Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    4.0 (1 review)
    Open 4:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 197 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    East End Double Dip

    East End Double Dip

    (30 reviews)

    $

    I've been to East End Double Dip just once as I don't normally consume dairy ice cream but was…read moreinvited along. They did have some unique flavors and large waffle cones which don't look like they came from a factory. Portions were above average. I was not expecting it to be a cash only business, so the person who dragged me along paid for my order, as I rarely carry cash anymore. In fact, I've discovered since I moved to this area that a lot of Peru businesses only accept cash. Slightly shady in my opinion and definitely inconvenient in this century. It's a somewhat cute little walk-up place. The limited seating outside seems to always be packed. It's seasonal, so it's not open year-round. I'd rather not eat outside in the heat nor do I especially enjoy dining in a car. My cone was already beginning to melt before I even got to dig in. The sandwich I got to go was alright, but that was from the separate pizza place behind it. Cash only as well and no delivery. Service was alright from what I remember. I'm sure this is a beloved place by many locals. It just doesn't have anything that would really draw me back for another go. I do know that a lot of patrons walk through the yards of the surrounding homes, park blocking driveways, and toss their trash into said yards. So, if you go, find a trash can or take your refuse with you. Simply put, just don't be a jerk.

    A hometown favorite - the nostalgia is part of the charm for me. Recently introduced my LA raised…read morebf to the pizza & a beagle ice cream dessert. He was a fan of both! The italian sausage is incomparable to others. I did feel they skimmed a bit on pizza sauce. Forgot to snap pics of the pizza! Service was friendly. Love the old school walk up and order vibes. We got everything to go!

    Domino's Pizza - Build your own pasta with veggies. Called to request robust pizza sauce instead of marinara to make it dairy free.

    Domino's Pizza

    (7 reviews)

    $

    I just picked up my order. My pizza was not cut into slices. It was one big slice. I am not…read morehappy that they forgot to run the cutter through the pizza.

    Dominos was never my favorite pizza except for one location I frequented years ago. The good thing…read moreabout Dominos is they're open later than other restaurants. It's one of the only delivery options in Peru, especially at night, and it's more affordable than the competing pizza chains. Online coupons are budget helpers. I hadn't ordered from here in quite a while. I did a few times when I first moved to Peru. Things were chaotic, and I was hungry. I was eating a bit of dairy here and there, but I've removed it completely again for heath & ethical reasons. That being said, there are not many plant based options, but thanks to some helpful websites that do the homework for me, I was able to easily figure out what I'd like to have. For what I got, this seemed a bit pricey, but it was really one of two restaurants open for delivery. Even though nothing was available on local delivery services, after issues from them all, I'd much rather order straight from a restaurant and not have a middleman to mess everything up. I'm low on groceries and really just wanted something to eat. I will only utilize this in emergencies, not just because of the small selection but the service isn't as good as it used to be. I used an online coupon to order the Mediterranean garden veggie sandwich and a build your own pasta. I called after I placed my order to ask for the robust pizza sauce instead of their marinara on my pasta since the pizza sauce has no dairy, and there isn't anywhere online to make a substitution request. I was on hold for nearly six minutes, listening to several schpeels. I hung up and called back and got someone right away who was vet nice and accommodating over my request. My sandwich had banana peppers on it, and that was something I requested for them to leave off. They're just something I can't eat anymore the older I get. The veggies were pretty sparse and sloppy. Seeing how I didn't get the cheese, it would have been nice to get a better amount of veg. I scraped most of them into my pasta and turned the bread into garlic bread. I don't remember the sandwich being very stellar even when I had it with cheese over a year ago anyway. Dominos' pasta primavera was actually really good in the past. It just needed garlic and black pepper, but since I didn't want dairy, I did a build your own tonight. As I said, I called to request robust pizza sauce instead of the marinara. The pasta looked far better than the sandwich, especially after I doctored it up with what I had in the house. I'm full, and it was semi healthy even though it lacked much of a protein source. Even doctored up, and I'm a pretty good cook, it was just okay. Overpriced, yet not as bad as what I checked out on the site of the other pizza place that was still open. Again, something I'd reserve for emergencies when starving. I really just need to move to a real city with better options. While the man who answered the phone was great, and I have had some awesome delivery drivers from here in the past, this one left my food on the porch for the no contact delivery as requested but sent no text and didn't call like I'm accustomed to receiving from this Dominos. I also always add "Please call, don't knock" to my orders. And for pre tipping over 30%, it was a little disappointing there was no notification or thank-you. Luckily, I had the tracker and kept an eye out. I'm sure there is a high turn over, so the people I had before may very well be long gone. This Dominos isn't awful, and I'm grateful there was at least something I could eat. I just won't be a regular. If you're in Peru and want something late, which really isn't even "late" by my standards, it's a decent choice. I'd go for the pasta before their pizzas and bread which can be greasy and lacking flavor. Another bonus is that, with the exception of 2020, (not sure about later) this Dominos is open on Christmas. I don't like making someone waiting on me on holidays, but it's good for those who WANT to work those days. A good driver I had Christmas Eve 2020 was a lifesaver when I didn't have food in the house and was explaining how he was bummed corporate was not allowing them to work that Christmas Day. I do have to say they are almost always super fast. That's why I was afraid to be on hold too long. There was a chance my dish was already being made. Dominos is open until Midnight. They're competitor across the street is only open until 11. I believe the other chain nearby is only open until 9 or 10.

    Papa Johns Pizza - Leaking garlic sauce

    Papa Johns Pizza

    (9 reviews)

    $

    I feel like I'm being a bit generous with three stars, but I'll roll with it since two seems…read moreslightly harsh. I hadn't had Papa John's in many years and never from this particular location. I'm left wondering what in the world happened to the quality. While the prices were lower than a competitor down the street if you order online and choose"deals," it's really not an inexpensive meal choice anymore. Better pizza than the competition across the way but not good. Papa John's used to have the best crust resembling a bread stick. Now it's flat and hard and dotted with puncture like marks. When did that start? Every other time I had Papa John's, the crust WAS the bread stick hence the signature garlic sauce included. I can't have them anymore, but I swear they used to place more than one pepperoncini pepper in the box along with the cup of garlic dipping sauce. They seemed to skimp on cheese and toppings even when extra toppings were requested. Floppy and messy. One of the pizzas had a cup of garlic sauce which was open and leaked along one side through the cardboard and all over the undercarriage of that pizza. When I gently opened that cup the rest of the way, it exploded and made a huge greasy mess. The bread sticks were soft and far batter than the crust. No flavor though other than the sauces you choose. Ten bread sticks, but some are small and oddly shaped. One cup of sauce per box. You can add extra sauces or get a deal on two extra cups for less if you click in the right place online. Even with their deals, two boxes of bread sticks cost more than a large pizza. I had to get two to get the price since I didn't want wings or the other sides. You're going to want plenty of extra sauce. Speaking of sauce, their cheese sauce is pale. It's spicy but the flavor isn't at all what I expected. The garlic is still the way to go, imo. They had a lot of other sauces they didn't use to have. I was hoping they had a salad on the menu. Nope. I also found it odd they don't have their own delivery drivers anymore. My online order was redirected to a Doordash tracker. My driver was polite and prompt though. I don't normally eat stuff like this, and after this experience, I doubt I would order from here again. Homemade or store bought seems more economical and the choice if you want flavor. I don't know what I was thinking and regret wasting money on this. My four legged pizza party dining companions were happy and had fun though. That was the only redeeming quality of this experience. The Papa John's I knew as a whole since the nineties is no more. Long gone are the days when pizza was a cheap dinner option on nights you don't feel like cooking or are having a celebration. Back when Papa John's had a simpler menu in simpler times, it was actually the best of all the chains. Sad now.

    Boneless chicken tasted like chicken nuggets all of the chicken nuggets was not covered in barbecue…read moresauce, cheese sticks, tasted good, but were kind of cold, and the marinara sauce tasted more like tomato sauce then a marinara

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...