Never fails to please. Real New York style 'slices' and pies with many other authentic New York pizza places offerings. Not fancy, not pretentious, just your typical New York pizzeria in the heart of gulfport. pizza always hot and fresh. all other foods also made to order. Drinks kept filled. Personnel are affable with a real typical New York vibe. Prices are locally oriented, not New York competitive (lol - I.e. very reasonable). read more

So I go to a pizza place and order lasagna. Maybe my bad. The place is long and narrow. I am not sure how clean, but all the napkin holders were dirty and dusty. No meat lasagna, so I had the spinach version. The 5" round aluminum tin might have had 1 spinach leaf torn throughout. The sauce was ok. Not a great atmosphere. Shopping center parking. Been there, done that. No reason to go back. read more

See all

Brooklyn Pizzeria has been a mainstay of the Mississippi Gulf Coast for as long as I can remember, going back to the days when everyone went to Hardy Court Cinema then walked a few doors down to get pizza. They are the kind of place that has been doing it right for decades. Brooklyn makes New York style pizza, meaning the crust is thin and the pizzas are quite large and flat. Think John Travolta folding a large piece to eat while walking down the street. They also do oven-baked sandwiches, garlic knots, salads, and more. What I love about their pizza is how well they have perfected the process. Their crust is thin but not crunchy, and has just the right amount of chew that make it more filling. Their sauce is the perfect balance between sweet and savory, which I enjoyed. They don't pile up a lot of cheese or toppings so that it cooks evenly and makes for a much more portable and easier to eat pizza. One thing I noticed this last visit was I could pick up a slice from the pan, just a couple minutes after it came from the oven, and none of the toppings slid off - even while holding it vertical for a couple of seconds to transfer to my plate. Try that at other places and you'll likely end up with a mess. The inside of this place still looks like 1980-something with old NY-inspired artwork, simple booth seats, and metal chairs. It is NOT fancy at all, which might turn some people away. It kind of reminds me of some place you might see a movie cop stop by the get some pizza while walking the beat in NYC. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Canadian Bacon pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

New York style! Great crust and sauce. Only ding is wish they used fresh mushrooms. Called in order for pickup. Popular place! read more

See all

Oh, my-my-my! Never thought we would find a real pizza place with normal prices. Everything was just what one would expect from an authentic pizza parlor. Highly recommend! read more

The BEST pizza on the gulf coast! The staff is friendly and the pizza is amazing. The place is always clean.

I've been here twice, and my second visit was so disappointing that I doubt I'll be back. The first time, I had pizza--it was fine, nothing to rave about, but decent enough to make me return. On my second visit, I ordered a calzone. When I placed the order, the cashier asked if I wanted a side of marinara sauce. I declined, thinking it was odd to need extra sauce since I assumed the calzone would already have marinara inside, like every other calzone I've ever had. When it came out, it looked fine from the outside, but as I started eating, I quickly noticed how dry it was. Bite after bite, it was just melted cheese and slices of lunch meat. I even kept thinking, "Maybe all the sauce just shifted to one end during baking," so I worked my way through it expecting to eventually hit that pocket of marinara. But nope--there wasn't a drop anywhere. Just dry bread, cheese, and meat the whole way through. By the end, it felt like more of a chore to eat than something enjoyable. If the standard here is to serve calzones without sauce inside, that should really be made clear. It was a frustrating and flavorless experience. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - A calzone that for some reason is made from a recipe that doesn't include any marinara sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

I'm from the 805 out in Cali, and every time I go back I always hit up my favorite pizza place. I do have to say, that Brooklyn's is not the same, however it's just as great as Toppers, but here on the coast!! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

See all

The pizza is true Brooklyn style pizza , it's delicious ! Seems to be a Gulfport institution! We have a second home near it and nothing is as good as yummy pizza hot from the oven! read more

The people here are super nice!! If you don't go when there's 50+people in the restaurant your food will be out within 10 mins. If it's like 4pm, call and order 30 mins ahead ! If you don't you'll be waiting a while. Salads are whatever but it's a pizza place so that's to be expected. My friends drink had like particles ? In it? Probably from the straw paper or paper towels. I told them it would make them grow big and strong and to drink it anyways. read more

First, the pizza was great. It was just a basic mushroom and onion, and it was great. However, the main guy there was just as rude as a real New Yorker. If you want authentic pizza, you get the Brooklyn attitude. I told him I was born in Brooklyn and was anxious to try the pizza. Crickets. OK, I get that. He's tired. I was wearing my favorite NFL team's hat and T-shirt, and I saw on the TV that we had just scored. Happily, I said, we've already scored? He said, "Who's we? There's no we here." I pointed to my clothes and the screen, and he didn't give a whatever. OK, fine, you suck at customer service. I came in for pizza, not to make friends, even though I just moved pretty close to the place. I had also ordered an eggplant parmigiana. I wish I knew what it tasted like, because they made a chicken one. Found that out once I got home. And the sauce had zero effort. Or close to it. A lot of tomato paste still needed to be diluted - it was too pasty - you could scoop it off the chicken. Tomato paste, in and of itself, can be bitter and very acidic. Got through a few bites and no more. My view of the place, let me put it in Brooklyn terms. "Forgeddabout id." read more

Of there were 10 stars I would choose it! The pizza is hands down the best on the coast! It's a true New York pizza. They serve by the slice as well. The line is typically long in the evenings and around lunch time! WORTH THE WAIT! It has enough seating to accommodate a good bit of people. It's nothing fancy. You're there for the pizza. So fah gettaboutit Go. Get. This. Pizza I'm sure everything is good! But I'm there for the pepperoni pizza!! Cheers! read more

I am a bit biased and bit of nostalgia for me. I have not been here in years. Especially the other location in Bay St. Louis. I only been there twice at that location. This particular location is in the hardy court shopping center in Gulfport off Courthouse. It is a very casual atmosphere. Great place for New York style pizza. It is a thin crust style. I have not been there in years and no expert on it, but to me it tasted and like what I use to get when I lived in New York City. They offer other food options. But really you are there for the pizza. I'm not a beer drinker but a great place if you want beer and pizza combo. You may think to yourself, "why would I want to get a pizza there and not somewhere else?" For starters, you can get a slice and not order a whole pizza if you just don't want a lot of food. I love this place! Not only they local and taste good! They don't hold back on the toppings. Carful when you order. If you order a lot of toppings, it can get heavy. Depends on what toppings you get. So worth it, from one slice to a whole pie. If you prefer add extras to your stuff. They offer the usual salt and pepper at the table. If you want more, they have red pepper flakes, Parmesan or Romano cheese, catalina and ranch dressing. If you are not too full. They have a few dessert fare. The seating is mainly booth style seating and one large table in the back for a large group. No padding in the booth and little bit at table seating. Little padding on the chairs/table. They offer a few arcade games and some vending machines. One LCD tv in the corner in the front. We ordered spaghetti and meatballs. Small order of garlic knots. The sauce is good and the meatballs are a decent size. The noodles are al dente. Garlic knots are fresh and hot. Like everything else is. Their is a pool of butter and fresh garlic at the bottom. I just use it to dip my garlic knots in it for extra flavor. Mac Daddy sandwich is so worth it and i don't know what is exactly in it? I tasted Turkey, bacon, ham, lettuce, red onion sauce and on a lightly baked focaccia bread. It is only comes in one size, half only. Very filling and worth it. One thing I noticed on the menu, they offer a half size muffuletta not many local restaurants offer this. We ordered a special 16" pizza to go (like a supreme). Got a ice water fountain drink and had to get a Barq's root beer in a glass bottle. It is a local thing and it was started here in Biloxi before they sold it and became part of the Coca-Cola line up. They also have a good selection of beers also. Drink responsibly. A must if you are in the area want great pizza in a casual spot. It is not stellar, but fantastic. In my opinion! No WiFi I can see. I don't know about any military discount. No mask required. read more

See all

Generational pizza spot! Never again. Rude employees. Don't go here. Better choice Sarduccis Pizza. Friendly and better pizza. Give them a try! read more

This is as close to New York pizza I've had since moving here. 10/10 great pizza. For those that complain about the attitude of the guy behind the counter... go to New York and find out. read more

The pizzas are great the calzone and Stromboli are tasty. Even the subs are really good.

This is my favorite pizza spot on the coast when I want to go for what I consider a traditional pizza. The pizza is excellent and really filling. I also love the garlic knots. read more

The pizza here is awesome! This restaurant is actually a couple hundred miles from where I live. Anytime that I am near the vicinity, I make sure to plan a trip there. Caveat, if you were looking for an elegant sit down restaurant with soft music in the background, etc. this is not it. It is a pretty simple place. Located in a strip mall. If the purpose of your trip is for great pizza, this is it. You walk up, tell the guy what size pie you want are ordered by the slice. I highly recommend it for those who love a good traditional pizza. read more

Enjoyed the pizza so much that I am still thinking about it. Definitely one of those hole in the wall places. The seating area does remind me of NYC. If you're questioning yourself about giving it a try, give it a try. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Supreme Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

Pizza is fantastic here. Thin crust is crunchy and the sauce is really good. If you like NY style pizza this is it. read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

Visiting for the first time I have to say the girl at the register almost caused me to just walk out. Incredibly rude with about 2 inch bejeweled finger nails, WORKING IN A RESTAURANT! The owner walked up and was almost as rude. Against my better judgement I decided we would go ahead and stay and eat. We had a long day and just didn't want to go somewhere else. My son ordered a calzone and it was terrible. Maybe 3 pieces of Canadian bacon and tons of what I guess was ricotta. It made the calzone wet. He's a major foodie but only ate a small amount. I ordered a personal pizza. The dough was not cooked long enough. It was a super waste of $30. The longer I sat there and looked around I noticed the place is filthy, staff all had on dirty t-shirts and dirty jeans. After looking around Yelp I noticed they had a health inspector grade "C" in early June 2025 and pulled it to a "B" in July. Overall I would definitely give it a failing grade. Save your money and go anywhere else. read more

If their pizza wasn't so good, I would give this place -1 stars because their customer service is absolutely hostile when making phone orders/picking up. They don't even treat you like that in New York when ordering some pizza. If you don't like people, give someone "people-friendly" the phone to take an order. read more

Best pizza on the coast Best Pizza on the coast Best pizza on the coast Best pizza on the coast read more

amazing pizza the cheese is fresh the sauce is great...... the service is slow due to not having enough staff i guess waited over an,hour for a personal pizza an a large pepperoni and the kitchen workers are moody an stressed for the same reason. It could have been a five star if the wait wasnt outrageous and the additudes were better read more

Wanted to try. It is tasty and reminds me of new England pizza. But too expensive. Charge extra for each ingredient and are scrimpy with it. Size of pizza makes up a little. read more

We were looking for a gluten free pizza restaurant. We found "Brooklyn Pizzeria" and it was great. You order at the counter and they call your name when it's done. This place has been in Gulfport for 32 years and has a nostalgia feel to it, with all the old New York pictures and decor. We ordered 1 gluten free pizza and one 18" with everything on it. That 18" was much bigger that 18". They definitely want you to get a belly full here. Great find for us! read more

I was looking for some pizza to chow down on tonight and saw this place and decided to give them a shot. Wow oh wow am I impressed with what they have going on. I ordered a large pizza thinking they would be the same size as your usual pizza places. This pizza is massive! The boxes they use are huge and the pizza still manages to overflow on the side of the box. The service was really good and straight to the point and didn't try to sell you anything else you didn't want. All in all very satisfied! To keep in mind a large half cheese/ half pepperoni was..... $15! Considering how much you get it's definitely the best bang for your buck! read more

Brooklyn Pizzeria - Large Half cheese Half Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Gulfport, Mississippi

Excellent pizza, if not the best on the MS Gulf coast. Great, fast service as well. Thank you to all at Brooklyn Pizza, you rock!

I have been going go to Brooklyn Puzza for many years ...before Katrina ...when Mark was there everything was wonderful ..just like When I lived in Jersey . The last few times that I have been there it has been terrible ..tonight the calzone and the Stromboli were horrible ....I will not be back ..staff at the counter are not friendly and you just don't have that welcoming atmosphere any longer its a shame that you spent years making such a wonderful business to see it fall apart after you retire read more

The pizza is very good! The side salad is very large and tasty. The garlic knots were very oily. Otherwise it's a nice spot for a quick bite. read more

The food and service were great. It was a great value fed 5 for under $50 (16in and 20in pizza and 5 drinks). We could of fed 7. Highly recommend this little treasure. read more

Staff is very rude and has no or little manors. Pizza was ok but they over cooked it and kept forgetting to fill my order which added an extra 45 minutes of wait time. read more

Pizzas were DENSE. When I picked up 4 pizzas I was surprised how heavy it was. It was all delicious except the cauliflower crust. That was not so good. But the rest was awesome and the service was quick and friendly. read more

Pizza and Stromboli are really good! This place is popular so my only complaint would be that you have to expect to wait at least 20-30 minutes for your food and usually 5-10 minutes to order and pay at their counter. Things would go more smoothly if they had more than one person/register open which I've never seen in eating here 30 or more times. The restaurant has basic bench seating. The food is good and that offsets the inconvenience of eating here. read more

Outstanding New York style pizza....the best on the coast. Always delicious and super sized.

Closest we've gotten to New York pizza in the Gulf Coast region. It's hard to get NY pizza here but this was hard to beat! They're in an unassuming strip mall, but the narrow restaurant goes pretty far back so there's plenty of seating. They were also well staffed for a busy lunch. A slice was about $3.50 which isn't bad at all considering the large size. read more

Great pizza and calzones. The staff at the register seemed a bit overwhelmed. Overall a good experience.

Amazingly tasty and delicious food!! Wait time is a little excessive but that's probably only on busy days.

Exactly like New York Style Pizza. Crisp crust and good sauce. No frills pizza place that reminds you of a New York pizza joint.

I can't express in words how great this pizza tastes. It is by far the best pizza I've ever had. I've never been to Brooklyn, but I have ate a lot of different pizza styles in my 60+ years. It is also probably the cheapest pizza I've had. This place is a jewel we will revisit often during our stay in Gulfport. read more