A Culinary Highlight in Mayagüez…read more While visiting family from the mainland U.S., we decided to look for an authentic local dining experience and discovered Don Quijote. It's a simple, unassuming spot, but the food rivals any high-end restaurant. We ordered the grouper, which was exceptionally fresh and flavorful, accompanied by perfectly seasoned vegetables and a high-quality green salad. The wine pours were generous and very reasonably priced. Beyond the food, the service was superb; the staff was incredibly welcoming and attentive. This is a five-star experience. It will definitely be a destination for us every time we return to Mayagüez.

I was curious about this place when I noticed it was a pizzeria. Unfortunately, the pedazo of…read morecheese pizza I had was not good at all. Nonetheless, I appreciate the attempt that this restaurant tried at pizza. Now the food besides the pizza was excellent. The habichuelas are phenomenal and they even make a mofongo with yuca which was excellent. The broth that comes with the mofongo is excellent and I would come here again to eat everything besides the pizza. Also the pistacho flan was an good and interesting dessert.

We enjoyed our pizzas and calzones. Great value. Huge calzones.- can feed 3 people , I think . The…read morecashiers were very friendly and helpful.

Good pizza, had the combo. Didn't try any other food. We were the only gringos in the place.read more

Service, I give them a 5. Food, I give them a 5. Tate of food, I give them a ten!!!! Absolutely…read moredelicious!!! Stop by and give it a try yourself. You will not be disappointed. Absolutely delicious! Ambiance, cute, romantic, family dinning..

Si quieres comer comida súper italiana lo Recomiendo. La…read moremasa del a pizza es exquisita. El Servicio es fenomenal. Súper delicioso!

Great local Rincon spot for pizza! Next door to Oktoberfest - can be difficult to spot at first…read more Very nice inside and super friendly staff! They have excellent combo deals on pizza. We got an extra large pizza with garlic twists and a 2 liter of soda for only $11! Annnd the pizza is delicious. Definitely come here if you're in the mood for pizza :)

Came here the first day in Puerto Rico looking for something open for breakfast. This place has…read morethe most amazing sandwiches...try the Cubano or Peril. Been here twice since and going to try the pizza. All hand thrown dough. This place is right next to Oktoberfest....the true name of the business is Aaliyas.

Stopped at Pepperoni for dinner. The service was excellent. They spoke good English and Spanish…read more Explained the menu, made recommendations. Had 2 sample of wine and decided on a bottle. The price was reasonable $25 for pizza, $25 for wine and $10 for an appetizer. + they are open late. We come around 9 and left at 10:30pm and they were still open. We sat on the patio under lights and enjoyed a beautiful dinner together in San Sebastián.

Delicious. Exceeded expectations. Had to order another pizza immediately. Will return .read more

I have to be honest and say I was a little scared to come. Last time I had their food was about 15…read moreyrs ago and was afraid the nostalgia would make me idealize it. I had been coming to this place since I can remember and have great childhood memories here. Now let's talk about the visit: started with their small sampler. Veeeery generous portions. The sorullitos were the best I've had in a while. Their mofongo was still on point with the vegetable broth and carne frita. My only comment about it is that the broth had more tomato than I remember but it was still good. Service was great as wait times for food were reasonable. Place was not packed for a Saturday night. One thing I would not recommend of what I ordered, is their Sangria. Not good at all, but the food very tasty, fresh and warm.

Great local restaurant with excellent pizza and much more. As plates passed by from other tables,…read morewe immediately regretted not ordering the mofongo with one of the many options available. My wife's veggie pizza was excellent, and she was more than pleased with it. Unfortunately, my experience was quite different. The kitchen apparently skipped my pizza, and after waiting for some time, they seemed to rush it by taking those toppings and placing them on another pizza that was already being prepared for someone else. It was obvious because the extra toppings were not properly cooked--they were neither crispy nor fully cooked. It was disappointing to see the quality sacrificed because of a lack of organization. There's no doubt in my mind that if my pizza had been prepared properly from the start, following the correct cooking process, it would have been a phenomenal pizza.

Pizza dough is fantastic, much bigger than I anticipated and lots of cheese. Worth the wait and…read moreaffordable.

It was fine. It always an absolute zoo and difficult to enjoy. 45 mins to an hour for 3 slices of…read morepizza.

Pedazos is the best in the West Coast! Our current favorite is the Barbacoa but there's plenty to…read morechoose from. Best deep dish pizza in Rincon hands down.