1. Carroll's Cuts

0

Freehold, NJ

Cancel

Open app

Search

Carroll's Cuts

5.0 (1 review)

Services - Carroll's Cuts

Haircut

Haircut and shave

Shave only

Carroll's Cuts Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carroll's Cuts

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Barbers 3,107 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The New York Shaving Company

The New York Shaving Company

4.6(25 reviews)
0.6 mi

Excellent barber shop in the old style tradition. The shop is well appointed and brings you back to…read morethe old days. Nostalgic 40's music playing. Located in one of the oldest refurbished brick factory buildings in Freehold. Great personal service. Highly recommended.

I booked my husband's first straight razor shave at New York Shaving Company in Freehold after…read moreresearching local barbershops for a traditional hot towel shave with all the pampering. The shop's 1940s atmosphere and music were exactly what I had hoped for, but the service and cleanliness fell short. The website described the $50 Ultimate Shave as including a hot towel, shaving both with and against the grain, eyebrow and nose grooming, and a brief facial massage. My husband only received a shave with the grain, and afterward, several areas of his face still felt rough. This wasn't the thorough, smooth shave we expected. I also noticed thick dust on the interior shelves and boxes of razors and shaving products. An old-school atmosphere can be charming, but a business providing personal grooming services should be spotless. My husband did find the experience relaxing, which I appreciated. However, for $50, customers should receive the complete advertised service in a clean, well-maintained setting. We left feeling that the experience didn't deliver the value or attention to detail we had hoped for.

Photos
The New York Shaving Company - Old school 1950's Barber Shop

Old school 1950's Barber Shop

The New York Shaving Company - Photo was taken two days after, so the hair has grown in slightly.

Photo was taken two days after, so the hair has grown in slightly.

The New York Shaving Company - Our products used exclusively during each service

See all

Our products used exclusively during each service

Suite 23 Barber Shop - Actually happy with a hair cut. Whatttt?

Suite 23 Barber Shop

3.7(13 reviews)
0.1 mi

Appointment was at 12pm for a 1 hour haircut and shave with Dom. I showed up 15 minutes early and…read moretake a seat. Not 1 person acknowledged me. 12:20 rolls around when I stand up to ask when I'll be seen. The barber, Dom, who is cutting someone else, said "Oh I thought you were a walk-in. I'll be right with you." Dom calls me up at 12:40pm. He seemed to rush through the haircut and shave. He spun me around so much it gave me whiplash. By 12:55pm someone else walks in, shakes Dom's hand, they shoot the s***, and Dom says "I'll be right with you." By 1pm, Dom says we're all set. He obviously wanted to be on time for his regular customer and rushed through me. I paid and left, never to return. I paid for a 1 hour session that lasted 20 minutes. Looking in the mirror, it was the worst haircut I ever got. It was comically uneven in the back, and they left plenty of hair on my neck. My wife even laughed when I got home. Luckily my friend was in town and was able to fix the uneven spots before a party that night. I had to shave my neck where Dom missed. The lack of acknowledgement when I walked in, the indifference towards the late call, the rushed uneven haircut and shave to take the next client on time, are all reasons I will never return. There was no apology and I felt like they couldn't care less. It's one of those places that only takes care of you if they know you. Check out Evil Fades in Millstone for a good haircut, shave, and baseline customer service.

So I never come out of a place actually happy with a hair cut. The place is extremely chill. Not…read moreentirely oh, based off the music lyrics, but incredibly chill. Had this lady named Natalya and my hair cut came out amazing. 10/10 would come here again.

Carroll's Cuts - barbers - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...