- great ice cream flavors - cookies and cream was delicious - waffle cone was decent; the wrapper stuck hard to the cone, so I could not eat that section - seating for 12 people Cute spot and great to come when weather gets warmer. read more

See all

This place is a sleeper. We were walking around Red Bank looking for some yummy dessert and stumbled upon this cute place. We were first attracted to the interior which resembled that of a summer day on a pier, a nice change from the cold November night. We walked in and found a wide variety of flavors most of which were unique. We decided we had to try it and haven't looked back since. My favorite flavors are the superman, strawberry donut, and cookie monster. They have a bunch of other unique flavors that feature great texture (strawberry donut has chunks of donut in there) which adds an extra layer of complexity to this ice cream place. They also have delicious waffle bowls and load you up until it's overfilling. All in all its a great ice cream place and my favorite in Red Bank. They have a wide variety of flavors and keep me coming back to try more and more. Note: This place is cash only so bring some cash or use their ATM but there is an ATM fee. read more

I stopped by here on a Saturday evening after dinner, and to my surprise- THE PLACE WAS EMPTY! I thought that was rather odd for a hot summer night, but I was happy I didn't have to wait in a long line. There was one girl working & she was very friendly. She asked if we had been there before, then offered us samples of some of her favorite flavors. The ice cream and waffle was absolutely amazing! The waffles are made fresh in house, and they pair perfectly with the creamy and delicious ice cream! I found this location to be vibrant and extremely clean. There's several tables if you want to hang out and eat your ice cream. The prices are reasonable & you definitely get your monies worth here! 3 scoops of ice cream on a waffle is around $6- which isn't bad at all! They take cash only so be prepared for that... There's tons of street parking, and a few public parking lots within walking distance. read more

Coney Waffles - Cookies & cream, Cookie Monster and Birthday Cake ice cream on a waffle- YUM! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Cute store with unique flavors and pretty bowls. This ice cream shop has a bright and cheerful interior, friendly service, aesthetically pleasing bowls and toppings, with a wide variety of innovative flavors. I've been back every week to try new flavors and haven't been disappointed yet! I especially recommend the Superman and lemon bar. It's like a sherbet creamsicle that's surprisingly smooth and less tart than expected. I also think the strawberry donut is very special in that it does taste like what it states itself as. It doesn't have an artificial strawberry candy flavor. Lastly the cinnamon twirl is quite spicy enough to provide that autumnal kick without overpowering the other flavors. Overall I have enjoyed all the flavors here and likely will continue to do so! 5/5 would recommend! read more

See all

I'm giving this business a two star rather than a one because we walked out! I was watching food network with my daughter and we saw this ice cream place, we actually watched the story behind it in Long Branch NJ. So the homemade waffle cones in different flavors as well and fancy ice cream, looked fantastic to pass up! My daughter and hubby are complete Ice cream monsters. We waited outside until the place somewhat cleared out. Social distancing isn't enforced. The second thing that turned me off was the man behind the register not wearing a mask properly! That seemed to be the theme. Groups of kids kept walking in and out mask less and it's very small and tight. I will not return to this location. read more

See all

Wow this place smells delicious from the moment you walk in!! They have many varieties of flavors from ice cream to different types of waffle cones. My bf for the rich and famous with the rainbow waffle cone. The ice cream was delicious and he really enjoyed the cone. I got the birthday and Cookie Monster on a chocolate waffle cone. I thought my waffle cone tasted better ! Both flavors were really delicious and highly recommend the Cookie Monster flavor. Only cons is that for some reason that flavor melted at warp speed and I had blue everywhere (had to walk back in for napkins which they don't give with out asking). Also, the cones do sit out and aren't covered, which I wish they would do especially during covid. Both cones came to $15, which I thought was fair for the amount and taste of the ice cream. Definitely filling and this place is totally worth a visit! read more

See all

went to this place for the first time ever a few nights ago with friends. Ordered the waffle sundae. Waffle was beyond stale like it was sitting there for long time. It was tough and chewy. Had I known they did that, i would have never ordered that. I thought it was going to be made fresh. that was a huge disappointment. Ice cream was OK...I've had better. The owner was standing there starring at us as we sat at the tables and tried to have our ice creams. We were a group of 5 and hadn't paid yet but that was because it was only 1 young girl working and him and nobody at the register at the time. Plus another group walked in and while she was servicing us, he was servicing them. We arent degenerates...we were going to pay once someone was available to take our payments...he stood there giving us the death stare the entire time. When he finished servicing his group.. he yelled out across the place that he needs to ring us up before he can ring the other people up. I was like....ooooook - Was getting my wallet out of my purse and while doing som the death stare the entire time. Wont be back read more

Not sure there is another ice cream shop I would recommend. From the location, to the various desserts offered, the place is a Diamond in the rough! Grab yourself a Coney Waffle, as you'll likely never see one anywhere else. Plus, you can't beat the location. It's a Win/Win! read more

I dare you to find smaller scoops of ice cream, not just in New Jersey, but annnnnnywhere. The ice cream is average, which is to say that it's tasty on a hot night. I liked it. Several of their flavors have crafty names. Crafty names that tell you absolutely nothing about the actual flavor of the ice cream. And when the employees behind the counter are barking at you to hurry up while you try to discern what the flavors actually are it's frustrating to attempt to order what you might actually enjoy. Increasing their serving size and clarifying flavors would take this place to a new level. They can get there. But in the meantime, if you're looking for an easy ice cream experience than you might consider other options. Get there, guys. I'm rooting for you. read more

Coney Waffles - I dare you to find smaller scoops of ice cream, not just in New Jersey, but annnnnnywhere. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

So happy I stumbled upon this place! Upon entering, you're hit with the most wonderful aroma, and you know it's gonna be a good time. I have a true allergy to dairy, so when I saw vegan options advertised by their storefront, I couldn't resist. This was about a month and a half ago, and I've been here 4 times since! (And I live in New York, haha). For those with allergies (or for vegan or lactose intolerant individuals), this place is a godsend, with a sizable selection of non-dairy flavors. I've personally tried chocolate, mint chip, and orange vanilla; and classic chocolate is the winner for me. They have a larger number of regular ice cream flavors, which was perfect for my boyfriend, who thinks vegan ice cream must be inferior (and I'm unable to try both to confirm, lol) to regular ice cream. They also have some awesome cone options, from colorful tie-dye looking ones to chocolate dipped ones. Very bright and inviting interior-great for photos. And everyone I've encountered here has been friendly and helpful! Cash only, so bear that in mind. There's an atm just inside the entrance, but of course it's best to bring cash from home/your bank to avoid fees. Highly recommend this place. Already daydreaming about my next tasty visit! read more

Delicious! I got the pistachio and would get it again. The vegan options sadly are made with soy milk. It would be great if they would make some without. read more

I've been wanting to try Coney Waffles for so long after seeing so many Instagram pictures of the waffle and ice cream. I was thinking I was going to get a fresh made hot waffle topped with ice cream! After all the name of the place is Coney Waffles you would think the waffles would be delicious! Sad to say the waffles were the worst part! I ordered the brownie waffle topped with chocolate peanut butter, vanilla with cookie dough and brownies, and Cinnabon ice cream. I asked for it to be topped with Reese's cups, but the man behind behind the counter said he was was out of them because he used them to make a cake. I thought that was weird to be out of Reese's cups since on the Coney Waffles instagram page shows tons of pictures with them used for crazy shakes and topped on most of the ice creams with waffles. The brownie waffle was so disappointing! It was not hot or fresh made. It was an imitation pre made artificial waffle! I'll never order a waffle here again! If I would of known that I would of just ordered my ice cream in a cup! The ice cream isn't home made it comes from Pennsylvania. Some of the flavors are still really good and some not so much. The Cinnabon flavor ice cream was DELICIOUS, and I'd definitely come back for that flavor! The chocolate peanut butter flavor ice cream was pretty good, but the vanilla with brownie and cookie dough wasn't good at all! If you want to try it just go for the ice cream and skip the waffle! If you want a fresh made hot waffle with homemade ice cream go to Luigi's ice cream on the same street! read more

Coney Waffles - Brownie waffle with chocolate peanut butter, vanilla with brownies and cookie dough, and the best flavor Cinnabon ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

What a treat. Prices a bit high but worth it. Great service and the selection is out of this world. Try the Batman Fudge and Superman Blast read more

Unfortunately I would give zero stars if possible. First off, the man behind the counter couldn't have been less pleasant or friendly if he tried. My husband and I were the ONLY people in the store and politely asked for a sample & was promptly told no. Ok that's fine. But then I asked for a small and paid $4 for this pathetic little bit of ice cream. Safe to say it was not worth the $4. Won't be returning due to price & actions from staff. read more

Coney Waffles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

I couldn't taste their delicacies in sweet indulgence , since all they have is CASH ONLY!

Loved the whole experience! The pirates booty is the best ice cream I've ever had!!!! They also make the rainbow cones at the location which makes it smell so good!! read more

Coney Waffles - House made waffle cones and ice cream scoops as big as their faces!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

Stopped in for the first time today. It's a very cute place, and the two girls working were charming. Hubs got a scoop of mint chocolate chip, which he deemed better than average: The chocolate was more curls than chips, and had a more chocolaty flavor than most, with no waxiness. My small chocolate peanut butter shake was too big for me to finish, but had a great balance of flavors. I also noticed they advertised various pareve and vegan flavors, should one be inclined. I'd recommend! read more

Came here last week & i enjoyed every bit of it. I ordered the shake I've seen on their Instagram and i was disappointed !! I had the only sugar rush lol. The decor reminded me of a circus like theme which i love ! Only thing is the cash only part i didn't really like it. It's 2019 everyone uses credit cards but they did have an ATM there. The guy working there was so sweet and helpful. Thank you for the wonderful experience and it was definitely worth the drive. read more

Coney Waffles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

Went to the new Location in Red Bank. After a long anticipation! Upon arrival we find out it's cash only, ok no problem they have an ATM on site.... 4 dollar withdrawal fee seems a bit much! We move on to ordering, with high hopes of having a churro waffle after seeing them posted to coney waffle's Red Bank Instagram page. We find out the Red Bank location does not have churro waffles, ok then why are you advertising it on red bank Instagram? Next we order only to be told numerous times toppings are extra. I get it thanks for the heads up but however one time would have be significant and maybe you post it on the menu? The waffle itself was cold and dry. The icecream however was good. To me it's not worth the hype. Marketing is on point but the product does not deliver. read more

There's ice cream cake and then there's Coney Waffle Ice cream cake!! Out of this world! They took my son's wish and blew it out of the water! So many flavor choices and the design elevates it to a whole new level!! I don't think I can ever have another ice cream from anywhere else! read more

Coney Waffles - Chocolate & cookies n cream cake with outer space "pop rocks and flying saucer" theme! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Red Bank, New Jersey

See all

I love this place. They have so many options, vegan ones too, and the food is always good (how can you not like ice cream??) It's definitely a must go to. read more

Underwhelming ice cream and waffle bowl for the cost. Cash only which is completely lame. read more

Excellent banana split with hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, and strawberry sauce!! Super delish cake batter ice cream. One of the only places one can get a shake float! So rich and creamy. Definitely recommend. read more

Cone batter was left out on the counter when it should be refrigerated at least... cone was bland, ice cream was bland. All overpriced. read more

Too soon to be so lax... I was rooting for this place, everyone around here anxiously awaits the next new spot but downtown Red Bank is the major league of eateries in Monmouth County. There are 3 other places that serve ice cream and treats like this within a 3 block radius so to open up and immediately try to coast is a mistake. Cold hard waffles, non-homemade ice cream, and so-so service is not the recipe for success in such a competitive market. Waffles are in the name, they should be hot and fresh for each order like other places around here. Now is the time to show what sets you apart but so far that has yet to be seen. I'm still rooting for this place, step it up! read more

Ice cream is ok. If you want a place to get really good ice cream, make the trip to cook-mans creamery, way better than coney waffle!

Love the location. Love the ice cream. Can't stand the staff. There is a gentleman that works there that is exceptionally rude. He's short when he responds to a question and is sarcastic. Unfortunately, I'd rather drive out of my way to go to Long Branch just to avoid him or even easier - head down the street to Luigi's. read more

I thought the ice cream was good and creative. Didn't have the waffle cone.. next time. Interesting but good combinations.

so my children that I spoil and give everything they want decide to take me to this rip off spot after I just dropped $65 at a fastfood taco place 15 feet away - I walk in and the guy behind the counter seemed to be a little not friendly - rather than adding to my credit card that is screaming, I decide to do him a favor and pay with cash - so my daughter goes up to him and pays the $15.50 with a $20 and came back to my table with $4!! so there was .50 missing - I now watch 4 young rich kids who could care less about their change since kommy and daddy r cashed up, and each of them received proper change - I then ask mr happy what the actual cost was for my rip off and he said $15.50 - I told him I am missing .50 - he reluctantly went into register to give me my .50 and gave me an attitude and looked at me like I was the crazy one!! here we go!! i by b read more

Went there tonight and really couldn't be more disappointed :( I've literally wanted to try this places for years! I follow hem on Facebook and Instagram and am always drooling over the pictures of huge shakes and cones that look so fun and delicious. I went with my husband and 3 kids and was hardly greeted by a miserable guy behind the counter. I told him we had never been there before and didn't know what it was all about or how to order, he just stared at me visibly annoyed. The menu is hardly a menu and doesn't explain anything. When I asked for an explanation of something he talked to the sign that just stated the name of what it was and explained it with his back to me where I couldn't hear him. The ice cream itself was nothing more than ok. So between the ok ice cream and the miserable attitude of the person behind the counter we were all so disappointed and will stick to Sonic for our milkshakes and ice cream since it's better tasting and more than half the price anyway. read more

Loved this place! If you are a kid, want to feel like a kid or are just a grown up who loves all kinds of ice cream this is the place for you. It is cash only and they have an ATM machine but best to come with cash. We arrived mid afternoon so the place was empty giving us time to chose from the endless ice cream options. The young lady working there was very accommodating explaining the flavors and giving samples to try. We opted for the waffle which gave us three scopes of ice cream. It is a great way to try different ice creams. The waffle was easy to hold and no problem with it dripping down your hand like regular cones. With the amazing pictures I've seen on their website and reviews from other locations, our choice was very boring but tasted delicious. Only negative is parking which can be difficult in Red Bank. We found a spot across the street and ate our ice cream inside. They have chairs and we were told the tables are in but still being put together. They had hand wipes which are a great idea for sticky hands. I hope to get there again soon. read more

See all