Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    3.8 (5 reviews)
    Open 5:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Their pizza was , however the "boneless wings" were dark, dry and hard to bite. Maybe wing chunks sat there all evening.‍

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Always great pizza! It's nice to have a Casey's so close. I like the good deals that I find on the app.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    This is actually my favorite pizza. Never thought a gas station would make such amazing pizza. Highly recommended

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,276 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Tasty Pizza Bar & Bowl - A cookie was nice.

    Tasty Pizza Bar & Bowl

    3.6(24 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $

    Not busy when I arrived. Ordered water with "some limes",…read moregot a tiny sliver of "a" lime. Okay. Pizza took over six minutes to go from the window to my table The heat lamp was not turned on so my pizza was already getting cold. Center was squishy not crispy. The $1.50 or "one topping" $1.95 green peppers barely made it out of the center of the cooled pizza. So your "first topping" will cost you $1.95 and each additional topping is $1.50. Oh, there are only Tobasco and Franks here for hot sauce . No creativity. No water refill offered either. Once the pizza did arrive, never was checked on to see if it was okay, it was NOT! I'm leaving this review only because the last time we gave this place a shot for food, it didn't go so well either. I have visited several times just to kill time though. Bartenders and servers vary in personality, ya never know if they have any hustle in them. Usually not. Bring a sweatshirt all year round, annoyingly cold in here. The music leans to rickety old classic rock. Not a happy feel, very Moose Lodge, or Eagles Club but cleaner. They have bingo, check before you come. My server knew the menu and prices well. She was very pleasant. Mushy center crust, very little topping dispersement, lack of topping choices, (very minimal, no jalapenos anywhere), very cooled-off pizza, time to deliver to table was not acceptable in any service industry I've worked in. I'll try again out of curiosity, but not if I'm in a hurry, or really counting on a stellar, crispy, thin crust pizza. If it goes better, I'll review accordingly. I wish things would have turned out better this time. Oh! And don't worry, I still tipped 40%. It's not all the servers fault and I'm not a monster!!....and all the customers got a cookie!

    Sooooo disappointed! We've lived in the area for over 35 years and Tasty's Pizza was our favorite…read morepizza joint for years. But after they moved to the bowling alley location, things have changed. I got a large specialty today, which was $26.41. It was not any where near as good as it used to be. The sauce was bland, the sausage had no flavor and the crust was like a frozen pizza. It used to have a great tasty sauce...a little spicy with a hint of sweetness...the sausage was flavorful...you could taste the fennel in it...and the crust was light, crispy and cracker like. It wasn't very good a couple years ago when I tried it either, but I was hoping they went back to their roots. They did not. Mansetti's in St. Francis and Chanticlear in Oak Grove, are much, much better. Hell, even Domino's in St. Francis is better, which tells you all you need to know. I will never get a pizza there again. Such a shame.

    Photos
    Tasty Pizza Bar & Bowl - View to the heat lamp where my pizza sat for over six minutes under the lamp that was not turned on.

    View to the heat lamp where my pizza sat for over six minutes under the lamp that was not turned on.

    Tasty Pizza Bar & Bowl - Small mushroom and green pepper pizza.  $1.50 for the green peppers that barely made it out of the center of the pizza.

    Small mushroom and green pepper pizza. $1.50 for the green peppers that barely made it out of the center of the pizza.

    Tasty Pizza Bar & Bowl - Sm cheese pizza-$9.99 Sm one topping pizza-$11.95 Sm pizza toppings-$1.50 ea  What is a "Total" fee of 59¢? This is a CC fee. See total.

    See all

    Sm cheese pizza-$9.99 Sm one topping pizza-$11.95 Sm pizza toppings-$1.50 ea What is a "Total" fee of 59¢? This is a CC fee. See total.

    Goose Lake Artisan & Farmers Market

    Goose Lake Artisan & Farmers Market

    3.7(3 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$

    I can't honesty review this business having said I've been there, but I can tell you WHY I didn't…read morego there. The lady who answers the phone is rude beyond belief. I purchased a voucher through Living Social for a pizza and wine tasting at this business. So far, so good. In tiny print at the bottom (I acknowledge that I missed this) it said "valid on Sunday's only." So, shoot me--I mistakenly called and tried to get a Saturday reservation. The woman on the phone made it clear in no uncertain terms that I was dumber than dirt for requesting a non-Sunday reservation. She made it pretty clear that I wasn't the first idiot to not read the terms of the offer. At first, I figured she was having a bad day and was simply fed up with getting a million Living Social voucher-holders calling to request a day on which the voucher wasn't valid. Okay, I get that--dealing with the public can be trying and even though I was polite and respectful, I may have been her last straw for the day. Enter my second attempt to make a reservation a couple of weeks later. On a Sunday! Woo Hoo! I call on Sunday morning at 9:00 AM. "Hi, I'd like to make a reservation for your wine and pizza special for lunch today." Big sigh from the (same) woman on the phone. "We require 24 hours notice," said in the same condescending tone I'd heard a few weeks before. "Well," say I--beginning to get really irritated with this gal, "Do you have anything available?" I figure if they're doing a Living Social special, it's because they need the business, right? Another big sigh. "We NEED 24 hours notice. We've already put in the pizza order for today." "And you cut it so close that there isn't two pieces left over?" I want to ask (but don't). Instead I say, "Could you perhaps call the pizza place and change the order?" Another HUGE sigh. "Maybe. But I can't make any promises. They don't open until noon." I explain that I am two hours away so that making me wait until noon to let me know if I can come and partake of their stupid pizza and wine for lunch isn't going to do me much good. A snappish retort, "We NEED 24 hours notice." "Yes, I get that, but now I am trying to determine if this is a possibility WITHOUT 24 hours notice. Am I to understand that you can't give me a definitive answer until noon? Because if that is the case, it's not going to work for me." With condescension,' I am TRYING to explain to you that we MUST HAVE 24 hours notice." This time, it was me who sighed. She finally acquiesced that she wouldn't be able to commit by noon and her tone insinuated that there was a snowball's chance in hell that she was going to call the pizza place. I tore up the voucher. $15 bucks wasted for sure, but compared to the aggravation saved by NOT going to this place? Priceless.

    Had a great time at Goose Lake! Had some good wines and the owner was very knowledgeable and quite…read morefriendly! They've got animals roaming, including a peacock that jumped up onto the hood of our truck and wanted to go home with us!! The farmers market was small but nice with some great products! As we were leaving, a food truck, Jellybean & Junes (I believe that was the name) showed up. Wish we could've stuck around to taste their food! Would be a great place to bring kids to feed the animals, food is available to purchase for the animals...nice touch! We will definitely be going back!!

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...