I have been searching for weller 12 for over two years, while visiting a friend downtown I decided to stop here and check for it, luckily they had and I couldn't believe it. I ran home with it. The place is very well organized and stocked up with various liquor categories from scotch and bourbon to tequilas, wines, beers and champagnes. Weller 12 Year Distillery: Buffalo Trace Age: 12 years ABV: 90 proof, 45 percent Nose: Sweet cherries in syrup, caramel, caramel apple. Palate: Caramel, vanilla, cherry, pound cake, a little bit of astringency. I also get a little bit of oak but less than you'd expect from a 12-year-old bourbon. Mouthfeel is a little on the thin side. Finish: More of that cherry vanilla Coke. Finish isn't super long. Rating: A read more

Convenience Plus - Weller 12 - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

one star because no good variety alcohol and too hi price but kind people...................................

The clerk was such a nice guy and pleasant to talk to. I was grabbing water and remedies for my hungover girlfriend and he gave me a Lindt chocolate ball to give to her read more

If you're looking for bourbon, you may not find a larger variety than Convenience Plus! The also have an assortment of other liquors, wines, mixers, snacks, and basics. The owner is very attentive and helpful in finding what you want. Will definitely visit again read more

Stopped in to potentially buy some high end bourbon. What a joke. They had all of my favorites. Only thing is their prices bordered on being criminal. A bottle of Buffalo Trace was about 100.00!!! Retail is 26.99. Really bothers me when small business owners do this. Yes, some dumbass will eventually pay up, but anyone with half a brain will walk. As the service guy said when I laughed at their prices, "don't blame me, I just work here." This says it all. read more

Sold me a 12 pack of cans of Coors light for $19. He made up price- bullshit -then got home and realized it wasn't even cold don't shop here read more

Ripoff! $17.99 for a six pack. Did I have to buy it? No. However, there are no prices posted anywhere. I would have walked out, but it was convenient. Felt like a total sucker walking out. Just know going in that the prices are strip club prices without the fun and you'll be fine. read more

DO NOT go here. Prices aren't posted. At the register, the cashier insisted that a six-pack of beer and one pack of cigarettes was $34. Like highway robbery. read more

Convenience Plus - Don't go here! - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

circled the block twice to find parking to shop at Convenience + only to walk up to the door to have the bald white man standing behind the counter with the door locked and open sign on (2pm on a Wednesday) apparently MY money wasn't good enough for him read more

Convenience Plus - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Amazing liquor store. Good selection of high end liquor and moderately priced stuff. Excellent high end tequila, Scotch, and Bourbon selections. I did also notice that they have 7 different wine categories ranging from chardonay to cabernet sauvignon. Tons of craft beers and beers from around the globe. I have been looking for blantons over the past two years, finally found it here, it was a bit more expensive but definetly worth it for me, i also picked up some japanese Sake which i enjoyed as well, the staff was knowledgable and helpful, thanks for the local chocalate guys, you will be seeing me again. Forgot to add, i presented military ID And recieved a discount, which was cool. read more

Convenience Plus - Wine ranging from chardonay to cabernet - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I would give this place negative stars. Yes they have a wide range of liquor and some wine and beer. The problem is the prices... laughable! I work in the business and when I asked why a bottle of tequila that is typically $35-45 throughout the US was marked at $94 and a bottle of champagne typically marked at $22-35 was $90... don't even get me started on the $1000 whiskey.... He just LAUGHED. So I repeated to be clear and I asked if the number on the sticker was actually the price or some other marker on the product... that was when the real issue with this place began. The man child who is clearly thinking he is going to a club soon,as he is dressed like a wanna be tough boy but he actually appears to be a brittle twig. He stands up on a high level and wears the stretchy mesh shirt like child trying hard to look tough. I am 52 and he appears 25... good thing he didn't come down or he would have been sorry. He barked at me the "prices are fair and buy it if you want or don't but grow up and deal with it". I had simply asked if he was aware he was charging three times the national average and if there is some wild local tax that would explain his prices. This store has good stuff but at crazy prices, so if you just have to have it and can afford it and don't mind dipshits.... Well this is your place. read more

Went in to by ibuprofen and a six pack of beer for my coe workers. He charged me $37 for the whole thing. I also couldn't believe the fact that he wanted $100 for buffalo trace and the prices for Stagg jr, Blantons, and the other allocated bottles was absolutely absurd! He told me "these are my prices and I know what I have". Do not shop here! read more

Crazy expensive! Was charged 14.12 total for a one liter diet coke, one liter bottle of water, 20oz Gatorade. Feels sketchy, had to be buzzed in and out of entrance door. Wish I had looked on yelp instead of googling "convenience store". Lesson learned. Unfortunately, there are no other options within 1.2 miles. read more

A complete rip-off. They wanted to charge me $17.99 for a six pack of michelob ultra. I sad no thanks and left. Do not shop here.

If you want to pay extremely overprice for items, this is the place for you. My red solo cups and cranberry juice came out to $16.16 and was about to buy a case of spotted cow beer until he made up the price of $54.99 for it. My guess is he makes up the prices as he goes since nothing is even labeled with a price tag. I should've put everything back instead of spending a single penny. read more

Such a great experience! We ran in to grab drinks before a bachelorette and were greeted and the store was clean and neat. Very timely and kind, great experience and a great selection of bourbons and whiskeys. read more

Well stocked store with a very a hospitable owner named "Jim," I it's name was because I knew I would be writing a review because I was impressed with the service. Although I didn't come in to buy liquor although I did look around enough to know that pretty much whatever you need as far as liquor, beer or wine probably be found there. The reason I wandered in there is because I was looking for quarters, I'm staying in a hotel (I have a review written for that as well) and I needed to use the laundry facilities which took quarters. The hotel was out of quarters because there appears to be a change shortage across the country due to lack of business, the mints being closed (I checked on this) and an overall COVID-19/Chi-Com virus related supply chain issue. I also didn't have my mask with me. As far the quarters were concerned though he was very low on them he did give me three dollars worth so I wouldn't be able to at least have one wash cycle and one dryer cycle. Again although he had said that he really didn't have enough Jim was nice enough to park with the minimum amount that I would need. For my washing and drying needs. Regarding the mask, I immediately mentioned it when I walked in because he had a sign on the door I suppose so he could be in compliance. I asked if you could sell me one which a lot of stores are doing but he gave me one for free and said to not worry about it. He held up the box and allowed me to take mine out with my own hand. I like that. As I think about it, there was one purchase that I made there, a "Blu," brand "vape pen," reasonably priced, decent selection of these items. I will say it would be nice if there was a bigger selection of Vape stuff. It would be nice if he carried "Puff Bar," brand. I had some nice conversation with him about how much I like Wisconsin possibly even better than the great state of Pennsylvania that I defected to after being disgusted by New York and New Jersey. If you're reading this and you aren't sure what it is about Pennsylvania and Wisconsin that I like though I have distain for New York and New Jersey I don't really have time to explain it now, not that it would take that long. I think about 50% of the people reading this will know exactly why I don't like those cesspool states. Nevertheless I don't want to get political as it is, just like probably most of what I'm writing, it is irrelevant to this review. Thanks again for your help with the quarters, the mask, vape pen and a nice conversation. read more

I've gone to Convenience Plus a few times now. I would not go here unless it's an absolute emergency. I picked up three tins of Zyn and the total came to $22, which is over double the price. The owner is really nice but it seems like he acts that way to cover up overcharging for all of his products. read more

So expensive! Maybe that's the only way for this business to survive in this location, but if there's any chance to buy it somewhere else, do that. read more

If i could give 0 stars i would. I come to Wisconsin for business a lot and always bring back spotted cow beer. I brought 2 12 packs to the register and the owner tried to charge me $73!!!! I said absolutely not I could get it cheaper at the airport. He tried to tell me all other beers are the $16.99 it should be but spotted cow was $35 for a 12 pack! He is a scammer and will charge whatever he wants. Don't go here unless you want to waste your money read more

I paid $19 for a 6pk bottle of Bud Light. This place is the biggest rip off. Don't go here. When he told me the price he had a smug smile on his face. I can't believe I actually paid it. Cheaper to go to the bar and drink. read more

We went in here and purchased a 12 pack of truly and a bottle of aspirin, and somehow, I have no clue house, it came out to $47.50. I didn't even realize it because I was paying with my credit card, and when I got back to the hotel, my wife looked and almost lost her mind. The assumption is it was about $36 for the 12 pack of truly, which usually cost between 16 and $18 and probably $10 for the aspirin. Absolutely stunning and borderline criminal. read more

Prices are more than double what you would normally pay. Do not recommend, go somewhere else.

Listen I hope the owner of the store sees this post. The owner and his son are both really enjoyable people and I like supporting a business that is located downtown and close to my office. I would call myself a regular. And that's the problem. I'm a regular and I feel like I'm being taken advantage of every time I go in. The prices are absolutely insane, and many items are unmarked. I paid $4 for a pack of mint tic-tacs today. It's just too bad. I don't think Ill go in anymore. There is a convince market in the lobby of the PNC bank building across the street, just go there. read more

As someone who works downtown, Convenience Plus is my go-to stop for when I didn't pack enough in my lunch or I'm craving something we don't have to drink in the work fridge. It's right in the middle of downtown, so parking is almost always nonexistent. But, that's expected. I personally believe the store is based more for when people are already in the area - hence the convenience! Walking in, you kind of expect it to just be a liquor store, as that's the merchandise in front. They seem to have a good variety of higher-end alcohol, but I can't say I've ever bought any. The store is very clean and well put together. The prices are a tad high for all of the items, but not outrageous for being a convenience store. Again, though, I can only base that on my own purchases - usually candy and drinks, lol. My favorite part of the store is the owner. He is always there, and is - to my knowledge - the only employee. He is friendly, courteous, and keeps me returning to his store because of the small-town feel (versus the gas station convenience-vibe you tend to see). I have frequently seen him remembering regular customers (including me), which is a great feeling while working smack dab in the "big city". And, he occasionally offers a free chocolate to patrons. Score! I'll keep returning to Convenience Plus, and I recommend the same for my fellow downtown workers! read more

They charged me 136$ for 6 6packs of white claws and 2 packs of cigarettes. What a joke. I will never step foot in there again.

This place is super convenient since you don't have to drive somewhere to get booze while staying downtown. BUT the prices aren't marked on anything and it's all 2-3x the normal price. read more

I paid $8 for two waters. Shame on me. Shame on them. That's about it. Otherwise it's got booze and snacks and stuff. read more

I don't understand. The store is called convenience plus. You come here because it's convenient...not because it's over priced. If you want discounted booze go drive to wal mart. We drove in town from Chicago for a bike race. Needed beer and ice stat. This was around the corner. We were helped right away by the nice gentleman working at the store. PLUS he gave us chocolates at the end of the purchase. Great experience. 100% convenient l. Will be coming back. read more

Kathryn, I found a wine at that store that was the best wine I've ever tasted. I bought it from them often. I decided to check the winery for other locations as it was $25 a bottle, I found out it's average retail price was $7.99, By the case I can get it for $5.99 a bottle. I feel cheated as I really liked the owner and was shocked he would rip off a good customer. read more

Beer prices are literally twice as high as anywhere else. Also, nothing is priced on the shelves so you don't know this until you get to the register and suddenly it's $40 for two mediocre six-packs. Avoid if at all possible. read more

Totally over priced. $15 for 4 ounce bottle of contact solution shame shame shame ! Do not go here.

Gets two stars cuz it is in the middle of downtown. Super expensive!!! Wow! Got a six pack, small bottle of ketel 1 and a soda for 48 dollars! Wow! Might be cheaper to drink at the bar. read more

This store is not a convenience at all. The previous review stated that he was charged $8 for 2 bottles of water. The stuff is over priced at this location. I went to purchase a bottle of grey goose VX and it was $129! It cost $60 for a bottle of Grey goose VX in Chicago! This place is over priced read more

So overpriced! Bottles of wine were marked up 3 times more than any other place! I was familiar with the brands and I am not exaggerating.

This place is a joke. $200 for a bottle of blantons and $4 for a bottle of water. Can't wait for a CVS, Walgreens is 7-11 opens next door to put this place out of business. read more

Got a bottle of cheap blanch for $14.99. Man behind the counter was very helpful; showed us where the chilled whites were and made sure we had a cork screw before we purchased it. If the prices are high...well duh... you are in downtown Milwaukee. Still beats the minibar at the hotel every time. read more

A very clean store with a wide variety of snacks, alcohol, sodas and toiletries. Owner was very friendly and even has a nice floral box displayed in his front windows. read more