I love a local community grocery market. Especially one that is embraced by the area. When we drove through the area we were delighted to see this store. See, my nephew's name is spelt this way. Not the typical most people spell Conner. We joked that we needed to drop him off or he'd be late for work. When we walked in here, it had that old time feel. More narrow than wide, but completely stocked with your needs, and then some. They even had a few items that were unique to them. They do have a small souvenir section that you can pick up a few things. My nephew got a magnet that bares his name. We spoke to the staff here and told them that his name is identical to the stores and they told us we weren't the first people in here that week with the same story. They also said that the magnets, little grocery bags with product in them, are made by an employee of the store. Such a great place to stop. read more

Conner's Supermarket - Grocery Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all

Wonderful store! Has just what you need and decent prices, considering how far off grid you are from the mainland! Everyone was friendly and we were able to get our dinner needs here! read more

I am really impressed with this store! From the outside, I wasn't expecting much, but I was pleasantly proved wrong! It is clean and larger than it looks. They even have a deli! Give it a visit! read more

Mom and pop supermarket but with ALL of the options! Highly recommend the drive! Gluten free and they have so many options!

A great small town private owned grocery store! They have everything you need for vacation. The service is excellent, and the selection is also very good. I prefer going here over food lion in Avon! They have a full service meat and deli department, produce dept, a huge selection of wine and beer also. This is our go to grocery store! read more

We always shop at Connor's when vacationing at Hatteras. Nice store, well stocked and of course great staff

felt like reids supermarket in Charlottesville perfect... went with the cheese selection.

Not a big place size wise but had everything we needed. Very convenient to the Hatteress area and beyond. Staff is super helpful also. read more

This is the island grocery store experience you've been looking for where it seems like everyone knows each other but you. They have almost everything you could get at Food Lion, maybe a little more expensive but a lot more of the Newhart charm! I thought I was back in Ruth Anne's store in Cicely Alaska ("Northern Exposure" reference?) ! Anyway the staff was very helpful when I asked for *big surprise* sunburn/aloe lotion. Yes, I roasted myself but Conners was there to help. Go to Conners they have it all! read more

What the heck happened?! You're now the most expensive place on the island. Can you say "Price gauging"!!?!! But on a positive, the cashier was a sweet person. read more

Conner's Supermarket - Double the price at Connors!!! I - Grocery Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

It's almost unbelievable the great selection this store had for everything I needed... from organic spices to sugar-free bbq sauces and fresh produce. The cashier was very fast, accurate and friendly. For being Memorial Day Weekend, the store was well stocked. The 30-min drive south from Rodanthe was definitely worth it, plus it's a cool area of the Cape to explore. read more

Important to support local businesses. Clean, courteous with great selection. Well organized store and convenient location.

DO NOT SLEEP ON CONNER'S this place is super legit and has everything you could possibly want from a beach town grocery store. Believe me y'all, I've been to my share of these kinds of places and they're all basically the same. Decent service, friendly enough people, and prices triple what you're used to. Conner's is similar, but their selection is psychotic. Yes you might be paying $14 for a 4-pack, but it is something local that you haven't heard of. Their beer and wine selection is out-of-this-world good. They have extremely top shelf stuff, and also the lowest fare you need. We bought a reusable bag, on the side it says "from caviar to PBR, we've got it all.". Truer words, etc Get some pimento (the caviar of the south) and little croissants for a cheapo lunch. Also snag some pasta salad. Closes at 9, so don't be too late. read more

Well stocked grocery store in an area where there weren't many choices. Very large wine selection! read more

Stopped at Conner's while on vacation last week. This is a local grocery store that has everything you need to feed your family for the week. I like to patronize local places rather than "chain" stores. We will definitely stop again when in the area. read more

This is a wonderful place. We love it. Good selection. Great meats. Friendly staff . And fairly good prices. Even cheaper than the big cat store. read more

Extremely clean place the deli has a great selection of meats and cheese staff was very helpful

Truly a hidden gem. Driving by you wouldn't think much of what you might expect but then you walk in and get caught in every aisle just mesmerized by the vast items they carry. Better than food Lion, wegmans, giant, Whole Foods etc. back at home (No.VA) you'd have to go to all of the stores above to get the wide variety of items they have just in this one place. All inspired by the regulars who come year after year asking them to carry certain items (I asked...) it has become a foodie's favorite. Staff are accommodating (signs that say "if you don't see it, ask") cuz most likely they have it. I sound like a commercial or sales person but it's just that great. Check it out!!! read more

Connors is the best around when in Buxton, NC! Located very near to the entrance to the Lighthouse and beach access roads, it's a perfect stop to shop for grocery items. However the key to this little gem is the deli...The chicken salad is a must have for us every time we head to the beach. The made to order sandwiches are excellent, and there are several pre-made options to grab and go, I suggest the Boom-Boom chicken sub...there are even low cal items to select from as well. With a great selection of beer/wine, drinks and souvenirs, you'll find everything you need at Connors! read more

This was the BEST small little town supermarket. It looks small but they had EVERYTHING we wanted and all prices were reasonable. We were only in town for 1 week and did all of our food shopping here! read more

Outstanding lunch today! Just had the thin sliced country ham and homemade egg salad sandwich on artisan bread! Try the deli at Conner's, you will be glad you did!! read more

Everything you need in a single store. Butcher, deli, beer, beach. Produce, bakery, gourmet. No need to go anywhere else. read more

Nice upscale grocery store. It was clean & well stocked. The deli counter had very fresh Boar's Head cold cuts.

Pretty good selection of most things you might need. I think we found everything we needed except maybe one thing.

We love Conner's! Wonderful, well stocked, friendly store. Fast service. Excellent deli. Great beer and wine selection! Go here while visiting HI, you will love it. read more

Everything you could want from a spot to pick up groceries at the beach. Above average deli counter

My husband and I have been vacationing on Hatteras Island for decades. Conners grocery store has always been there for us. This year, with COVID, they offered ordering via email and curbside pickup! We placed a $300+ order and it was absolutely flawless. I can't thank them enough! read more

Top Shelf service from the friendly peeps at Conner's ! Great spot to pick up all we needed. No need to go to Food Lion. We stopped here for a quick in and out if we needed anything... (Stopped in 4 or 5 times). We spent most of our $$ here as well as we cooked our dinners for ourselves in our rental all week. The isle where they have the Nick Nack gifts and such has Magnets, shot glasses , T shirts..ECT.. We had the best tasty Sausage , Chicken, Thick pork chops and Steak . YUMMY meats and loved the The Ice cream cookies They were out of this world! Lemon cookie with Lav Blueberry Ice cream !!! Support small Biz Shop @ Conner's. See you next time. read more

Can't say enough about Conners! This is the upscale foodie outpost on Hatteras Island. I can't get fresh mint and fresh chives or phyllo dough at most bigger luxury supermarkets in Virginia, but Connets has it in December. Staff was friendly, helpful and on point. It's really a pleasure. Thank you! read more

Great little market in Buxton NC, they everything you need for a stay. No need to go elsewhere and the service is the best!

Amazing grocery store right near the Hatteras Light. They have everything! Their motto is "PBR to Caviar" and I believe it. Stop by for a deli sandwich and picnic supplies, gourmet snacks, and TP. And a sweet thank you to the gal who made my sandwich today- I wondered if you had butter instead of mayo, and I saw you sneak into the market for butter for my sandwich! Thanks for the delicious lunch, which I am eating on the sand, enjoying myself! read more

This is a great local store. I called ahead to make sure they had Boars Head (its gluten free) lunchmeat (Food Lion does not) and they not only had it but I have never seen it so cheap anywhere. They also had a very large selection of fresh and a lot of local produce. All prices I saw were comparable to Food Lion and some cheaper. The staff is friendly (unlike Food Lion) I like to buy local at every opportunity. read more

When I'm in the outer banks, and I have a choice, I prefer to give my money to local establishments rather than a chain. So when I'm in Hatteras and we need to hit the store, I go to Conner's. In Avon I prefer Village, however they're closed for the rest of the season due to the hurricane. You can find all the essentials you need here. read more

This place is so special and amazing. My favorite thing about this place is it's family owned and has been open for a very long time. They have so many unique things other grocery stores don't have. Their customer service is like nothing I've ever seen. They are very friendly and willing to stop everything to help their customers. If they don't have what you want, they will special order it for you. read more

This has been my biggest surprise on Hatteras Island. Nowhere on the Outer Banks would I have expected to find a gem like this. They've a great deli, selection of (including vegan ones) of hard to find items in such a remote area, outstanding meat department and general items as well. The service can't be beat at this family owned and operated store! You WILL love it! read more

If you need groceries and you're on "Hatter's" then Connors is your treasure trove. All the staples + wine & beer, organic stuff as well as a good selection of spices and Asian ingredients. I went in looking for something deliberately difficult to find and was ecstatic to discover it was known and stocked. Friendly people and a great choice. read more

This grocery store is a Hatteras Island staple and the choice if you want to support a locally owned store (instead of the Food Lion). My family has been vacationing here for over 40 years and it has yet to let us down. It has your essentials plus great service at the deli and the meat is solid for any meals you decide to stay in for instead of going out. While the Red and White seems to have scaled back big time (unfortunately - another nice local grocery store), Connors is the way to go read more

Good restaurant, especially for the area. Not as big and not the selection you will get a the Food Lion about 20 minutes north, but definitely good enough - who wants to drive 20 minutes to and 20 minutes back to a bigger market when you have the beach to get back to. They are very friendly there as well, helpful when we had specific things we were looking for. Prices decent. Of note, the beer selection here is outstanding. Really good microbrew section! read more

I actually did not go in, but my fiancee did and he said it had everything we needed. Right across the street from where we stayed they were fully stocked read more

Decent selection of basic foods that you need. The premade sandwiches were decent and superior to what you get at a typical supermarket. On a related/unrelated note, I've noticed that many beach towns have people who are working on seasonal visas. Nothing bad or good but I overheard a manager of some type teaching two girls of possibly Eastern European origin the finer points of the southern accent. Kinda an interesting moment. Globalism knows no bounds. read more