Ok, before I say anything, good or bad, about this place, I need to say that I have always loved horses and always will. If a place like this does not have respect for the people or horses, I will have no respect for it. This is the main reason why I am giving only one star. I came here once last summer, had a negative experience, and after reading the other reviews I have a much fuller understanding of the condition of these horses.
I visited Mackinac Island last summer and was thrilled to find a riding stable. Nothing can describe the excitement I felt to go riding again. It isn't often that I get to ride, or even see, horses and I was more than happy to give this place a try. I filled out a paper stating what kind of rider I am (having taken lessons when I was younger I'm not a bad rider, but definitely not perfect), and before I knew it my horse, Fritz, was tacked up and stood outside, waiting for me. I mounted and a young woman politely showed me how to turn, stop, and go. Then they let us go with our guide, who followed slightly behind me and a few other horses. We walked in a line against the curb of the road. This is when the trouble started. Fritz, who seemed to be the dominant horse in the group, wanted to be in the front of the line, and he was trying to cut in front of the horses ahead of me. One of the horses was diagonal from me and when Fritz would walk faster to try to get around her, my knee would poke into her hind leg. Afraid of the other horse kicking out on frustration, I had no choice but pull on the reins to slow Fritz down. I HATE pulling that hard on the reins because I know it hurts their mouth, but what choice did I have? There was no other place for us to go. Fritz slowed down at first, but soon resisted me and eventually the two people in front of me (who weren't part of the guided ride) rode onto the wooded trail. Fritz was able to be in front now and walk far away from everyone else, who lagged behind. When I tried to get him to stand still so the others could catch up, he wouldn't want to.
This is the part when the REAL trouble started. When it came time for us to turn onto the wooded trail, the guide, who stayed behind with the slower horses, told me to right. This should have been a simple task, but when Fritz caught a glimpse of the other two horses who used to be in front of us, he turned left. Was told to pull the reins sharply to the right, which I did, but Fritz walked backwards, spun me in a circle, and then trotted near a bunch of trees. The guide caught up to me and helped to get me out of that mess by telling me to trot him into the right direction and the issue was resolved. Once again, Fritz was waaay ahead of the other horses. I stopped him and tried letting another horse in front of him, but he stayed so close to the other horse's behind that it kicked out. After that I gave up and allowed Fritz to be in front. When it came time to return to the stable, someone took Fritz by the reins, I dismounted, and, unfortunately, was glad the ride was over.
I hate to admit it, but this was the first time I ever rode a horse and regretted it. For the longest time I blamed myself and my lack of proper riding skills. I assumed my bad experience was because I couldn't take charge and be the bigger person. But now that I look at the bigger picture I see that these horse are overworked and frustrated. They do not receive the breaks they need to refresh themselves, I'm sure many riders don't know what they're doing and pull on their mouthes and sit unevenly in the saddle, they walk in the heat and have to tolerate the noise of the crowd on top of all of that. I'm not saying it's the horses' fault. It's the people who look after them who aren't doing their job. Horses, like people, NEED a break. Other reviewers have said their horses bolted, which sounds an awful lot like repressed agitation being released. Horses respond to stressful situations by fighting or fleeing. When Fritz refused to listen to me, he fought. When other people's horses bolted they fled. There needs to be a change in how the people care for these horses, or someone could get seriously injured. read more