It's been awhile since I've been to a Brewster's and my first time in Newnan GA. I was expecting the half price banana split if you brought your own banana which I did. I was informed that the half price banana split was stopped during Covid. That's a reasonable precaution for Covid. My question to Brewster's is if Covid still an issue? I ordered a full price banana split whick was very good though pricy. read more

The butter pecan ice cream!!!!! OHHHH MY LORDYY! Went here after taking my cousins bowling, it's not your normal ice cream atmosphere. It gives a nostalgic feel, i love the walk up window and the fact that you can see all of the ice cream tubs. The two employees there seemed young, they were closing up for the night but still super helpful. I loved the flavor of the waffle cone! i know they make them from scratch, it had a subtle sweetness that complemented the butter pecan SO well! The flavor of that butter pecan was melt in your mouth goodness! I am absolutely floored from the deliciousness! Finally doing my review because I had to settle on some talenti tonight, wishing I had some bruster's LOL. read more

I visited this place 3-4 times in my entire lifetime. Prices were very high and the ice cream was horrible. Service was ok. Has no ambiance whatsoever. Don't waste your time. read more

They didn't even serve us when we got there they shut the window in our faces and told us to go away. We got there at 10:15 because google maps said they closed at 11 and they refused to serve us. read more

I got my first taste of Bruster's a couple weeks ago. I got mint chocolate chip and pistachio. It was delish! It reminds me of Friendly's back home (CT). read more

This might be a very unpopular review of a community icon but this was my first visit. Bruster's ice cream shop in Newnan on hwy 34 was where me and my two granddaughters ended up after a spaghetti dinner in Woodstock. It was dark and there were spotlights lighting up the area - no indoor seating. ( I think that goes for all of this Chains stores.) we ordered 1 rocky road hot fudge sundae, 1 vanilla shake and 1 scoop of another flavor ice cream. Total was close to $17! It wasn't worth it. Better ice cream can be had at Krogers for a lot less and you'll have "leftovers." Why people buy this is beyond my understanding. Was it bad? NO, but was it great! NO. It just wasn't worth it. Did the young lady behind the counter do her job, yes. But was it friendly and helpful, NO. It continues to amaze me what people will settle for given the fact that there's really no competition out there for stand-alone stores selling a particular item. Ice cream should be fun, this wasn't. read more

We went to this location for the first time. It was ok. Only things I'd say were different than usual were the tip jars asking for cash tips for their college kids working, and there were no napkins available unless you troubled them for some. I understand saving the expense of napkins, but it's crazy to have to ask for something to clean up your mess. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Promos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

See all

First time at Brusters, but it is delicious! Got sea salt caramel cheesecake in a waffle cone and there's actual chunks and REAL swirls of caramel. And they have huge portions! Definitely a sharing experience. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Sea salt caramel cheesecake in waffle cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

My wife and I went for an ice cream fix yesterday afternoon. We were disappointed to find the outside location closed but managed to find our way into the bowling alley. There we found slow service without a smile from staff that seemed to be just going through the motions. Our ice cream was very soft, almost like soft serve in a bowl. As we drove away, my wife said," that was a bummer". I agree completely. Not sure if we will go back. read more

Ice cream is delicious but the staff has some rude teenagers. Not all bad though some of them were nice. The girl that handed out the ice cream kept yelling out the orders rudely like 3 times even when we were standing right there to grab it. The outdoor tables need a good cleaning too but i thought all of this was worth it because the ice cream is delicious. i got coffee and cake batter in a sugar cone. read more

Very expensive, it took 20+ min to get two root beer floats one cone of ice cream. I asked for sprinkles and put one spoon full over the top. It cost $20.00 for three items. Staff seemed annoyed to have to take my order. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newnan, Georgia

They are friendly and polite. However, was surprised that they didn't have sugar free options to choose from. Other than that the visit was good. read more

Love this place, it's real ice cream that stands up to toppings like hot fudge. It has flavor and texture, not just sweet. My favorite is key lime pie, I get it every time. read more

The ice cream was so freaking delicious but the portions were huge. We'll be back to try some new flavors but we'll be sure to order a baby or a small cone. read more

Every Sunday night my family comes here and have never had a problem. Tonight we came for my sisters birthday and our server was Briana. She was rude and argumentative when she got our order wrong. We were ordering basically the same thing we always do, a small waffle cone with two different ice creams. Briana would not listen and put one flavor in the cone my sister ordered but she didn't realize it until we got to the car. I ordered mine next and again she didn't listen to me and brought the wrong thing. I handed it back and told her that wasn't what I ordered. She threw it in the trash and again I told her what I wanted. Finally, my daughter and I were telling her the correct order and she said I wanted one thing and my daughter wanted something else, both the wrong flavor. Both my daughter and I said no. After paying, I asked her name and told her she was very rude and she proceeded to argue with me and I asked her to let me finish. I said we've never had a problem before. She also was very slow and had a smart, sarcastic attitude. Not a good experience and we heard others complaining as well. I didn't even finish my ice cream because I was so aggravated with this girl. We can go somewhere else and spend $20 every Sunday night for a lot better service. (I also usually tip, but not this time.) We will have to think seriously before coming back. read more

The ice cream is great, like all Brusters, no complaints there. With so many choices in Newnan now (Cold Stone, numerous FroYo places, DQ, etc) it's nothing special that you can't get anywhere else. The food is so-so at best. They have Nathans hot dogs, which are decent, but the fries are TERRIBLE. You do get a lot of them, which is typically a good thing, but not in this case. I don't quite know how to explain it - they're big and thick, but have no flavor and are kind of mealy. My wife got some mini corn dogs and said they were so-so. The kids working there seemed disorganized. The first one took our food order on a napkin and had to ask many times exactly what it was we wanted. Then the kid that took our ice cream order didn't write anything down, forgot what we wanted, and had to come back to get the order straight. It really seemed like it was kind of unorganized in there, which is more a reflection of the management than it is the kids working there. read more

Wow when did Brusters get so stingy with the portions? I got a waffle bowl and it barely had any ice cream. I complained to the help and they gave me some bs excuse It will be awhile before I go back read more

I love this place staff are patient and nice. Food is ok but the ice cream is the main reason I go there. No indoor seating which is unfortunate for a rainy day. Speedy service usually staff is good about giving good advice on what to get. read more

Like the ice cream extremely expensive for no reason. I would bring the kids here but it always smells like weed inside. I don't want my children around high teenagers. read more

I used to love going here, never had any issues before, but today, well that's a whole different story. We stood at the window for a good while before any one of the employees came to serve us, then when we're placing the order which was for two freezes, one mango, the other one lime and then a mnm blast. We got the freezes and one of them was a watered down orange freeze and the other is a really watery PEACH MILKSHAKE, that was supposed to be a lime freeze??? So went to go tell her about the mistake and try to get them remade and I just give up on the lime freeze at this point so we get the freeze back and it's still an orange freeze but at this point it's whatever. I try to pay for the one freeze and the mnm blast, and she tries to charge me two freezes and the blast. After I tell her it's just one freeze bc I didn't want the lime one anymore cause I'd given up on that mess, the lady ringing me up proceeded to get an attitude with me bc I told her it was just one freeze and the mnm blast since I didn't get the other freeze since it was messed up so severely. Just very disappointed in the service today. read more

Bruster's is now closed. Their last day open was Sunday, August 3rd, 2014. The Bruster's inside Junction Lanes will remain open. I had to rate it, so I rated it four stars for their ice cream.. If I had to rate the previous management, I'd rate it one star. read more