Before I get into the bad, here are some positives about Cityside Subaru. And until my most recent…read morecar incident, I would have raved about these strengths to anyone who needed a Subaru. When I bought my car, my interactions with Flavio, one of the sales representatives, was so great that I still remember him 8 years later. I remember how respectful he was with my parents (who came with me to help with the process), how he was not pushy for us to buy at Subaru, and how he encouraged us to make a sound decision by continuing our search with the two other dealerships on our lists. I don't know if he still works there, but I remember recommending Cityside Subaru / Flavio to friends when they were looking at an impreza model (and they also reported having a positive interaction with him). Also the customer service reps I had spoken with before, during, and after my car gets service usually are pretty approachable for my questions. The waiting area is pretty nice and filled with snacks. I work nearby, so this Belmont location has always been convenient for me.
So then why such a bad score? Well, recently I had an incident where a belt snapped - and it was after being replaced two years ago as well as having a routine maintenance check up only one month ago. The inspection apparently passed at the time. I don't know if it's faulty material or faulty labor, but my car found itself with a shredded belt resulting in engine failure a week ago from today. When I called to tell Subaru about this, all the rep did was shrug and agree this seemed too soon to happen. And maybe it was a faulty material or bad labor, who can tell, right? Despite the rep listening to me, the end result seemed to be like there was nothing Subaru could to do. Now that I think about it, I don't think there even was an apology from the rep's end besides "things like this happen." Sure, ok that may be true. Things DO happen and faulty car parts exist, so freaking Cityside Subaru should at least have some kind of policy to support the customer when they do. I know next to nothing about cars, and the engine is never opened until I bring it to the car maintenance, so I know for sure this can't be my fault. Yet to be fair, I was not sure what I was expecting from Cityside - maybe a credit for a future inspection (not like I would come back...) or tire rotation or something? Maybe even an acknowledgement Subaru messed up and a reimbursement for at least part of my previous inspection?! I have no idea to be honest. After reflecting on that call, I did feel unsupported as a customer, especially as a loyal customer who has been getting routined maintenance appointments with them since 2019.
This is already a long review, but two years ago, I had a similar situation in that my car went in for inspection, had a battery replaced, and then that battery DIED a month later. When I brought the car for a battery check, they did not reimbursement or claim it was their faulty material, but recharged the battery and "gave it back" by keeping it in my car trunk. I'm not sure why they thought I would want it back, and they didnt even ask if I would want to keep it. They also kept trying to blame me for it, saying Ieft the car lights on...but the lights turn off automatically so I don't understand how that is my fault? After reading other people's reviews here on yelp, it truly seems like other people have had issues with Cityside Subaru giving them bad parts, especially batteries.
I'm so disappointed to give such a bad review to Cityside. Like I wrote earlier, there clearly were a lot of reasons I continued to get my car serviced here. But their policies (or lack there of) do not support the customer and they clearly use bad car parts. What happened to my car this last time threatened my safety, and the lack of any support loses my trust with them. I think I'll check out the MetroWest dealership for the next time my car needs a service. And maybe you should too if you need your Subaru inspected to ensure your own safety when driving.