Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open 5:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 2,084 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Knolla's Pizza - Stingy Italian sausage on a NY Large.

    Knolla's Pizza

    3.4(144 reviews)
    11.2 mi
    $

    Good: Pizza was fantastic!! Ordered cheeseburger pizza and was not dissapointed. Flavor freshness,…read moreand hot out of the oven. Bad:Ordered online and was not given an option to pay at pick up. Placed order @ 6:33pm provided a ready time of 7:03pm. We arrived at the appointed time and then were told it would be an additional 15 minites. Finally received pizza @7:21pm. Problem: asked the employee about the additional 15 minutes and asked why the online ordering doesn't adjust to the volume. She said it never adjust and she said they were slammed. She apologized and said it should be ready in 15 minutes. I felt her response was just standard boiler plate that she throws out every day. Waiting 45 minutes really not cool when a lot of apps for online ordering can actually calculate a GOOD pick up time. Manager and Owners need to do better. You have a good product but questioning my return status.

    First off, the pizza is great. No complaints there…read more But I ordered delivery, and Knolla's recommends ordering through Toast because then I wouldn't have to pay a surcharge that the restaurant charges. The delivery absolutely sucks!! Toast subcontracts through DoorDash and UberEats- no problem with that, but it's been over an hour since my pizza was picked up from the restaurant. Originally it was going to be approx 15 from pick up to delivery at my house. They keep pushing the time back 5-10 minutes each time. I'm still waiting for the pizza, which I'm sure won't be fresh or hot now. I called and texted the delivery driver but never got a response. I called the restaurant and told them that it really reflects poorly on them since they are the one who recommended that I order my delivery through Toast. The employee was super nice, but couldn't do anything for me since I ORDERED THROUGH TOAST. But, she did say she would relay my comments to the manager. Never going to order delivery from Knolla's again.

    Photos
    Knolla's Pizza
    Knolla's Pizza - Tiramisu is my fav

    Tiramisu is my fav

    Knolla's Pizza - My creation of beef, chicken, jalapeño,  and extra cheese. Yum!

    See all

    My creation of beef, chicken, jalapeño, and extra cheese. Yum!

    Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza - College Hill - Gamberoni

    Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza - College Hill

    4.2(151 reviews)
    9.6 mi
    $$

    Il Vicino is one of our favorite "chain" pizza spots (Il Vicino is a small chain that spans 3-4…read moreStates). In my opinion, there are 3 requirements that make a great pizza; fresh ingredients, dough flavor, and how it's cooked. Il Vicino almost always knocks it out of the park with those requirements. The ingredients are almost always (more on this later) fresh tasting, the dough flavor is absolutely delicious, and the woodfire cook is my favorite way to enjoy pizza, and it makes the place smell so good. I have never ordered anything other than pizza from Il Vicino, but my wife has had the pasta on a few occasions and I have sampled it. On one occasion she ordered the alfredo, and the pasta was well made and well flavored...it doesn't taste fresh-made, but still good. The alfredo sauce has good flavor, but is also unlikely made fresh in house and was runnier than I prefer. We've never tried their panini's or soups, but I've had almost every pizza on the menu. In dozens of visits, we've only had 2 experiences that were underwhelming. One time the pizza was simply undercooked...the flavors were on point, but it just needed a few more minutes in the oven. When a manager came by to check on us, I mentioned it to him, and he gave us 50% off the price after confirming that we declined having them to make us a new pizza. On the other occasion, something was clearly off with the freshness of the mushrooms...it almost seemed as if they had run out of their normal mushrooms, and instead of 86-ing them they ran to the store and bought canned. That said, it's only happened once, and I can forgive singular bad experiences. In terms of overall freshness of ingredients, you can tell that they're not the highest quality in the world, but they don't taste canned or frozen, and given the prices, I can live with "good quality." Which brings us to price. Prices are more than fair, and portions are appropriate for 1-2 people to enjoy a single pizza. Our family of 4 can usually eat there for under $30, sharing 2 pizzas that taste miles better than the national chains.

    This place was just as good as I remembered back when I went right before the pandemic basically…read moreclosed everything down. The prosciutto pizza was delicious, but the Caesar salad was a hit since it's one of the best Caesar salads I've had in my life. The spicy oil was super delicious especially when I eat it with bread that I wish I had taken some back home. The inside was cozy and it had a fall vibe to it. Overall, I would return to this place.

    Photos
    Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza - College Hill
    Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza - College Hill - Angeli - 08

    Angeli - 08

    Il Vicino Wood Oven Pizza - College Hill - Pizza with Pepperoni, sausage and slices of tomato on it.

    See all

    Pizza with Pepperoni, sausage and slices of tomato on it.

    Godfather's Pizza - Classic Combo

    Godfather's Pizza

    3.1(34 reviews)
    10.9 mi
    $$

    Very disappointed as of 1-20-2026. The pizza ingredients are not equal to several months ago, and…read morealso the flavor is not good. I think they are freezing the ingredients, which decreases the flavor. They obviously are not fresh as they were in the past. I think the previous employees quit there positions and these new hired employees dont accept their responsibilities. There was no employee at the counter for several minutes, and she was negligible. The current employees need to be replaced by responsible employees or this place will close. I ordered from Godfathers about every 2 weeks, previously, but I will not place another order ever again. It's a long drive for a pizza that is not nearly as favorable as it used to be. Soooo disappointed.

    Okay soooo apparently don't order from inside is what I am gathering from the other reviews?? My…read moreonly experience is delivery through DoorDash. To be completely transparent, I've done a ton of traveling and if the food tastes good to me, I'll pay whatever price within reason so the prices don't bother me. Inflation is here to stay and if it's THAT much of an issue for you, Little Caesars is right down the street for much cheaper, but you'll sacrifice taste and quality. I am usually a coal oven or wood fire pizza only Neapolitan or NY style pizza only kind of gal. However, for being neither of those things Godfather's Pizza is quite good. It does not "taste" chain to me, and I can indulge and not feel like complete trash after eating it. Little Caesars, Pizza Hut, and Dominoes are all within a couple of miles of Godfather's and having had all of them several times----Godfather's is the clear winner for me. There are a multitude of specialty pizzas in a generous number of sizes including mini which you don't find very often. Even the mini pizza had generous toppings, was made with care, and it was less than 10 dollars. The several times we have ordered, the cheese is plentiful, the toppings are evenly distributed, and our order has been 100% correct each time. Also, they actually cut CLEANLY through their pizzas! I don't know why but for whatever reason all the other chains in this area really struggle to cut their pizzas cleanly, so I am always having to run a knife through them anyway or the slices are tearing weird. I won't lie, looking at pictures of the pizza, they don't really look all that visually appealing but the taste is very solid. I also could wager that they don't travel all that well. Being heavy on the toppings and thicker slices I can imagine any travel time beyond like 10-15 minutes the pizzas probably become soggy pretty quickly. But overall, have I had better? Yes. Have I had worse? By far. But when you're looking for quick, convenient and most importantly tasty pizza---really I don't have any major criticisms and will continue to give them my business.

    Photos
    Godfather's Pizza - Storefront

    Storefront

    Godfather's Pizza
    Godfather's Pizza

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...