It's worth checking this trendy and stylish shop when strolling around Mystic. Tons of fashionable…read morewomen's wear and accessories. Things are neatly organized and beautifully displayed. It's a surprisingly sizable store that extends to the back with a couple of dressing rooms. The dressing room has pretty pink drapes for doors giving it a luxurious look. I ended up buying only a makeup bag here and my gf bought a few things. Overall Service: There was two staff working here at the time, we were welcomed in with a warm greeting. They were not gossiping while customers were present and assisted people when approached. I would totally come back here again with my gfs!

My boyfriend and I popped in here right after arriving in Mystic because it was 60° outside in July…read moreand I needed a jacket or sweater. We were greeted by 2 sales girls right away who were happy to assist me. They did have a good selection of sweaters and also some hoodies. Definitely had some cute clothes, which I was ignoring since I really just wanted a jacket. They had a clearance rack; one of the items on it that I tried on had a hole in it. Found a really cute cream colored denim jacket right away that I tried on in their dressing rooms and it fit great. The jacket was a little pricey, however I really like it.

What a unique store! Perfect for Christmas gifts!! The customer service and gift wrapping was…read moreamazing. DEFINITELY make this a stop on your way to Mystic.

Not my kind of place, but my wife liked it. We spotted it on Yelp and decided to stop. Lots of…read moreinteresting and unique items. Would recommend only for women or perhaps men who like to decorate (ahem). We bought a dried out starfish and some silver tea lights for my mother in law. See my profile for more information on how I rate stores. A 3.5 to 4 star establishment.

Stumbled upon this awesome shop on their grand opening. We were greeted by a Southern Tide rep, who…read morewas friendly and offered us free koozies, croakies, and stickers. We went inside and the merchandise was predominantly, Vineyard Vines, Southern Tide, and similar brands. The staff was informative and friendly, and even offered us mimosas! There's a collection of men's and women's clothes, shoes, and accessories, fairly priced (similar to MSRP). I bought a pair of Sperry Boats, which I wore out of the store after they gracefully threw away my old, beat up ones. My fiancé purchased a Vineyard Vines Shep Shirt and a rain shawl (which she's very happy about). This shop will do very well and I'm happy to have given them business. We will definitely go back again!

Love this store! There are always new items you don't see elsewhere mixed in with favorites like…read moreToad & Co, Prana & Vineyard Vines. Knowledgeable honest salespeople and it's always neat and easy to shop.

Great store! Super nice employees always ready to help. Would definitely recommend. Really cool…read moreclothes and styles.

FatFace is a British casual, street wear clothing store, for men, women and children. I've seen…read morethis store across several cities across Europe. Locally I've been to the FatFace stores in New Haven, Newport and in Mystic. While in the Mystic store recently, they treated shoppers to iced tea and cookies. I like the selection of items they offer. There's a nice variety of tops, jeans, skirts, dresses, leather wallets and purses, and more. However, the prices are very high, even for the most basic items. The items are good quality, but very similar items can be found at plenty of other retailers at a much more appropriate cost. I can't see myself purchasing anything here. While the store is in a vary attractive area, and it's always beautifully set up, staff is also very friendly and attentive, the items aren't anything unique, and similar items can be found in many other places. I simply can't recommend shopping here.

What a friendly place with lots of beautiful and high quality items for decent prices. I loved the…read moretwo ladies working there as they were friendly and helpful. There is a wide selection of beautiful purses, candles, and jewellery. I looked at a nice leather bag and it looked very high quality. But my big cell didt fit in. Must get a purse that fits the cell. I strongly recommend shopping here and stopping buy.

This was the best store in Olde Mistick Village, the prices weren't astronomically expensive, and…read moreit was very tasteful. The clothing and jewellery selection was beautiful, and the soap and candles smelled so good! Definitely not a tourist trap. Would definitely visit this store again!

I've never seen my mom happier than when she was in this store. The employees were so kind and…read morehelpful, really taking the time to help her find exactly what she was looking for and thoughtfully showcasing different products. The whole space looked beautiful and smelled amazing, Such a lovely store and experience overall.

I love coming to the Becca Rose shop and getting the dragons blood soap! All of her soap smells so…read moregood. I can never decide on which one I want. You can find jewelry, books, tarot cards

You know those "destination hoodies", they're cotton, a bit worn looking, with a destination on the…read morefront in bold font? If you go to Newport, you would get one that says Newport on the front. These are super trendy, particularly during the spring and summer. Just Mystic is a store in downtown Mystic where you can find a variety of these hoodies, t-shirts and hats for the whole family. This cotton is heavy duty, but still light and breezy, it is made to be worn, so it only gets comfier with each wear. Just Mystic merchandise isn't cheap, one of their basic sweatshirts without the hood will run you $65 - $75. These make an excellent gift for someone who you've visited Mystic with but isn't from the area.

Great local apparel shop located in the heart of downtown mystic (previously a toy store)This was…read moremy first opportunity to stroll in and take a look at all the cool merch I've been seeing on their @justmysticshop Insta account. I will tell you that I did not leave empty handed. Winter hat Long sleeve tees trendy sunglasses all in which will make one heck of a Christmas gift. (pics to follow) They offer a ton of local apparel great for the tourist of course but equally as attractive to us locals. I was eyeballing some other comfortable attire for myself that I plan to return to snag after the holidays. Plenty of printed champion sweatshirts and long sleeve men's tees that peaked my interests. Cheers to 2023 and some new clothes for me

A treasure hunt with charm and value…read more Penny Wise Consignment is one of those places where you walk in "just to browse" and somehow leave with a bag full of finds you didn't know you needed. The shop is well‑organized without losing that fun, treasure‑hunt energy that makes consignment shopping so addictive. Clothing, accessories, home goods--everything feels curated enough to be worth your time, but still priced like a true local gem. What really sets Penny Wise apart is the staff. They're friendly, patient, and genuinely invested in helping you find something that fits your style or your home. There's a sense of loyalty and community here--you can tell regulars come back not just for the deals, but for the people. Inventory rotates often, which keeps things fresh, though it also means you've got to be quick if you spot something great. A little more space or updated displays would push this place into five‑star territory, but honestly, the charm is part of the appeal. If you love good value, unique pieces, and a shop that feels like it's run with heart, Penny Wise is absolutely worth the stop. Enjoy

The best thrift store in this town, with lots of clothes, handbags, THE SHOES OMG (got a pair)…read more Lots of named brands items like Michael Kors, Kate Spade, and entire table of Tory Burch, I spent $100 & came home with lots of summer attire. Loved this place

Love the warm feeling when you walk in with plenty of things to look at with good prices. The lady…read moreringing me out was absolutely sweet and nice to talk to and will help you out if needed . They sell clothing, jewelry and more . I found the most adorable anklets here . I had to buy a few I just couldn't choose just one. Trinkets for a nice gift or buy something for yourself.

A beautiful store in downtown Mystic that has women's and a selection of children's clothes. Love…read morethe shop window s and alway happy with my purchases!

Stoped in and purchased myself a treat while staying at the Inn at Stonington. The associate was…read morelovely and I can't wait to wear what I purchased. Beautiful unusual top and co-ordinating skirt

She has a TONNN of really beautiful, unique clothes. The store itself is small and can be…read moreclaustrophobic; when I was looking at clothes, I felt like I was shoulder-to-shoulder with the only other person who was shopping at the same time. The clothes are striking and really high quality. I splurged on a beautiful duster and I was pleased when she was able to tell me exactly who designed it and where. I'll stop in again if I'm in Stonington in the future.