Cake by Sierra Photos
Business Info
You might also consider
More like Cake by Sierra
Recommended Reviews - Cake by Sierra
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Sierra has made my girls birthday cakes the past 2 years. Sierra is super easy to provide ideas to and she runs with it and everything turns out beautifully. All our guests are amazed by how the cakes look and even MORE impressed by how delicious it tastes. I've had a number of guests say it's the best birthday cake they've had!! We know other bakers personally, but I keep choosing Sierra because her results cannot be beat and prices seem very reasonable for what you get.
Sierra knocked it out of the park with a cake for my spouse's birthday. They love Lego so I was looking for an "elevated look" with Lego theme, but didn't want too much fondant. Within minutes of submitting the online form and providing inspiration photos Sierra confirmed the design and everything was set. Delivery to our house the morning of was even better! We all loved the cake - it tasted great & was the perfect surprise!
I contacted Sierra for the first time for a hot wheels cake for my sons 4th birthday. Sierra was great sending me a quote and adjusting small details in order to make sure the details in the quote would reflect the cake I wanted made. Communication through email was pretty responsive, not immediate but she would eventually reply. Pricing for the cake itself and for delivery was very reasonable! She arrived on time with the cake and saved me a LOT of stress. Cake itself was good. I've posted pictures of the inspiration cake and the cake she made. We got lots of compliments on it and the taste was actually pretty good too. It was not too sweet and by far the best tasting of all fondant cakes I've ordered in the past from other vendors. The one thing I was upset about were the orange race tacks on the bottom half of the cake. While everything else was done quite beautifully, the tracks were not very neat. I notice details a lot so of course it bothered me more than it should've. The cake overall looked great and no one seemed to notice the tracks. I just wish she would've made sure that she could've pulled those off before making the cake. But again, small detail and not a deal breaker. Overall it was a great experience and I'd most likely order again with her. Thanks Sierra!
Super friendly, amazing cupcakes! Highly recommend Sierra she is so sweet and has a knack for making tasty treats. We asked her a week in advance to make cupcakes for our sons first birthday, and we were very pleased by her service, her friendliness and the quality of the cupcake. She returns calls in a timely manner highly recommend.
Sierra is such an amazing and talented baker who surprised us with the most creative cake and cupcakes for my daughter's 5th Barbie birthday. The cakes were so amazing with the most intricate detail, I must've given her information to everyone at the party that asked about her. The cake and cupcakes were so yummy, and we even enjoyed the cupcakes a few days after the party. Thank you Sierra for making such show stopping pieces for my daughters birthday. She is also so reasonably priced compared to competition and responds quickly. Try her, you will not be disappointed!
The cookies and cream and strawberry cakes were delicious. Strawberry was my personal favorite and had actual strawberries in it. The cake was moist and fresh. The decor was beautifully made to our specification. She worked with us on designing something Dungeons and Dragons themed and integrated several designs into two layers and allowed the perfect amount of room for a topper I wanted, including dowels so the heavy 1.5 lb topper would be supported. She expertly printed the font I wanted for initials and ampersand, made a nice castle with greenery and dice-shaped windows, dragon scales, and a mini dragon tail wrapped between the layers. It was beautiful and delicious, and everyone loved it.
Sierra did an amazing job on the cake for my sons 11th birthday! He wanted a baseball themed cake and it came out exactly how he envisioned it, if not, better! Not only did it look great, it tasted even better! That is so hard to find these days. I feel like if the cake looks nice it tastes bad or vice versa. Not in this case! We ordered the very strawberry and white chocolate and raspberry flavors. They were both amazing. I had to change the delivery address last minute and Sierra was very flexible, it wasn't an issue at all! She delivered the cake efficiently (which is a HUGE help when you are hosting a party) The cake ordering process was impressive. From the very first email, to the very last piece of cake, Sierra was remarkable. I will definitely be ordering from her again!
I looked online for a local cake shop, for an anniversary I was going to celebrate. I then came across Cake by Sierra. It was very easy to fill out an invoice on the website, and they get back to you right away. Very good customer service as they make sure they have all the details on the cake you want, and how it is going to look. Very easy to pick up, and it's perfectly wrapped as well. Would definitely recommend, and will be going here in the future
Wow, just wow! I am so impressed by Sierra and her service! It was easy to order online, apply our customized cake, and she was quick to respond to my questions. The cake was delicious! The buttercream was to die for, cake was moist, and mousse was delicious! I will definitely be ordering from Sierra in the future. Thank you for making a beautiful and delicious cake Sierra, our guests couldn't stop raving about it!
If the review was purely on looks and customer service I would give 5 stars. If it was on taste and quality of cake sadly I would give less... so overall I'll give it a 4. At first the cake was dense after sitting out for an hour and the custard or filling was not spread evenly so when we took a slice it fell apart. The filling was more towards the center. I allowed the cake to sit out for another hour( 2 hours total) and tried the cake again and it was dry at that point. It is very disappointing because the cake was beautiful. I received so many compliments on Instagram on the cake and was asked where I got it so I referred everyone here in hopes that maybe mine was a dud. I would give her another chance because her work is truly great just the cake itself was a let down. I had a little more than half the cake left over but threw it away even thought we spent a pretty penny on it. I think the cake had good flavor but was distracted with the dryness of it...To end on a positive note Sierra seemed very nice and responded to emails in a timely manner. The cake looked exactly as I wanted it and I was very please with her talent in decorating the cake. Another positive is my 3 year loved the look of the cake as well.
3 months ago
Absolutely looooved the cake! I ordered a customized cake for my son's 5th birthday of dragon ball z, sierra did the most amazing job! The dragon ball's were cake pops and everything including image of Goku was editable. We chose cookies and cream flavor and it was absolutely delicious! Everyone at the party complimented it and kept asking where I got it from because it was so good! 10/10 recommend and will be definitely ordering again! read more
2 months ago
I got a red velvet heart cake, designed exactly like the reference photo I sent and how my mom wanted it! She made the cake quickly in the time frame I needed which was amazing because I was running out of time. Cake was beautiful and the buttercream for the design she used had an amazing taste, not too sweet which I love in my opinion. The red velvet was also perfect. Everything from emailing, accepting, paying and picking up the cake was extremely easy and effortless. Thank you!! read more
7 months ago
Cakes by Sierra is by far the best!! We ordered a custom cake from them to celebrate my company's 10 year anniversary and she knocked it out of the park! We got so many compliments on the cake and you can tell she took her time with making it exactly what we were envisioning. Thank you! read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much again Ginah! I appreciate your message and so glad…
8 months ago
Sierra has made my girls birthday cakes the past 2 years. Sierra is super easy to provide ideas to and she runs with it and everything turns out beautifully. All our guests are amazed by how the cakes look and even MORE impressed by how delicious it tastes. I've had a number of guests say it's the best birthday cake they've had!! We know other bakers personally, but I keep choosing Sierra because her results cannot be beat and prices seem very reasonable for what you get. read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much Marissa! You have been so great to work with and…
7 months ago
Sierra knocked it out of the park with a cake for my spouse's birthday. They love Lego so I was looking for an "elevated look" with Lego theme, but didn't want too much fondant. Within minutes of submitting the online form and providing inspiration photos Sierra confirmed the design and everything was set. Delivery to our house the morning of was even better! We all loved the cake - it tasted great & was the perfect surprise! read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much Elle! :)
1 year ago
I contacted Sierra for the first time for a hot wheels cake for my sons 4th birthday. Sierra was great sending me a quote and adjusting small details in order to make sure the details in the quote would reflect the cake I wanted made. Communication through email was pretty responsive, not immediate but she would eventually reply. Pricing for the cake itself and for delivery was very reasonable! She arrived on time with the cake and saved me a LOT of stress. Cake itself was good. I've posted pictures of the inspiration cake and the cake she made. We got lots of compliments on it and the taste was actually pretty good too. It was not too sweet and by far the best tasting of all fondant cakes I've ordered in the past from other vendors. The one thing I was upset about were the orange race tacks on the bottom half of the cake. While everything else was done quite beautifully, the tracks were not very neat. I notice details a lot so of course it bothered me more than it should've. The cake overall looked great and no one seemed to notice the tracks. I just wish she would've made sure that she could've pulled those off before making the cake. But again, small detail and not a deal breaker. Overall it was a great experience and I'd most likely order again with her. Thanks Sierra! read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Hi Melissa, thank you for taking the time to leave a review! I’m so…
10 months ago
Got my sons 1st birthday cake from sierra and was more than happy with the results!!! The cake and flavor came out beautifully. Got the birthday sprinkle filling read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you Ivanna! I’m so glad you enjoyed it :)
3 years ago
Not only the cake looked amazing, it tasted so good!!! Communication was perfect all the way, delivery right on the time scheduled, exceptional service. Highly recommended! read more
2 years ago
Super friendly, amazing cupcakes! Highly recommend Sierra she is so sweet and has a knack for making tasty treats. We asked her a week in advance to make cupcakes for our sons first birthday, and we were very pleased by her service, her friendliness and the quality of the cupcake. She returns calls in a timely manner highly recommend. read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much Jennifer! Glad you enjoyed them :)
1 year ago
I sent my inspo photo for my baby shower and sierra make the cake exactly like the photo I sent! It was beautiful and tasted great! Thank you!! read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Yay! So glad you loved it! Thanks again! :)
3 years ago
Sierra is such an amazing and talented baker who surprised us with the most creative cake and cupcakes for my daughter's 5th Barbie birthday. The cakes were so amazing with the most intricate detail, I must've given her information to everyone at the party that asked about her. The cake and cupcakes were so yummy, and we even enjoyed the cupcakes a few days after the party. Thank you Sierra for making such show stopping pieces for my daughters birthday. She is also so reasonably priced compared to competition and responds quickly. Try her, you will not be disappointed! read more
3 years ago
The cookies and cream and strawberry cakes were delicious. Strawberry was my personal favorite and had actual strawberries in it. The cake was moist and fresh. The decor was beautifully made to our specification. She worked with us on designing something Dungeons and Dragons themed and integrated several designs into two layers and allowed the perfect amount of room for a topper I wanted, including dowels so the heavy 1.5 lb topper would be supported. She expertly printed the font I wanted for initials and ampersand, made a nice castle with greenery and dice-shaped windows, dragon scales, and a mini dragon tail wrapped between the layers. It was beautiful and delicious, and everyone loved it. read more
3 years ago
Sierra did an amazing job on the cake for my sons 11th birthday! He wanted a baseball themed cake and it came out exactly how he envisioned it, if not, better! Not only did it look great, it tasted even better! That is so hard to find these days. I feel like if the cake looks nice it tastes bad or vice versa. Not in this case! We ordered the very strawberry and white chocolate and raspberry flavors. They were both amazing. I had to change the delivery address last minute and Sierra was very flexible, it wasn't an issue at all! She delivered the cake efficiently (which is a HUGE help when you are hosting a party) The cake ordering process was impressive. From the very first email, to the very last piece of cake, Sierra was remarkable. I will definitely be ordering from her again! read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much Andrew! So happy you enjoyed it :)
2 years ago
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Thank you so much Jessica! :)
2 years ago
I looked online for a local cake shop, for an anniversary I was going to celebrate. I then came across Cake by Sierra. It was very easy to fill out an invoice on the website, and they get back to you right away. Very good customer service as they make sure they have all the details on the cake you want, and how it is going to look. Very easy to pick up, and it's perfectly wrapped as well. Would definitely recommend, and will be going here in the future read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
I appreciate you Brock! So glad you enjoyed it :)
3 years ago
Wow, just wow! I am so impressed by Sierra and her service! It was easy to order online, apply our customized cake, and she was quick to respond to my questions. The cake was delicious! The buttercream was to die for, cake was moist, and mousse was delicious! I will definitely be ordering from Sierra in the future. Thank you for making a beautiful and delicious cake Sierra, our guests couldn't stop raving about it! read more
1 year ago
If the review was purely on looks and customer service I would give 5 stars. If it was on taste and quality of cake sadly I would give less... so overall I'll give it a 4. At first the cake was dense after sitting out for an hour and the custard or filling was not spread evenly so when we took a slice it fell apart. The filling was more towards the center. I allowed the cake to sit out for another hour( 2 hours total) and tried the cake again and it was dry at that point. It is very disappointing because the cake was beautiful. I received so many compliments on Instagram on the cake and was asked where I got it so I referred everyone here in hopes that maybe mine was a dud. I would give her another chance because her work is truly great just the cake itself was a let down. I had a little more than half the cake left over but threw it away even thought we spent a pretty penny on it. I think the cake had good flavor but was distracted with the dryness of it...To end on a positive note Sierra seemed very nice and responded to emails in a timely manner. The cake looked exactly as I wanted it and I was very please with her talent in decorating the cake. Another positive is my 3 year loved the look of the cake as well. read more
Business owner information
Sierra J.
Hi Shelby! I really appreciate your honest and constructive review.…
3 years ago
4 years ago
Sierra did our twins "2 Legit 2 Quit" birthday cake and nailed it! She incorporated all of my ideas, created a sketch and executed it to perfection! But not only was it stunning to look at, the cake was moist and incredibly delicious! I had to taste it for myself when all the guests were raving over it! Trust Sierra to do your cake and you will not be disappointed!!! read more
3 years ago
I found cake by sierra by doing a google search and I am so glad I did! I wanted a special Spiderman cake for my sons birthday and she created exactly what I envisioned. Her talent is on a other level! The best part is the cake tasted amazing too! Also, her prices are totally reasonable. Thank you for making my sons birthday so memorable. read more
4 years ago
Sierra did an amazing job! The cake was delicious and the pickup was super convenient. She was very responsive to emails and any details. I bought flowers and she arranged them on the cake. The cake was for a baby shower and the mom-to-be loved it so much. Would highly recommend! read more
4 years ago
Where do I start ?! Had the pleasure of getting a cake made from this wonderful lady this week ... my brothers birthday was Thursday 2/24 I reached out to Sierra Tuesday night and she got it done literally right on time .... Customer service was amazing , location was easy to find and the red velvet cake was 100/109 highly recommend!!! Thanks again . read more
2 years ago
I am SOOOO happy I found Sierra! She is amazing. My son wanted a Bowser SHELL cake and she more than delivered. Prices are super reasonable and she will deliver for a small fee! All around wonderful experience and my little guy was super happy. Highly recommend. read more
3 years ago
Sierra made my daughter's Minecraft Themed Birthday Cake. It was the first time I have used her services and she definitely didn't disappoint. Her price seemed reasonable to me and still top notch quality. From the beginning when I contacted her about what I was looking for, to the end where she delivered it to the party venue. It was top class. Will definitely recommend her to others and will use her for my daughter's birthday cakes again. The inside of the cake was tasty and fluffy and not overly sweet which is what I wanted. Even the icing/ frosting wasn't super sweet and everything on the design was edible. Daughter chose Red Velvet for the cake. Definitely use Sierra for your cake needs. read more
3 years ago
This review is way overdue. We had Sierra make our daughter's quinceañera cake and we absolutely loved every aspect of working with her to make my daughter's dream cake come true. From the cake tasting and consultation to the delivery and setup everything was perfect. And better yet the cake tasted amazing, it was so good we had a layer made specifically for us to take home and enjoy. A few months later, on super short notice, Sierra was then able to make a small cake last minute for us and it tasted even better than we remembered! read more
3 years ago
I don't usually do reviews. BUT SHE IS AMAZING! it was a great experience all the way around. Her customer service is great! I had to reschedule my daughter's party because of weather & she was beyond understanding & accommodating. I planned my daughters party around this cake I had seen. Wasn't sure if I would find someone to duplicate it. BUT I DID! My daughters cake & cupcakes were beautiful! And once we tasted everything, I realized I now have my go to cake person! The cake and cupcakes were delicious! If you need a custom cake Sierra is your person! Thank you for helping me make memories for my daughter read more
3 years ago
Sierra made the most beautiful and delicious cake for my daughters birthday! Definitely will be coming back for all my custom cakes! read more
3 years ago
My husband likes his cake and the taste is perfect Sierra is also friendly and accommodating. I will definitely recommend her to others read more
4 years ago
I ordered a box of mini cakes for Valentine's Day, and I was so happy with Cake by Sierra's goodies! The cakes were beautiful, and tasted delicious as well!! Sierra was very accommodating for scheduling a time to pick up the order during a busy weekend, and responded to my messages promptly. Would highly recommend this small business, and will be going back with my special occasion cake needs! read more
4 years ago
4 years ago
She did so good with our cake and cupcakes. The cake was perfect! Not too sweet, just enough to enjoy the taste of red velvet and the cream. She made me vision into reality, which I thought was really hard... but she did it like it was a piece of cake, pun intended! read more
3 years ago
More info about Cake by Sierra
1423 Cuyamaca St
El Cajon, CA 92020
Directions
(858) 381-4208
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.cakebysierra.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Cake by Sierra
Review Highlights - Cake by Sierra
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
3 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
3 years ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
Cake by Sierra - customcakes - Updated May 2026
Best of El Cajon
People found Cake by Sierra by searching for…
Bakeries in El Cajon, California
Cupcakes in El Cajon, California
Birthday Cake in El Cajon, California
Cake Bakeries in El Cajon, California
Swedish Princess Cake in El Cajon, California
Dubai Chocolate in El Cajon, California
Last Minute Birthday Cakes in El Cajon, California
Red Velvet Cake in El Cajon, California
Custom Cookies in El Cajon, California
Edible Photo Cakes in El Cajon, California
Gluten Free Bakery in El Cajon, California
Custom Cupcakes in El Cajon, California
Baby Shower Cake in El Cajon, California
Cookie Delivery in El Cajon, California
Tres Leches Cake in El Cajon, California
Number Cake in El Cajon, California
Mini Desserts in El Cajon, California
Minecraft in El Cajon, California
Wholesale Bakery in El Cajon, California
Cookies in El Cajon, California
Panaderia Bakery in El Cajon, California
Trending Searches in El Cajon, CA
Bakeries That Deliver near Cake by Sierra
Brunch Reservations near Cake by Sierra
Chocolate Chip Cookies near Cake by Sierra
Cinnamon Roll near Cake by Sierra
Custom Cakes near Cake by Sierra
Custom Cookies near Cake by Sierra
Farmers Market near Cake by Sierra
Gluten Free Bakery near Cake by Sierra
Graduation Dinner near Cake by Sierra
Hip New Restaurants near Cake by Sierra
Ice Cream Truck near Cake by Sierra
Japanese Bakery near Cake by Sierra
Mango Sticky Rice near Cake by Sierra
New Mexican Cuisine near Cake by Sierra
Steamed Crabs near Cake by Sierra
Browse Articles
Browse Nearby
BEST of El Cajon, California Coffee near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Desserts near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Restaurants near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Things to Do near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Bakeries near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Parking near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Ice Cream near Cake by Sierra
BEST of El Cajon, California Cupcakes near Cake by Sierra
Browse Brands
Related Searches in El Cajon, CA
Affordable Wedding Cakes Available in El Cajon, California
Bakeries That Deliver in El Cajon, California
Bakery Birthday Cake Delivery in El Cajon, California
Best Chinese Bakery Options in El Cajon, California
Best German Chocolate Cake Bakeries in El Cajon, California
Best Mini Cakes Available in El Cajon, California
Best Panaderia Bakery Treats in El Cajon, California
Browse Popular Pastry Shops Around El Cajon, California
Delicious Carrot Cake Bakeries Near El Cajon, California
Delicious Cookie Cake Options Available in El Cajon, California
Delicious Croissant Options in El Cajon, California
Delicious Egg Tart Treats in El Cajon, California
Delicious Fondant Cakes Available in El Cajon, California
Discover Vegan Desserts Near El Cajon, California
Discover the Best Macarons Available in El Cajon, California
Discover the Best Patisserie in El Cajon, California
Enjoy Pastries and Coffee Near You in El Cajon, California
Explore the Best Sugar Free Cakes Available in El Cajon, California
Fast Cupcake Delivery Services in El Cajon, California
Find Custom Birthday Cakes Made Fresh in El Cajon, California
Find Delicious Chocolate Cake in El Cajon, California
Find Top Birthday Cake Bakeries in El Cajon, California
Find the Best Coconut Cake in El Cajon, California
Find the Best Macaroons in El Cajon, California Today
Fresh Chocolate Covered Strawberries in El Cajon, California
Get the Best Baby Shower Cake in El Cajon, California
Order Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies in El Cajon, California
Order Custom Photo Cake Designs in El Cajon, California
Order Custom Wedding Cakes in El Cajon, California
Order Delicious Custom Cupcakes in El Cajon, California
Order Delicious Gluten Free Cake in El Cajon, California
Order Delicious Ice Cream Cake Near El Cajon, California
Order Delicious Red Velvet Cake in El Cajon, California
Order Fresh Strawberry Cake in El Cajon, California Today
Order Fresh Vegan Cake Treats in El Cajon, California
Order Gender Reveal Cakes in El Cajon, California
Order Kids Birthday Cakes Made Fresh in El Cajon, California
Order a Smash Cake in El Cajon, California Now
Reliable Cake Delivery Services in El Cajon, California
Savor Delicious Apple Pie in El Cajon, California
Shop at the Best Asian Bakery in El Cajon, California
Taste Fresh Treats at a German Bakery in El Cajon, California
Taste the Best Brownies Available in El Cajon, California
Top Chocolate Chip Cookies Near El Cajon, California
Top Spots for Fresh Scones in El Cajon, California
Top Sugar Free Bakeries to Try in El Cajon, California
Try Delicious Cream Puff Desserts in El Cajon, California
Try Tasty Fruit Tart in El Cajon, California
People who viewed Cake by Sierra also viewed
Veronica's Goodies
45 reviews
$$
The Elegant Cake
6 reviews
Angela's Eccentric Kitchen
244 reviews
$$
The Cupcake Store
316 reviews
$$
Molly's Bakes
3 reviews
Crumbl - Santee
233 reviews
$$
Rodriguez Paletas
6 reviews
Dilly’s Ice Cream Truck
29 reviews
Silver Whisk Delizia
3 reviews
Lyndsay’s Cakery
39 reviews
University Heights