Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open 4:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Scott D.
    10
    46
    33

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 281 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Donnies Homespun Pizza - Avocado salmon burger! With chips & hummus.

    Donnies Homespun Pizza

    (88 reviews)

    $

    Stopped in for a little pre-game meal before heading out for Friday night football. The place was…read moreseat yourself and starting to fill up. I grabbed a spot at a very small bar and ordered a new IPA and 10 inch pepperoni and pineapple pizza. The bartender/server was very friendly and knowledgeable of the local beer scene. Enjoyed chatting with him while I waited for my pie. The cool came out and let me know that he messed my pizza up and was making it again. Almost made me late for the game but I didn't mind. Appreciative that it was made right. The dining room/bar was lightly decorated and had a homey vibe and included some cool art. Definitely recommend

    Cool place that's a surprise to find in Decatur. It's not the expected little pizza parlor, but a…read morecool bar and restaurant. Donnie's has some hip vibes going on, with cool old music and fun employees. For sure it's like nothing else around here. There's also lots of plant based options. A very different pizza place than we thought it would be. I assumed this was just going to be like a dumpy place and you order at a counter. This turned out to be a place with a full bar, and has a lot more going on. Basically it has a kind of classic hard rock theme with cool artwork. The food rocked too. It has more than just pizza. There's also plenty of appetizers and salads. We got an appetizer to share. It was the Vegan Antipasto. It's about $9 for a bowl full of good stuff. There was hummus along with giardiniera, olives, onions, pitas, spinach, and tomatoes. For the pizza, they have vegan topping choices. They happened to be out of these. Has lots of interesting things to try here. It's certainly the most unique restaurant in town. They have lots of traditional pizzas and have options for vegans and vegetarians.

    Pizza Factory

    Pizza Factory

    (22 reviews)

    $$

    This place not only has the most delicious pizza but it also has the best staff ever!! I mentioned…read moreit was my birthday and they wrote wishes on my box!! The toppings are generous and they are fast!

    We were recommended this place by a family member and he really hyped up the pizza! The pizza…read morewas... okay. However even after a speedy delivery and spending $67 plus a generous tip, the breadsticks we ordered 13.99 for 12 cheesy and 6.99 for 5 regular, were 1. Soggy with butter and 2. Ice cold. Us, being broke college students figured we would soak it up with a paper towel! We were able to squeeze a breadstick and watch butter drip off of it in a steady stream. However... it only turned us off from seeing just HOW MUCH BUTTER was on the breadsticks. We replaced Mariana with garlic butter but that came in a SEPARATE CUP. So, i decided to call. The call started with me explaining that there was a pool of butter in the tinfoil, and the bread was not edible. It was explained to be that "that's how our breadsticks come" and "99% of our customers know that's how it comes and love it." I was to blame, for trying a local pizza place. I explained that we didn't know- I was talked over, and down to. He kept explaining the same thing to me so I said I understood but I still wanted the partial refund. Fist he offered to send a whole new box out to us and TAKE the old one. Which, working fast food I know you don't do. I said no, because it seemed redundant and likely would cost them more in gas, ingredients, etc. he put me on a brief hold, then came back. He said he would "meet me in the middle" and give us $12 back on the card. Which doesn't even cover the big box. I said no, and said "is $21 going to make or break you guys?" He first refused to give me his name- saying it was "none of my business". I explained that I WORK CUSTOMER SERVICE and know that I am allowed his first name (I offered to drive out if needed) he then said his name was Jim, and that he was the manager. I don't believe it strictly because of how absolutely baffled I am by his lack of decorum, his attitude, and the fact he went round and round blaming me for something that I don't know. The person who ordered has now been blocked from the website to order in the future. While we don't remember everything said I'd like to add that I am very rarely rude to workers, because I am a part time service employee and KNOW how hard it is. From jump, Jim was rude and condescending while trying to also tell me that he was "trying to make the customer happy"

    Del Carmen's Pizza

    Del Carmen's Pizza

    (1 review)

    I recently moved back home to Decatur Il and couldn't help but think about Del Carmens pizza. It…read morewas just that goodI would usually order from the one on 22nd St but that one no longer exists, so I went with the one in Mt Zion as the other two were closed on Sunday. I ordered two large 18 inch cheese pizzas. I paid almost $60 for this pizza and it wasn't worth the price. I was told it would be ready by 7:30p, I made it by 7:35-7:40. By the time I made it home the pizza was stale, cheese was very dark with no melt to it, it was hard to chew and it was not hot at all. I am very disappointed in Del Carmens for giving me, what I assume was old pizza that had been sitting there. I expected my pizza to be made as ordered, not leftovers from earlier that day or possibly the day before. I received a coupon for next time, but I will not be visiting this pizza parlor again. It doesn't take pizza that long to cook and for them to give me old pizza was a slap in the face. Del Carmens and the employees need to do a better job of delivering quality food for the prices they charge.

    From the owner: Products Pizza…read more Services Delivery, Dine-In, Catering Business Description Welcome to Del Carmen's Pizza, the pizza with pizazz based in Decatur, IL, serving the surrounding areas with mouth-watering pizzas that will satisfy your cravings for over 52 years! Established with a passion for creating delicious pizzas, Del Carmen's Pizza offers a wide range of delectable choices for both dine-in and delivery. Our focus is on providing quality pizzas made with fresh ingredients and a blend of flavors that will keep you coming back for more. Come experience the taste of perfection at Del Carmen's Pizza!

    lulus pizza - Supreme pizza...16"

    lulus pizza

    (6 reviews)

    I have ordered Pizza's several times and have to admit that it is one of the best ones so far…read more I have tried several combinations, but prefer the simple ones with the mix sauce.

    Lengthy story, but please read it-…read more Here's a story about LuLu's pizza, it's Kylan's favorite, he's always wanting to go there. We thought it was a great place and really nice people worked there even people that cared, we were very wrong. As most of you know I was in an accident last Sunday, when on my way home. I was planning to pick up a pizza once I got into South Shores for little man on my way. After calling 911, my husband and daughter, I asked Krista to call Lulu's and cancel order since I was just in an accident and couldn't make it and she didn't have a car seat for Kylan so I knew she couldn't go get it either. When she called, she was told by the manager Jeff, that the pizza was already finished and waiting and if we weren't going to come get it, then we would be put on a list and no longer be able to call in orders for a pizza. I was floored by this establishments lack of compassion and empathy. Needless to say my daughter ever the worrier, dug and old car seat out of the garage and went and picked up the pizza, she didn't want LuLu's to think we were deadbeats or miss out on their $13.00, since that was their main concern. After leaving the hospital and hearing what my daughter had to do, I called LuLu's and apologized about everything and was met with callous rudeness about the situation. I'm writing this in hopes that some of you will share this and think twice about buying anything from an establishment that cares so little about a member of their own community. Please feel free to share this post or pass it on if you know the owners. As for our family we won't be back again.

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...