I have had many many many many many slices of pizza from Casey's pizza and it has never steered me…read morewrong in fact I love Casey's pizza

Not the first time we have had a problem with this Caseys pizza, we were told 45 min for pick up…read morewhich I was fine with then when I get there they said another 15 min which ended up to be another half hour, they did not even put my pizzas in the oven till after my second 15 min wait . The manager finally walked in after I'd been there for 25 min spouting off orders, but in my option she should have had better control on her staff in order not to fall this far behind. I'm not looking for a free meal I'm looking at having my order filled on time and correctly. They had my number also so they could have called and said it was gonna be longer. When I did get home with my 2 pizzas 1 was cooked but could tell it was sitting for a little while, while the other one was so undercooked my 3 year old grandson who loves pizza said it tasted yuckie. Not impressed at all

Good tasting food and always have great service. I love the look of the place a lot too. The only…read moredown side is it's very pricey while having smaller portions compared to similar dining experiences.

Wonderful everything taste great and service was great and polite and fast. Building was clean and…read morenice

We stopped here for lunch on the way out of town. We were the only customers and had a great…read moreconversation with one of the staff members who is visiting all the MN State Parks as we are. We chose a hand tossed pepperoni and black olive pizza. It was good. Served nice and hot. Lots of cheese and toppings. The inside is decorated like a pizzeria but the outside is basically a warehouse with a sign. Don't let the outside deter you. Splitting the small pizza was a good lunch portion. Good stop.

Last month, I tried to call them no one answered my phone call. I called again no answer, and I…read moredrove there the soutside sign said, their business has closed for good.

Home cooked food, great chicken and burgers and the staff are always kind and attentive…read more Eat here almost every week in a nice downtown Paynesville restaurant.

My first time eating here. I will definitely be coming back…read morethe service was very welcoming. A nice pace as we just moved here from Princeton. Pizza was definitely great you can tell it's homemade. Sauce was on point, not too sweet Fries were golden and not overdone. I would 100% recommend this place. Prices are ok too!

The food is okay... some better than others, but Jimmies Pizza is very expensive and their food…read moremost definitely is not worth the buck.

Poor service and average pizza. We waited an extra 30 minutes for our pizzas at the store, after…read morethe hour they said it would be when we placed the order. Nobody helped us for 20 minutes. Very disappointing, not to mention VERY overpriced.

We randomly had to be in New London and needed to find a place for dinner and wanted to see the…read moredowntown area and so ended up at Goat Ridge. It did not disappoint. It was a bit confusing about what you were supposed to do when you came in. We waited for a while to get seated but then discovered that you're supposed to order at the bar and seat yourself. Signage needs to be better to let new people know what's up. Beyond this, everything was great. I got the NA lager and wife got the ginger beer. Both did not disappoint. Everything But the Goat pizza was an excellent supreme pizza. Sausage in particular was delicious. Loved the fresh veggies as well. The outdoor seating area was fantastic in the summer. Live music and the river created a perfect evening!

Fun place. Lots of inside space of its cold or rainy out, but they have a wonderful beer garden…read morenext to the crow river which is perfect for a lazy summer afternoon. I don't drink, so I can't comment on the beer. But based on what I saw they looked like they had a good selection, even a reasonable NA menu. My daughter ordered a salad which I tried. Really nice. Healthy and tasty. I am sure the rest of the food is great as well. Looking forward to coming back later this summer or sometime in the fall. It's probably perfect in the fall. Cheers!

This was very good pizza, everyone was happy with it. We ordered a large cheeseburger pizza on…read morethin crust, pizza rolls, and the gluten free crustbwith steak and chicken. The pizza rolls were more like a calzone with pepperoni or think of their pizza fries with pepperoni in them. Everyone liked the pizzas. I ordered the gluten free for myself and it was so good. The steak had great flavor and the crust tasted like a regular pizza. Since we were visiting the area we will be giving the local Jimmy's a try hopefully it is just as goos.

pA good pizza place in the Cold Sring area. service has always been good there. would recommendread more

Ok so I said I wouldn't go back. I waited a year and have been a few times since my initial review…read more I obviously caught them on a rough night. Each time I've been back has been great food, great service. Their pizza is awesome. My usual is the bacon cheeseburger and love it. The sandwiches are tasty too!

Stopping in Melrose, Minnesota overnight and trying to find decent food was tough. I had an itch…read morefor pizza which I'm kind of a snob with so with the reviews I decided to check out this place. I walked in and the atmosphere was up and everybody was happy and it looked like a good start. I asked my waitress what she would suggest I order if I wanted to come back every day for the rest of my life and that will seem to be a tough question for her. She made a few crazy suggestions and I decided to go with a purist pizza of meat and cheese. Extra cheese. I also ordered a garden vegetarian delight pizza in order to get my rabbit food in for the day. Both pizzas came out pretty quick and were nice and hot. I was expecting some serious meat and at least enough cheese to cover the pizza so I was very disappointed. I wish I would've asked for them to be cooked a while longer as well because they were thin crust and I like my thin crust crunchy. The vegetarian pizza was OK, again if the crust was crispy it would've been better. They were approximately $20 apiece for the large which wasn't really that large so again I was slightly disappointed there. If I'm ever in that area again, which is entirely possible, I probably would try somewhere different. I will say the place got really really busy in the time that I took to order and eat with the locals. Just cause it's busy does it make it great.

I just ordered a pizza and two rootbeer sodas and I believe it was by far the BEST tasting pie I've…read morehad to this date. I have ordered Jimmy's pizza since 1997 and the varieties have always been a good taste, never dissapointed. But tonight, I tried a completely new recipe...cauliflower crust, alfredo sauce, peperoni, onion, black olives cheese and cheddar. OMG you must try it. The only thing that I think might make it better is asiago sausage. Thanks guys, hats off and keep up the great work!! NDH

I ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza and the jimmy sticks with marinara and garlic butter. They…read moreforgot my garlic butter and this is not the first time they have forgotten items I ordered. Not happy