Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cold Stone Creamery

    5.0 (1 review)

    Cold Stone Creamery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cold Stone Creamery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Cold Stone Creamery

    Simply Frosted - The Sweet Tooth Logo

    Simply Frosted

    3.8(62 reviews)
    33.7 mi
    •$

    I will say upfront this is a really pretty cake, custom covered in a reproduction of a painting I…read moredid and my artist signature. That's the reason I gave 2 stars and not just 1. My good friend ordered me a custom birthday cake from this bakery. When he went to pick it up, it was not decorated to what he asked for (it was supposed to have additional icing detail on the sides and adornments on top). I cut into it and it looks good but the cake layers are uneven/thin, icing layers are thick in ratio to the cake and the sugar paper wasn't adhered well (wavy). The icing is overly sweet and the white cake was supposed to be wedding white but it's a buttermilk white. It's tangy, tastes off and the blue icing had so much color it has that dye aftertaste. The cake is pretty but it's not good. I don't know what my friend paid for it but I am guessing it was pricey because it was custom. I love supporting local but not if it's a poor product. I would think twice before buying a custom cake here.

    The best thing about the very simple cake I ordered was the taste. It tasted very good. The decor…read morepart was...elementary. Like a child did it. Very disappointed. We had to spruce it up a lot on our own. The person there when I picked it up was brash. I had to sign a piece of paper saying I agreed that it looked fine?! She flash showed me the cake that was already boxed. She definitely wasn't proud of the work and when I got it to the car to look more closely at it, I understood why. I was pretty upset. It was embarrassing, thankfully it tasted good.

    Photos
    Simply Frosted - Very Berry Cupcake

    Very Berry Cupcake

    Simply Frosted - Apple of my Eye Cupcake

    Apple of my Eye Cupcake

    Simply Frosted - Cherry Meltdown Cupcake

    See all

    Cherry Meltdown Cupcake

    The Cake Lady

    The Cake Lady

    3.7(9 reviews)
    27.4 mi

    Ordered a cake two weeks in advance. Was called two days before it was to be picked up with no…read moreinformation about the cake. I explained it again and set a time for pick up the next morning. Jana called that morning to postpone my pickup time from 11am to 5pm. I showed up to pick it up and she wouldn't answer the phone or door. Finally at 5pm she answered the phone and told me the cake wasn't ready. She blamed it on family issues but I got my own too. What a disappointment. Be careful if you order from her.

    NEVER USE HER. She and her male helper showed up 3 hours late to the wedding. Both DRUNK. Yes…read moreDRUNK. The wedding cake only had 3 tiers instead of 4. She said the 4th layer didn't make it whatever that means. It was not even done when they arrived. They were putting it together in a back room. The icing was not put on thick enough and It was nothing like what was ordered. The cake was dry. The cupcakes were all chocolate-not the 3 special flavors that was ordered and paid for. The icing tasted like it came out of a Duncan Hines can. The grooms cake looked like a hot mess and stuff just thrown on it and part of it not covered with icing. Needless to say this lady should NOT be doing cakes. So unprofessional, disorganized and seems to always have personal matters. She even met with the wedding party 4 times before the wedding. Like who is DRUNK and has an obligation to provide a service to people. Even the venue people couldn't believe it.

    Photos
    The Cake Lady
    The Cake Lady
    The Cake Lady

    See all

    Cold Stone Creamery - customcakes - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...