I don't know if it's ALL of the Casey's or just the ones around me. I stop at various Casey's, usually 5-6 times a week but sometimes more.
Two days ago around 8am, I wanted a slice of pizza from the Durant location and the pizza was expired by over a half-hour and they still had it out. I told the lady behind the counter and she said there wouldn't be more for ten more minutes. I asked her if she was going to take the old slices out and she said not until the new pizza was ready. Disgusting and appalling. I was going to settle on cheesy hash brown rounds and they were burnt, also expired and she didn't have any of them cooking yet.
Yesterday around 730am, I bought a muffin from the University Drive, Muscatine, location and it expired two days previous.
Today around 915am, I bought a dozen doughnuts from the Wilton location and my cake doughnuts were doughy and undercooked (not the first time I've had that problem) and my triangle-cream-filled doughnuts were hollow inside and didn't have cream.
To say that I'm disappointed in Casey's is a massive understatement. I also sent this to their corporate office. I will update my review if/when they contact me with a response. read more