As others have said, I also had a transmission repair issue with this shop. Brotz replaced my old transmission lines and topped of my fluid after a leak was discovered. Fast forward about a month, I'm encountering the same transmission issue, right in the middle of the holidays. I had to wait about a week to get into any local shop, so I picked the first one that answered their phone (I need my car for my job). After the second shop had some time to look under the hood, they informed me that my new transmission lines had not been installed properly - rather than attach them with the proper tool, Brotz had cut off the ends of the old transmission lines, cut off the connector-ends of the new transmission lines, then hose-clamped the two together. This "repair" resulted in all of my new transmission fluid leaking out, potentially damaging my car further. Due to my need to my car to be repaired ASAP, I asked the second shop to pull the trigger on the repair after seeing the damage that Brotz had done.
After my repair was done properly, I went back to Brotz to request a refund on the transmission lines and fluid, as the shop would have needed to pay for these again, even if they were the ones fixing the mistake they had made in the first place. The shop owner tells me that he doesn't have the money and that I'll have to take him to court - I told him that I understand that times are tough and I'd like to avoid court, to just work something out to save us both some time. He loosely agreed to this and I told him I would be back to talk after a little while.
Two weeks later, I go back to the shop and the conversation goes about the same as before, only the shop owner also rants about firing all of his staff and suing another local garage, which was kind of confusing. As it turns out, my spouse verified with another local shop that they had been re-doing repairs on cars that had been to Brotz. Apparently, several other folks were in the same boat I was.
Finally, I go back to Brotz after another week has passed to talk to the shop owner again. When I spoke to him, he told me that because I didn't come to him first for repair, he wasn't liable for the parts his shop butchered before putting them into my car. I replied saying that I was there to work something out, to which he said "I don't want to work things out, you can go to Hell and get out of my shop."
Save your money, your time, and your vehicle - go support a different local garage. read more