Cathedral Cafe
Cathedral Cafe Photos
CATHEDRAL CAFE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Cathedral Cafe
Recommended Reviews - Cathedral Cafe
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I feel like you should definitely go in to get the full experience, and the building itself it absolutely beautiful. I thought the layout was cute but the parking situation is absolutely terrible in my opinion, but that's what you gamble when eating downtown. I thought the food and the service were just okay, nothing to go on and on about. I think this was a once and done situation for us but that's okay. We enjoyed our meal, but for the price, the food was just alright. Definitely recommend just to go once for the vibes and if you like it, go back!
Beautiful coffee house and cafe located in a former church. Beautiful ambience and delicious food! Make sure to visit the shop upstairs with local artists treasures!
We were so hungry that we didn't even think about taking pictures of our food. But it's okay, because we will definitely return! We ordered a bagel sandwich with cheese and eggs, as well as a fluffy omelette, and both were incredibly delicious. It was the perfect quick breakfast to fuel us before a day full of adventurous hikes. The service was prompt and friendly, making us feel welcome. Our meals arrived warm and satisfying, with freshly brewed coffee that was rich and aromatic. The restaurant offered a variety of sweets and snacks, so we picked out a few to enjoy during our hike. The place itself was beautiful! Vibrant and colorful, with a cozy, inviting atmosphere that felt just like being in a home away from home.
My husband and I went hiking with our dogs at New River Gorge National Park last month and I hadn't gotten around to posting my reviews yet. We stopped in at Cathedral Cafe our first morning there before hitting the trails because they are pet friendly on the small deck area/outside where the picnic tables and table sets are. We ordered a blueberry muffin and some sausage for the dogs to split (they were on vacation too!), my husband ordered the breakfast bagel, and I ordered an omelet with toast and potatoes. Nothing was seasoned and we had to go back and ask for butter for the toast because nothing came out with it and it was nothing was offered when it was dropped off. Both of our main breakfast options were pretty bland and overall very expensive for what we received. We ordered a cinnamon roll to split between us and that was good. We sat out where the picnic tables and table sets were to give the dogs more room to lay down/to be away from the front entrance with people going in and out. We found out you cannot take alcohol out past the deck, so we could not have mimosas. Just something to keep in mind if you are visiting from out of town. That area also houses the ice storage, so while we were eating a man kept coming back and forth with a huge ice delivery, which riled up the dogs because it was so loud and right next to where we were sitting. It is a really cute spot and since we were visiting an area near a national park, there are only a handful of options in the small town, so I'm still glad we visited. I just think it is a better spot to sit inside and enjoy the stained glass windows, have access to condiments, etc than to eat outside with dogs.
First time at Cathedral Cafe. Got a strawberry shortcake iced latte and a breakfast sandwich. Pretty busy around 10:30 on a Sunday but was able to order to go. Had some art and jewelry for purchase. A little merch. Otherwise pretty bustling.
One of the better breakfast spots I've gotten while traveling in a few years. I ordered the 5.10 special with sunny side eggs, bacon and potatoes. It's an evenly balanced platter which is great for a meal, or a starter for the more experienced eaters. I followed that with the blue berry pancakes. They were delicious and had options for chocolate chips as well. The coffee is 6.5-7/10 here. Next time I'll ask them to make it stronger. There are plenty of condiments to choose from, jelly, hot sauces and seasonings. Would highly recommend this beautiful church turned restaurant if you stop in fayetteville!
Our breakfast stop before headin on the road home! Cute spot where you can dine in or take food/drinks to go. Really enjoyed my smoked salmon bagel . Items came out quickly. Service was nice. You order at the counter and given a number. If you're heading into town or heading out, pleasant place to grab a bite. :)
This place was hyped up by a few locals, so maybe I went in with high expectations, but I wasn't impressed. The vibe is cool and it's nice they renovated an old church and kept the character of the place, but that's where the positives end. Service is awkward as you order in line, still have to go get your own drinks and then they ask for an 18-25% tip when you talk to a human for maybe 30 seconds. Prices are high. For $3.99 for a side of potatoes, I was expecting a lot larger portion. The turkey stack breakfast sandwich was just mediocre and lacked flavor. They have a gift shop so maybe you can go in to check out the ambience, but I would skip eating here.
PUMPKIN PIE COLD BREW from Cathedral Café - 134 S Court Street Fayetteville, WV for the perfect coffee-dessertish-yummerific hurricane of tastiness. It was quite pretty to look at, too! They are consistently awesome! It was good seeing you as always, Wendy Stone Bayes! I'm a big fan!
What a beautiful spot! Located in downtown Fayetteville, we parked out front and were quickly greeted by the person behind the bar. She told us to sit anywhere, grab a menu, and order at the purple table. We perused the menu and I decided on the ultimate grilled cheese panini and added ham. It came with a dill pickle spear and chips. The panini was huge! Should have shared! The bread was so good though! My husband had to try the animal cracker cheesecake and I had a small bite. It was very good! My friend ordered the carrot cake and that was divine! They have a retail shop upstairs as well with some fun shopping to check out while you wait for your food.
4 months ago
Such a cute cafe. Briefly stopped in to grab some caffeine before hitting the shops and it was beautiful inside. Would love to come back and experience more of their menu. read more
5 months ago
A business that sells food in a structure that used to be something completely different is right up and into our alley so it was literally the first thing we did upon stepping foot within the town boundary. We were seated immediately on a Friday at around 1pm. I love their vegetarian options but this is a place that assumes if you are a vegetarian, that you like and must have onions and mushrooms in every meal. I couldn't find much other than pancakes/pastries/sweet shit that didn't have onions and mushrooms but fortunately, they were able to accommodate my request for the tofu scramble without onions or mushrooms. GF ordered the vegetarian quesadilla with, you guessed it, onions and mushrooms (among other things). My tofu scramble was good but calling it a scramble is slightly misleading as it is actually tofu cubes albeit very crispy and tasty tofu cubes. This dish was probably potatoes. A few spinach leaves and maybe 1/100th of a pepper. I will concede to the fact that some of that volume might have been taken up by mushrooms and onions. The dish was very good regardless and the accompanying salsa added a really nice extra je ne sais quoi. I also really like the pay first and then leave whenever you want model to avoid being held hostage to bad service not to say that they would've provided bad service but it is a risk anywhere. Regarding GF's quesadilla which I did not have the pleasure of sampling bc of onions of mushrooms "I thought it was decent". When I asked if she had any details or specifics to add, she replied, "no". read more
Solid breakfast and coffee spot! The avocado toast was actually pretty unique and had a lot of great flavors going on. The coffee was decent, although I wish it had a little more of the flavoring in it. The staff was friendly and they have a cute little shop upstairs that's worth checking out. It's one of those places where you walk up and order and then they bring the food out to you. There's a good amount of seating inside too. I also noticed they serve alcohol later in the day which is a nice option. Overall a good spot for breakfast and I'd definitely stop back in! read more
I feel like you should definitely go in to get the full experience, and the building itself it absolutely beautiful. I thought the layout was cute but the parking situation is absolutely terrible in my opinion, but that's what you gamble when eating downtown. I thought the food and the service were just okay, nothing to go on and on about. I think this was a once and done situation for us but that's okay. We enjoyed our meal, but for the price, the food was just alright. Definitely recommend just to go once for the vibes and if you like it, go back! read more
We were so hungry that we didn't even think about taking pictures of our food. But it's okay, because we will definitely return! We ordered a bagel sandwich with cheese and eggs, as well as a fluffy omelette, and both were incredibly delicious. It was the perfect quick breakfast to fuel us before a day full of adventurous hikes. The service was prompt and friendly, making us feel welcome. Our meals arrived warm and satisfying, with freshly brewed coffee that was rich and aromatic. The restaurant offered a variety of sweets and snacks, so we picked out a few to enjoy during our hike. The place itself was beautiful! Vibrant and colorful, with a cozy, inviting atmosphere that felt just like being in a home away from home. read more
23 days ago
We wanted a good local coffee shop when we were in the area for New River Gorge national park and this was it!! It was busy in a Sunday morning but the food and the coffee were great! read more
29 days ago
Great service, very good coffee and breakfast. Would definitely come back. The place is very pretty and whimsical too! The stained glass windows are a must see. read more
My husband and I went hiking with our dogs at New River Gorge National Park last month and I hadn't gotten around to posting my reviews yet. We stopped in at Cathedral Cafe our first morning there before hitting the trails because they are pet friendly on the small deck area/outside where the picnic tables and table sets are. We ordered a blueberry muffin and some sausage for the dogs to split (they were on vacation too!), my husband ordered the breakfast bagel, and I ordered an omelet with toast and potatoes. Nothing was seasoned and we had to go back and ask for butter for the toast because nothing came out with it and it was nothing was offered when it was dropped off. Both of our main breakfast options were pretty bland and overall very expensive for what we received. We ordered a cinnamon roll to split between us and that was good. We sat out where the picnic tables and table sets were to give the dogs more room to lay down/to be away from the front entrance with people going in and out. We found out you cannot take alcohol out past the deck, so we could not have mimosas. Just something to keep in mind if you are visiting from out of town. That area also houses the ice storage, so while we were eating a man kept coming back and forth with a huge ice delivery, which riled up the dogs because it was so loud and right next to where we were sitting. It is a really cute spot and since we were visiting an area near a national park, there are only a handful of options in the small town, so I'm still glad we visited. I just think it is a better spot to sit inside and enjoy the stained glass windows, have access to condiments, etc than to eat outside with dogs. read more
3 months ago
First time at Cathedral Cafe. Got a strawberry shortcake iced latte and a breakfast sandwich. Pretty busy around 10:30 on a Sunday but was able to order to go. Had some art and jewelry for purchase. A little merch. Otherwise pretty bustling. read more
3 months ago
Food and service was great! Perfect for a quick lunch on the go!! We got the Reuben and avocado toast! read more
7 months ago
One of the better breakfast spots I've gotten while traveling in a few years. I ordered the 5.10 special with sunny side eggs, bacon and potatoes. It's an evenly balanced platter which is great for a meal, or a starter for the more experienced eaters. I followed that with the blue berry pancakes. They were delicious and had options for chocolate chips as well. The coffee is 6.5-7/10 here. Next time I'll ask them to make it stronger. There are plenty of condiments to choose from, jelly, hot sauces and seasonings. Would highly recommend this beautiful church turned restaurant if you stop in fayetteville! read more
5 months ago
5 months ago
1 year ago
Our breakfast stop before headin on the road home! Cute spot where you can dine in or take food/drinks to go. Really enjoyed my smoked salmon bagel . Items came out quickly. Service was nice. You order at the counter and given a number. If you're heading into town or heading out, pleasant place to grab a bite. :) read more
5 months ago
3 months ago
This place was hyped up by a few locals, so maybe I went in with high expectations, but I wasn't impressed. The vibe is cool and it's nice they renovated an old church and kept the character of the place, but that's where the positives end. Service is awkward as you order in line, still have to go get your own drinks and then they ask for an 18-25% tip when you talk to a human for maybe 30 seconds. Prices are high. For $3.99 for a side of potatoes, I was expecting a lot larger portion. The turkey stack breakfast sandwich was just mediocre and lacked flavor. They have a gift shop so maybe you can go in to check out the ambience, but I would skip eating here. read more
PUMPKIN PIE COLD BREW from Cathedral Café - 134 S Court Street Fayetteville, WV for the perfect coffee-dessertish-yummerific hurricane of tastiness. It was quite pretty to look at, too! They are consistently awesome! It was good seeing you as always, Wendy Stone Bayes! I'm a big fan! read more
What a beautiful spot! Located in downtown Fayetteville, we parked out front and were quickly greeted by the person behind the bar. She told us to sit anywhere, grab a menu, and order at the purple table. We perused the menu and I decided on the ultimate grilled cheese panini and added ham. It came with a dill pickle spear and chips. The panini was huge! Should have shared! The bread was so good though! My husband had to try the animal cracker cheesecake and I had a small bite. It was very good! My friend ordered the carrot cake and that was divine! They have a retail shop upstairs as well with some fun shopping to check out while you wait for your food. read more
This restaurant was recommended by the hotel and our white water raft tour guide.. Overall, we felt it was just OK. You order your food at the cash register. Your drinks/coffee will be called for you to pick up your drinks. They deliver your food to your table. When you pay, you have an option to leave tip at 18%, 20%, 25% or other. Chocolate chip pancakes were burnt (see pix) Chicken quesadilla was ok - chicken was a bit dry Chicken pot pie (special) - not that great and we didn't finish it. I prefer the one in Glencoe at Apple a Day. Smoked Turkey, provolone cheese, and avocado panini was ok - they only gave three small slices of avocado (see pix). Breakfast burrito - ok (a bit cold inside) Overall, the cafe was just a regular cafe. read more
1 year ago
Panini was delicious & Tomato soup was thick; really flavorful. The souvenirs were cool- shirts, stickers and more.. pretty quick service after the 25 min wait. Went during the summer around 12:30 lunch time on a Sunday. The key lime pie martini was interesting, not too bad at all. I'd love to go back when I have more time. Didn't get to go upstairs read more
1 year ago
We went for breakfast and the place was fantastic, coffee bar, small outdoor seating area and some great food as well! The staff made you feel like home and a must stop if you are in the area. read more
3 years ago
Sometimes you seat yourself and sometimes a hostess seats you. Small parking lot next to the building or street parking. Eclectic and hipster vibe and music which I LOVE! Very welcoming and inclusive. They are a cafe that also sells shirts, stickers and other merchandise from local artists. LOVED my oat milk chai and apple spice croissant french toast! I went up to the counter to order and pay and then they give you a number that you place on your table- helps the employees find you. Service can sometimes be slow when busy but they are WORTH the wait! read more
2 years ago
Y'all every time I come to WV, no matter where I ALWAYS have to make a stop here. Their food is amazing. The flavors are great, the dishes are creative, and their coffee beverages are straight gas. The inside is so cozy and feels like you've been entered into an another dimension.It's so relaxing and if I could, I'd spend all day in there. Everything is made fresh and with love, everyone is so nice and welcoming. Seriously, if you've never been it's a WV staple for sure. read more
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
Strange place. The staff sits you then tells you to go to the register to order then you have to go get your coffee. My gluten free toast was served cold. The restaurant is cute but the flow is strange. read more
9 months ago
4 years ago
Adorable spot that we were fortunate enough to experience while in town doing the Gauley. The music was great, the weather was perfection, the coffee was yummy and the bagel Sammy's were a dream! No alcohol allowed in the lower outside area (picnic tables) due to the licensing but this didn't bother me since I was drinking coffee. read more
1 year ago
We thought it was a great spot for lunch. Came on a Tues around noon between hikes and we were able to get a seat inside. They have an outside patio, but were doing some work on it - so it was closed on this particular day. You order at the counter, then take a seat and they bring your order to the table They had decent selection of sandwiches and panini's. My bride ordered the Vegetarian Panini and added turkey and I ordered the Turkey Reuben. They were healthy portions and came with chips and pickles on the side. Service was friendly and fast. We would come again when in the area. read more
The largest and most active business in this town (which surprisingly was not that crowded otherwise given the proximity to such splendid outdoor experiences), this cafe offers the ambiance of a small church and an eclectic brunch menu. I found a tofu scramble. The options for vegetarian, not overly sweet, and at least some protein are not abundant in this part of the country, so this was a win for me. The chili powder flavored stir-fry was actually better without the salsa on the side than with. There were also potatoes and spinach; cooked spinach is never as good as fresh, but it's something. Some white bread on the side helped mop things up. Both the indoor and outdoor seating were packed on my visit, and it seems a place that-while not amazing-is likely to appeal to most people. read more
I knew I wanted to eat here during our visit, but I didn't anticipate to come here every day! We had multiple breakfasts here and ordered lunch to go one day. I love the staff and the vibes are just very laid back. On a typical day you grab a menu, seat yourself, then order at the counter (busier days you have to wait to be seated). I got a different latte every day, tried hot and iced. The hot comes out very hot so I'd typically take the rest to go. I love love love that you get a different cup every time it's just kinda whatever they have, it just fits. We enjoyed all our food! The sandwiches we ordered with the garlic aioli were sooo good. My favorite breakfast item was the egg, spinach, bacon bagel! They have a cute small gift shop upstairs. Parking is limited but we didn't have a problem most days. This place is such very relaxing and laid back we loved visiting during our trip! It was the perfect 'regular' spot! read more
Came in for breakfast about an hour past open on Sunday and the place was busy! We had a 20 min wait for our table, but it ended up only being around 10 mins total. We sat, got up and ordered, and came back to the table. The coffee drinks were out in under 5 mins and the food was out in about 10. All 3 of us had bagel sandwiches. I had the smoked salmon on an everything bagel without onions and it was perfect. there wasn't too much cream cheese, there was plenty of salmon, and the bagel was toasted lightly. I ordered a dirty chai and it was topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon. It wasn't sweet at all, but was smooth and creamy. They have two bathrooms tucked in the back corner that are unisex. The one I went in was small, but clean. They have most tables inside, but a few outside seating options, as well. It was getting way more crowded as we left. Several parties were waiting outside for their table. Go early! read more
1 year ago
10 months ago
Page 1 of 9
More info about Cathedral Cafe
134 S Court St
Fayetteville, WV 25840
Directions
(304) 574-0202
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.thecathedralcafe.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Cathedral Cafe Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Cathedral Cafe
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
22 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
3 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
9 years ago
5 years ago
5 years ago
8 years ago
2 years ago
6 years ago
3 years ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
7 years ago
4 months ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
11 years ago
5 years ago
