The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!

We absolutely love Wallhouse Coffee, we stop in every time we visit Amish Country. The customer…read moreservice, coffee, food, ice cream and inside dining area is a first class experience. The cafe is always extremely clean and inviting. If you haven't been here yet, stop dragging your feet and go already, you'll definitely be glad you did. BOOM!!!!

Lots of parking! When you walk in, you can order at the bar and then wait at the other end for…read morepick-up. I ordered a brown sugar maple latte and it was delicious. I would definitely come back here! Lots of indoor seating and tons of options for food/drinks. Breakfast served til 10:30 and closed on Sundays.

The wonderful smell and sounds of roasting coffee greets you when you enter. Off to the right is a…read moresmall table with two seats if you need to rest and want to relax. On the wall to the right is a large selection of whole bean and ground coffee. The selection off coffees to choose from include organically grown, single origin, and various blends with descriptions of their flavors. There is also a variety of bag sizes from 2oz sample sizes to 8oz, 16oz, 2lbs, and 5lbs. There are also kcups available. I bought a 16oz bag of organically grown coffee sources from Peru Highland and can't wait to taste it.

I have been ordering my coffee from Baltic Coffee for years now. I have NEVER been disappointed…read morewith the service or the taste of the coffee. I used to go to the store in person in Baltic, Ohio, but since moving to a different part of Ohio nearly 4 years ago, I order my coffee exclusively online. I have been unable to find a local roaster that comes close to Baltic Coffee company.

Best place ever! The people there were nice. The place is cute but the tables and chairs are a bit…read moreold and creaky. I would recommend changing them into something more comfy? The large donuts were amazing! I loved the Original. Would definitely come back!

I absolutely love this place! The food is great, the drinks are the BEST (I got a brown sugar…read morelatte), the workers were so nice, the place feels so cozy and comfy I didn't wanna leave! Definitely recommend going here if you are looking for a cozy spot to drink a coffee.

This was a pleasant experience and we will be back. This entire county is a dream for middle-aged…read morewomen, but this is a place to get a reasonable meal as a guy not trying to lose their mind looking at quilts, etc. Food = Fish sandwich and noodle soup were both good at a fair price. They run out of pies throughout the day because they're not serving old pie here, but they're good and lots to choose from. Service = Very friendly. Sometimes a guy has questions, like "Why is there a log of cheese with my soup?" (even though it's awesome). But they answer in a friendly way. Restaurant = This place is busy, you will likely wait. Lots of seats, because apparently I'm not the only one that plans on going back after visiting. Clean and quick.

Lovely spot for lunch in Amish country! Be prepared to wait if you go on a weekend...luckily there…read moreare a couple of shops nearby though where you can browse while you wait to be texted that your table is ready. They close at 3pm, took our names at 2pm, and said it would be a 45 minute wait (which it was) but we didn't feel rushed once we were seated even though it was close to closing time. Our server was extremely friendly and great! Foodwise, we ordered the veggie quiche with a side of the house tomato basil soup and the bistro burger (bacon added) with a side of their soup of the day, cheesy potato. They have a variety of specialty coffee drinks but I chose to order the lightly sweetened peach tea for something different. My husband really enjoyed his burger and said it was well seasoned. He enjoyed the potato soup also and only wished they had fries to enjoy with the burger. My tomato basil soup was tasty! The quiche needed seasoning...I had to add salt and pepper and hot sauce and it could have done without all the extra cheese sprinkled on top. It came with a slice of blueberry bread though which was nice! The peach tea was refreshing as a change but I'd go with coffee next time. All in all we'd eat there again for sure and would try one of their delectable-looking pastries next time too. Thank you for a nice lunch, Rebecca's Bistro!

Fantastic all around! A friend highly recommended while we were visiting the area. Amazing food and…read moreservice by Lynda. Lovely setting with a gorgeous bakery case. My husband enjoyed the chicken tender club and I had the best Reuben of my life. Owner, Mark Miller, stopped by to check in. We felt so welcome. Can't wait to return.

Frankly, I didn't hate or love it. I just don't see a reason to make a trip there other than a…read morelack of competition. Food = Jalapeño popper dip was good. Pork chop was cooked alright, but definitely needed a sauce to add some flavor as it was bland. Coconut mango rice was sad (my wife is filipino so she knows a bit about rice, mangoes, and coconut). I had the reuben and it was alright. I don't understand why all the steaks and fish are "market price" on the menu. This is not a fancier restaurant that serves wagyu, why can you not figure out how to price half of your meats? Service = Good with no problems. Restaurant = Stylish, Spacious, and Clean.

Esther's bakery is so worth the trip! Run by an actual Amish woman who makes everything from…read morescratch with quality ingredients made with pride. Esther makes a phenomenal "coffeecunio" which is a perfect way to start the day while touring Sugarcreek. You also cannot help but have one of the many delicious pastries on hand for breakfast or a snack. This is not a corporate run entity this is a family run business made with love, care and quality food. A must stop in Sugarcreek!

I am embarrassed for the Amish woman working there with how HORRIBLE her service was. I came in…read morewith my family and my daughter dropped her spoon and my husband asked for another and she said "I gave you another already" and my husband asked if he can just pay for it so our 4 year old can continue eating her ice cream... and she said "no" Very nasty attitude. We come to Amish country as it is only an hour away. But we will NOT be returning to Esther's again. Very disappointed with how my family was treated.

Dutch Valley restaurant is a meat and potatoes establishment that is either a buffet, or you can…read moreorder by menu. Today I went to Dutch Valley and had a nice scenic drive to Sugarcreek. I ordered the buffet and it was pretty good overall. I thought the food could have been a little hotter. However, the servers were nice and were very attentive to refilling my Pepsi. I recommend this Buffett for large gatherings, or to enjoy a peaceful home cooked like meal. The restaurant is super clean and they also have a bakery and store where you can buy different things. Outside of the restaurant, there's a concert hall and another gift shop. There's also the Carlisle inn which is a hotel onsite. This is also a good weekend trip, plus you are not that far from the other parts of Amish Country such as Walnut Creek, Berlin, and Millersburg.

Of the area "Dutch" restaurants Dutch Valley is the least good, however it's busy due to the…read moretheater and hotel complex, as well it its proximity to the highway. During our visit yesterday, all of the hot buffet items were cold with the exception of the broasted chicken which was good, however it ran out for about 15 minutes as it was popular since again all the other hot entrees were cold. Additionally at least three of the buffet plates had residual food after washing. Our server was nice and attentive, however the cost wasn't worth it, given the food was cold. It's been at least a decade since I was last there and now I remember why. We should have just driven the extra 15 minutes to Walnut Creek.