Thanks to fellow Yelpers, found this quality pizza place while traveling near Crawfordsville…read more We walked in and felt very welcome. We were greeted by the friendly staff. The pepperoni honey pie was recommended so we tried out the hot and sweet pizza. Yummy, yummy. The restaurant smells delicious and is super clean. The whole kitchen prep area is open and you can watch them prepare the dough and make your pizza. The wood stove is the amazing centerpiece of the kitchen. If you're in the area it's worth a try for great pizza.

I have had the same perfect pizza several times, and my husband is working his way through the…read moremenu. 5 stars every visit.

Decided to give their pizza a try for dinner while passing through town. They only offer carry out…read moreor delivery, something important to know. The building is a bit dark and odd inside. The individual taking our order was really nice, informed us that our order should be ready in about 15 minutes and she was spot on. Breadsticks were so delicious, they were only slightly firm on the outside and super soft and chewy on the inside. Pizzas were a bit on the greasy side (like puddles underneath them), but were good. Pepperoni was spicier than expected (which wasn't a bad thing) and the Cheese Boss was (dare I say) almost too cheesy. Definitely worth giving a try if you're looking for good pizza on the go.

Amazing pizza! The sauce has a great flavor. The crust is a perfect blend of not too thin and not…read moretoo thick. Don't take my cheese pizza photo for what they would make you--I always ask for light cheese and heavy sauce. Our only wishes--serve the breadstick sauce hot not cold. And offer green olives as a topping and you would be perfect. But we are pizza picky for sure. Take note, as of Oct 3, this place is take-out or delivery only. We had never been here. The employee was really nice. We placed our order to go and went outside. He brought our order to us in our vehicle within 15 minutes. Great service. The prices are also very reasonable. $24 for 2 pizzas and breadsticks. We will definitely add this pizza place to our list of places to return.

It's a slow pace. Don't go here if you are in a hurry. If you were looking for a chill vibe and…read moresome excellent food, this is your space. I got the chicken bacon ranch sandwich and it was the most delicious buttery crisp soft bread that I've ever had on a sandwich. I could've just thrown all of the toppings off and eaten the bread and Ben in heaven. The crisp bacon and the ranch and chicken and cheese gooey gooey in the middle of all the delicious bread Just elevated the experience. Throw in the cinnamon twist breadsticks that were wonderfully soft, gooey, gooey, and coated in icing and this was an over-the-top experience for me. So glad I checked it out and tried something different.

We have ALWAYS had great food at Greeks, but Charity made our experience super. She is the best…read morewaitress we have had there. She checked up on us and made sure everything was good. Thanks Charity for adding to the Greeks excellence!

You can never go wrong with an Arni's Jr. . This is a salad that is top full of diced meat and…read morecheese. There's a little bit of radish in it too. I love their blue cheese dressing. It is so thick and creamy and you really don't taste the blue cheese crumbles at all. I also enjoy their pepperoni pizza. I like how the pepperoni is crumbles. Thin crust makes it even more tasty in my opinion. The sauce is amazing! With a salad order, you'll be out the door in five minutes with a pizza order. You'll be out the door in 15 minutes. If you decide to dine in, they have several seats and some outdoor seating. I noticed they have soup on the menu too. That will be something to stop in and get this winter.

Good lil mom and pop joint food is good and quick and there's a lot of it only complaint there mean…read moredoesn't say what is in your order

You know what Crawfordsville didn't need? Another pizza joint. You know what Crawfordsville did…read moreneed? A high quality pizza joint like Mama Fazio's. Sadly, even with all the pizza places in town, my favorite was still, as much as I hate to admit, Pizza Hut...until last night after trying Mama Fazio's. We ordered breadsticks and an XL (18 inch) supreme pizza (no anchovies)to be delivered to the new brewery in town. I loved that the breadsticks orders each included two dipping sauces--no fighting over dipping choices there! The breadsticks were soft and well seasoned. The supreme pizza was amazing, even warmed up for lunch today. Toppings stuffed high and covered in fresh mozzarella cheese. I think this is the only pizza place in Crawfordsville with ground sausage other than Arni's. My only complaint is that they used canned mushrooms instead of fresh. That actually tends to be a deal-breaker for me, but the rest of the pizza was so good that I can overlook it! I see a lot of orders from Mama Fazio's in our future.

Barstool fan review…read more Frankie we are here in Crawfordsville. Home of the worst restaurants in Indiana. One bite everyone knows the rules. Mama Fazio's is a hole in the wall pizzeria just off the corner of the blustering downtown Crawfordsville. One bite, everyone knows the rules. Just on pizza alone. It's one of the best in town, which isn't saying much. If you want to try the blandest pizza in all the land Crawfordsville is the place. Arnis with their tomato paste sauce. Marco's with their cardboard crust. And then the collection of national conglomerates. That is about it. But one bite, everyone knows the rules---- 6.3. One bite. Everyone knows the rules. The flop was real. Real bad. Cheese thicker than crust. No flakiness. Too much oil not enough flour. Sauce is real good. Pepperoni spicy. Too much cheese. Basic. But might be the best pizza in Crawfordsville. Which isn't saying much. Three stars is on the salad, breadsticks, and wings. The sauce came on the side which looked like the nacho cheese I ordered for the breadsticks. Salad was good. Not Arni's good, but it's hard to screw up a salad. I could tell their dough and breadsticks were frozen. Three stars on the location. Most restaurants in C-Ville are two stars. So it is above average. Rookie rating scale by Yelp! Should be a 2.7.

Ordered 2 pizzas one in picture has topping missing on 2 slices ! Very disappointing food…read morepreparation. And it was carry out so the pizza was not tossed around in car.

Terrible service unplugged the phone refused my order manager was fired for such poor service…read more Please view my photo for the entire story

This is my second review of this pizza king. The first review does not show up on here for some…read morestrange reason. It is still the same! When you order pizza you hardly get any sauce and have to request extra sauce to even taste it. It is also completely flavorless! Ordered mushrooms on our pizza and got canned/jarred mushrooms! How awful, no fresh ingredients? Just terrible! This is NOT like the old pizza kings that used to be!!!!! Plus they have been charging over 3% fees for your order total for using a debit card. Won't be back!

I've tried both delivery and drive thru options, both were great experiences! The food tastes very…read moregood, and have always gotten my food hot. It's located a bit far from downtown but it's worth it.

I love going here for the salad bar just great . I have always loved the hut pizza . The waitress's…read moreare always friendly . Food is always hot and good

Second time in two weeks our pick up order has been completely screwed up/lost. Absolutely horrible…read moreservice! Rolled up to the window right on time. Cant find your order please pull up.....20 minutes later go inside. 10 minutes later someone ask if they can help me! WOW! That's 30 minutes of my time Pizza Hut. So refund so sorry. Tack another 15 minutes of waiting while we remake your order. Now I am at 45 minutes out of MY Sunday night. Lobby is now full and cars wrapping around the building. This is the second time Crawfordsville Pizza Hut has done this to me. Think I'll be back?

If I could give this place zero stars I would. My husband picked up an order through the drive thru…read moreand was insulted by an employee about the condition of his truck and made fun of him. WILL NEVER GO BACK TO THIS AWFUL PLACE!! Don't give them a penny!!!

Food has gotten much better but they just decreased their delivery radius to under 2 miles,…read moreapparently. My organization is 3 miles away, my house is 4 miles away. I ordered a lot of pizza through them for my organization and personally. Probably about $100 a month. Well, guess I gotta figure something else out. I have been ordering Domino's delivery since 2006. I know franchise owners. But, I need delivery. Good luck Domino's. And remember, this isn't the city. Rural communities do better with larger delivery ranges.

Open until midnight and always great customer service. Very well lit and clean restrooms.read more

Always clean and I can get in and get out. The cashiers are always friendly and helpfulread more