. If you want fillings upcharge. If you want different flavors than vanilla chocolate or marble upcharge. It was disappointing of the service we got since it was a suggested place by our venue which included our wedding cake up to $500. I can say the cake was dry and so was the service. read more

If you're looking for a bakery that holds customer service and respectful discussion to a gold standard, LOOK ELSEWHERE! This bakery made it seem like doing their job was an inconvenience and was extremely rude to my fiancé over email when just asking about their service. To us, being a kind and caring person is very important and speaks about the quality of the person. This bakery should be ashamed of how they treat customers and should never make a bride feel like an inconvenience. Save yourself the negativity of these people and find a bakery that holds customer respect to high values. read more

Corey was rude and My wedding cake was humiliating. It was small and sad for $400. I was so embarrassed. 2 years later and I'm still so disappointed about it. read more

First bakery tried in the area outside of the typical Wal mArt/Publix cake. Loved it. German Chocolate cake was done to perfection. Great customer service. Will definitely use Corey as our bakery. read more

Corey and Stacey did an awesome job. I gave them a last minute order, of a cake for my daughters baby shower. The cake was absolutly beautiful. Better than I expected. Everyone made comments about it at the party. Then we served it. Corey makes his own vanilla. It's his signature flavor. Iwas without a doubt the best cake I ever tasted. The cake was gone in minutes. I will never go anywhere else for cake. Thank you so much! read more

My daughter asked for a steampunk themed birthday cake. I asked for something amazing, but affordable (oh and then to incorporate something cat). Corey's Bakery was accommodating, price was affordable, cake was beautiful AND delicious!!!! We'll definitely be ordering from here again! read more

See all

We had our wedding on Honeymoon Island 3/12/15. Corey made our cake and it was amazing!!! Everything that he bakes is mouth-watering and original. The design of the cake was also very beautiful! Thank you Corey for making our night that much "sweeter"! Love, Jamie and Casey read more

Corey's made the cake for my birthday party. Beautiful and delicious! My husband had planned a surprise party for me and Corey worked with him to produce the perfect cake for the party. Our guests were very impressed! read more

Yowzahs!!! This cake was aaaaaamazing! We are from Michigan and were going to be spending our son's 15th birthday down here in FL. I googled a specialty cakes place in Palm Harbor and found Corey. His reviews were great so we went with him. I'm a cake snob and always try to get the best and tastiest. In Michigan we use a bakery that won Cupcake Wars for our cakes. Let me just say that this cake blew them out of the water!! I've been looking for a bakery to "wow" me with their cakes and Corey, my friend, you did it!! This chocolate cake with Oreo frosting filling was like nothing I've tasted. It has some unique flavor that just sends my tastebuds soaring! Corey was super kind, hospitable and awesome to work with! Saying I highly recommend this bakery is an understatement. There's no question THIS IS THE BAKERY FOR YOUR EVENT!! I just can't say enough about how fabulous this cake was. I can only imagine what all the other goodies he makes are like! I always know when something is Good because it makes me stand up and dance and that's exactly what happened read more

Corey's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

I really can't thank him enough. The cake that he made was more than I ever could have wished for, he really gave me better than I could have imagined for myself, it took his eye and hands to make something truly magical. I will never be able to remember my wedding day without remembering that cake and the beautiful man who created it for me. I want everyone to know that he is an artist, a genius, a consummate professional and damn if that cake wasn't as delicious as it was gorgeous! Corey took my limited vision and expanded it into a thing of beauty. Not only is he the sweetest person on Earth anyone considering him for their cake would be hard pressed to find ANYONE and I do mean AN EE ONE better than this man. He's brilliant, his cakes are as beautiful as his heart. read more

I can tell passion when I see it. Today was my daughters 6th birthday and she is in love with sea life and especially our famous Winter the dolphin. After calling around I landed on Corey's Bakery. After talking with the girl who answered. Corey himself caught wind of the call and respectfully took over from there. We chatted for a minute and most of it was him going OFF on what he was about to create and how good it was going to be. I picked the cake up a few days later and was greeting by Corey who has even a better personality in person than he does on the phone. He showed us the cake and the presentation was spot on. It was beautifully crafted with two Dolphins, sea shells, and a some impressive shades of blue. It was a marble with butter cream and the dolphins were made out of homemade white chocolate. This man even makes his own vanilla extract. The taste was perfection. It was a huge hit and I highly recommend you let this make bake you something cause he's not playin' around in that little shop of his! Or maybe he does play idk. Somethin's goin' on in there. read more

Corey did a fantastic job on our wedding cake. He captured the look perfectly and the taste was beyond delicious. We had many veteran wedding guests complimenting the cake. Corey is very passionate about what he does and it shows through in his work. Highly recommended! read more

My fiancé and I attended a tasting with Chef Corey recently, and it was wonderful! We both agreed the Caribbean Cooler was our favorite, it was very original and tasted like key lime! We had a hard time narrowing down which flavors to choose for our 5 tier wedding cake, I am excited to our guests to be treated to our wedding cake! read more

We loved everything about Corey's bakery! They were so welcoming and helpful. We did our tasting with them for our wedding coming up, and it was delicious! Everything melts in your mouth and the different flavor choices are incredible! We would absolutely recommend them to anyone! read more

August 2015: Very pleased with our experience meeting Corey and tasting his cakes. I took a gamble on this business because of the location of the store in relation to our venue and even where we live, but I'm SO GLAD I decided to check out Corey's Bakery & Catering anyway. What drew me in was the unique list of flavors Corey has to offer on his website. He has some of the most unique flavors I have ever seen. Corey accommodated my very inflexible schedule and still managed to whip up a very professional, yet fun, tasting appointment and consultation. The first thing that grabbed our attention (besides the list of flavors), is the fact that everything Corey uses is all natural. He even makes his own vanilla extract! How's that for dedication to quality? The cakes he makes are amazing. So flavorful and definitely unique - they don't even need filling...you won't even find a list of fillings on his menu. Our biggest issue was trying to narrow down what flavors we wanted to use for our cake - so many to choose from that were all SO YUMMY! This was our first cake tasting and I knew we didn't need to go anywhere else. Corey is passionate about his work and we are so excited about working with him. We can't wait to see what he comes up with for our design too, as his cakes look just a wonderful as they taste! UPDATE: March, 2016: our cake was one of the only highlights of our reception. Truely saved the day after lousy food and a bad DJ. Our cake was gorgeous too. We left the entire design to Coreys discression, and it tasted phenomenal. Our guests couldn't compliment it enough. The unique flavors blew them away. I finally got to eat some leftovers last night.. Still as moist and amazing as it was three days ago! I wish I could give Corey and his blossoming business 10 stars! read more

Believe everything wonderful thing you read about Corey's Bakery. I started my search for a specialty cake 2 months before my daughter's college graduation and could not get any bakery to answer a phone, return calls or emails, or message on Facebook (yes, believe it or not, some of them did business just through Facebook). It was only 2 weeks away when Corey answered the phone. I was ecstatic that I actually got to talk to someone. Then he told me he was booked solid the day I needed it. I then began to tell him my story and to ask for other references and that's when he said "Oh no! I am not going to send you back out there. I will make some room." He made a very desperate mom so happy. He was an absolute joy to work with. I felt like I was family the minute I stepped in his shoppe. I am horrible with names and I don't remember the name of the girl there I worked with, but she was awesome too. I had a picture of what I wanted and they delivered. I was very impressed with the service and very happy with the cake. It turned out awesome and tasted delicious!! read more

I recently contracted Cory to make cookies as a gift to the guests at my daughter's wedding. I sent him a picture of what I wanted them to look like and they were far and above what I provided. I was expecting a simple standard sugar cookie but they were so much richer than that. Guests raved! read more

Very pleased with our experience meeting Corey and tasting his cakes. I took a gamble on this business because of the location of the store in relation to our venue and even where we live, but I'm SO GLAD I decided to check out Corey's Bakery & Catering anyway. What drew me in was the unique list of flavors Corey has to offer on his website. He has some of the most unique flavors I have ever seen. Corey accommodated my very inflexible schedule and still managed to whip up a very professional, yet fun, tasting appointment and consultation. The first thing that grabbed our attention (besides the list of flavors), is the fact that everything Corey uses is all natural. He even makes his own vanilla extract! How's that for dedication to quality? The cakes he makes are amazing. So flavorful and definitely unique - they don't even need filling...you won't even find a list of fillings on his menu. Our biggest issue was trying to narrow down what flavors we wanted to use for our cake - so many to choose from that were all SO YUMMY! This was our first cake tasting and I knew we didn't need to go anywhere else. Corey is passionate about his work and we are so excited about working with him. We can't wait to see what he comes up with for our design too, as his cakes look just a wonderful as they taste! read more