This bar has stopped serving Fireball. WTH Get Fireball…read moreback or lose us. Ridiculous

Great neighborhood pub with an even better staff. Relaxed atmosphere; perfect for a casual evening…read moreout.

Stopped in for an early dinner and instantly felt at home. From the moment we walked in, the vibe…read morewas warm and genuinely welcoming, like the kind of hometown spot where the regulars all know each other (and you're treated like one of them). The staff was friendly and engaging, chatty in the best way, attentive without hovering, so the whole meal felt relaxed and easy. I ordered the burger with bacon and American cheese, and it absolutely delivered: juicy, flavorful, and exactly the kind of comfort-food hit you're hoping for when you order a classic burger. Big bonus: it's a surprisingly great place for toddlers. Comfortable, family-friendly, and the kind of environment where you don't feel stressed bringing little ones along.

Plymouth Tavern might have the cheapest drinks in town, but apparently the service comes with…read morejealous mean girl behavior included for free. A bartender named Anastasia spent more time policing where girls were sitting and acting territorial over the boys, than actually doing her job professionally. My friends and I were ignored on multiple occasions while watching her happily serve everyone else around us, then tonight got told we "couldn't be" in a room with our own friends. We literally walked in for two seconds to say hi, not even intending to order drinks through her and got treated like we were committing a felony. The craziest part was watching a grown bartender run around talking about customers instead of actually bartending. If the energy spent gossiping and targeting certain people went into actual service, maybe this place would have something besides $2 drinks going for it. Never been somewhere that felt so unnecessarily immature, and uncomfortable. There are plenty of bars in Erie where the staff acts like adults. This just isn't one of them.

Good food. Best wing in town. Like getting a pitcher of beer. Clean bar. Good service. Comfortable…read moreseating

we were there on Jan12, 2025. Great service and food. The bartender/ service guy was spectacular…read moreand the cook prepared great food.

9/15/2025 Ate List:…read moreTurkey Rachel - 5.7 Public House over the years has changed a lot. Near it's opening and when I lived locally. This spot was bumping. Food was amazing and would be THE spot in the area to go. Lunch, Dinner, it wouldn't matter - there would be a wait. With every visit over the last decade or so, my experience continues to decline as the food and service has suffered with time. What once was a staple meal has become a poor iteration of what once was. Bread is obnoxiously thick. The flavors on the ingredients feel off. It's disappointing. Still feel like there's a chance this spot recovers in time but with their expansions - this location has suffered.

Wish I could give 3.5 stars. It's pa.. support pa.. BUY HEINZ!!. Ambiance was great. Love the…read morehanging lights. Service was good-very friendly. Did was good.. solid upscale bar food.

If you haven't tried the buffalo chicken tots you've missed out! Service was spot on as well…read more. music playing great Christmas atmosphere.

I had a great breakfast last Sunday while watching the early NFL game. It was cold and rainy, so I…read morestarted with the Cinnamon Roll coffee drink, with Fireball, RumChata and whipped cream. It absolutely hit the spot. The croissant Benedict was really delicious, with perfectly runny yolks and plenty of creamy hollandaise. Also, the potatoes were especially crispy with just the right amount of spice. The service was very friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back, even when football isn't on the menu.

Love the ambience and the good selection of their drinks here (it is quite pricey, but it is well…read moreworth the experience) . The schoolhouse is a great place to grab a drink and hangout with your friends. Though, there are limited selections of food/snack items offered.

Very cool building and an even cooler atmosphere. The cocktail list was impressive and even though…read moreour bartender was new, the cocktails were delicious. Unfortunately, we didn't get to try the charcuterie because nothing we ordered outside of our first cocktail showed up. Sadly, we left after one drink since the small space filled up and the bartenders seemed overwhelmed. I will definitely try it again the next time I'm in town. I know how hard it is to find help these days.

Had dinner last night with friends and the food and service was great, I had the beef on wick…read moresandwich and it was amazing, my friends had the perch and said it was delicious, our server Erin was so kind and helpful, if you haven't been there you really should give them a try I promise you won't be disappointed.

Had a great experience here with my friend for dinner. Phil…read moreis definitely an exceptional waiter, very professional and helpful. We enjoyed the Soft pretzel and Cajun tenderloin tips an appetizer. Tried Pan fried perch, it tasted fresh and cooked perfectly. The Filet dinner was also cooked to the perfect temperature we ordered. We will definitely be back.

Stopped here for lunch on Wednesday afternoon. I started with the tortilla soup and it was very…read moreaverage. There wasn't a lot of chicken or anything else in it - it was mostly a semi-thick broth surrounded by lots of tortilla chips. My husband ordered the Reuben and was so so disappointed. The corned beef was tender, but he was appalled when he removed the bread to find a layer of corned beef folded in half to cover half of the sandwich. There wasn't much corned beef at all. Cole slaw also tasted like bland cabbage. :(( Not sure we would return.

Great service at bar Very honest menu suggestions…read more Had a some good shrimp taco's as well as good steak salad. Beer selection was fair. Good vibe

Stopped in late as it was the only place open in Erie that we could find on a Wednesday night…read more Haven't been here in 20 years. Katie, our bartender, was amazing! Ambiance is super nice. Billiards til 2am, clean atmosphere. The upbeat demeanor of the bartender made our night!

Stopped for a quick lunch and the place looks amazing inside with all the pool table and such a…read morenice bar. Food order was quick to be taken with about 10 other guests in the bar. Place was real clean and so were the restrooms. The food on the other hand not so good. First off we ordered wings, a sandwich and the daily special which was a meatball sandwich all with fries. The wings were crisp and barely edible, the small wings were cooked to a crisp and the 2 larger ones were ok. The meatballs in the sandwich were black and so old/overcooked that it was not edible. The other sandwich was ok and the fries were fresh and cook correct. Wait staff never came back for a drink refill, no apology for the bad food but credit was given. Definitely would not return for the food.