Love this place, but no one ever answers the phone when calling to order. Then, if you go in to order, the wait times are ridiculous. Would give more stars if they just answered the phone. The food is good, but not worth those wait times. Usually, I try calling, and if no one answers, I order from another pizza place. read more

I've been visiting Holiday for a while now,and I always stop by Brooklyn Best. The pizza is really good and I love a good salad. They make the salad just the way you want, I prefer more turkey and they were very accommodating. The people there are so nice even when they are super busy. Great spot! read more

I would normally wait for a second try but I've decided to go with my first experience here. I had a lg pepperoni delivered to the Backyard Tavern. It was so overcooked I had to force eating half of it and the other half of the burnt disaster sits at home while I wait for a bar bbq to heat up and hopefully enjoy a meal after two weeks with the flu and very hungry. A sad situation for $21. If you were indeed Brooklyn in any form or fashion, this would never have left your establishment. Jeff read more

Great New York style pizza. If you're cravin' Fer a pie like back home, here ya go. Fast delivery too. Try the garlic knots. read more

Pretty good slice here. Stopped by for lunch as i just recently started working in the area and am looking to find my new go-to's for a quick bite....will def stop again. read more

Absolutely the best calzone in Florida that I have found. If you are near this place you have to try it. They also have great pizza and the cheesy bread is awesome. I hope they put one in Trinity. read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

Wish their customer service was as good as their pizza. They deliver to the front of my neighborhood but not the back where I live so I drive to pick it up. Was told 30 min when I placed my order, walked in to pay and was told it would be ten more minutes and that they would bring it out. Sat in my car. For twenty more minutes. Went inside to inquire again and the girl told me it was in the oven. Guy finally brought out my pizzas but not the two liter, said he would go grab it. Asked if he would throw in some cannolis for the wait and he laughed and said NO. Had you told me an hour when I placed my order I would have arrived at an hour. Let him know I would be finding another pizza spot, he just laughed again. Communication is key, I'll take my business where it and my time are valued. read more

Pretty good pizza, and done before estimated. Definitely try it again. The staff was very nice.

Please Improve the way you dump a bunch of garlic from a Jar on your pizzas! It Stays where you dump it, plus it was dated in the jar and we could taste it!!!! It has happened twice! I did not feel well at all after 2 pieces, could not finish that either! Pie was wet/mushy in the middle underneath and Very wet thin?!!! We are New in town and would like to patronize the Brooklyn pizza, but need improvements! Stuff very nice!!! Thanks! read more

Seriously the greatest pizza and service! The knots are a must to try with the marinara. Also try the margarita pizza. read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - 2 orders of knots - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

See all

NOOO!!!! I got food poisoning from them!! I have never gotten food poisoning in my life until now. ........ be careful people! 2*only because of the garlic knot!s! They're always fresh and fabulous I love them! Other than the garlic knots, don't waste your time. We have been coming here for a while but now the last few orders my wings have been BONE dry and they smell like old oil! They need to change the oil if it smells it's old and nasty. The pizza.... such a disappointment, it's flavorless. Go somewhere else period just don't waste your time here it's not good anymore. They don't care. read more

We ordered the pizza around 4:00 pm today very enjoyable except the very center was a little mushy. Didn't stop me from eating 5 slices. Sauce was very good and so was the rest of the crust. Very friendly staff at we will be back. read more

Wow, when you pick up a beautiful looking pie, it is really a bummer to be disappointed. They nailed the crust perfectly, which is the toughest part! There was no overly aromatic smell from the pizza, that makes you burn the top of your mouth, as you are so eager to scarf down the pie. Group consensus: perfect thin well done crust. The sauce was delicious, but very difficult to find, not even close to covering the pie. The toppings, were all sliced paper thin ( literally) pepporoni, onions, sausage, peppers & minimal cheese! Of the toppings, the only outstanding flavor we got was the black olives. We had also gotten garlic knots, which looked & smelled good, but we did not eat, as we needed to go eat. Our dinner had all the potential & for a few cents savings by the store they ruined our dinner. The price was not cheap, fairly standard for area....very dissapointed. What's a girl to do? Keep looking to find my forever pizza, now that I have moved to Pasco. read more

See all

Love the little shop, good food with only one complaint, they need to use less oil on the Pizza as even the cheese was very greasy. Still, it was very much an NY style pizza and had a very authentic taste. read more

The best pizza I've found in west Pasco, their garlic knots are great, wings are cooked crispy on request and the people are very friendly.

I wanted a good chicken parm sandwich andI got one. They only had canned drinks. I was the only customer and it took fifteen minutes to get sandwich read more

The pizza was cooked to perfection. I rate this as a maybe I'd go back because my pizza seemed to be salted to excess.. most likely the person who prepared the pizza got heavy handed with salt. But because the pizza looked great with a lot of toppings . I'd try it again but will voice my concerns read more

This is the best pizza place I have ever tried. My kids are also very picky and loved this place. My son said "best pizza ever!" I cannot think of one complaint about this place. Owner and staff are so friendly. If you are in the area, you have to try this place because it sets your expectations of great pizza to another level. read more

Delivery is quick, Pizza & wings are great. Girl on the phone taking orders was really nice and listed the specials. 10 wings, large pizza 2 toppings, and a 2 liter soda for $23 is a great deal. I really really loved the wings, definitely recommend. Wish the pizza was a little crispier, but that's personal preference. I'd order again! Happy customer. read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - Pepperoni & Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

See all

This is my favorite hand-tossed, made from scratch dough, real deal Brooklyn pizza place. Every time I order i get delicious food, delivered fast, and not that pricey either. The sandwiches are all good, a nice alternative if your not feeling up for a pie. Don't forget to try one of their Calzones, it's probably the best thing on the menu. Keep the good food coming guys! read more

Heed my warning ! Menu is misleading! The Italian sausage and peppers sub is disgusting. It consists of crumbles of sausage and little pieces of peppers. When I called to express my dismay, manager was rude and proceed to tell me they use the same sausage they put on pizza! read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - Heed my warning ! The Italian sausage and peppers sub is disgusting. It consists of crumbles of sausage used on pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

I'm originally from NYC. Their pizza is fantastic ! Super-fast delivery ... And they don't make mistakes with your order.

Bathroom was DISGUSTING!! Pee all over floor. Smell was awful. Clean your bathroom. Plus it is one uni sex bathroom. Not cool. read more

My new "go to" pizza place. Small family type place, spotless clean. NY style pizza. I asked for them to make slightly well done, and it was perfect. Tons of cheese, sauce, toppings and all quality. Crust was perfection. Med-Thin, crispy but just enough doughy inside. X-large was HUGE. I'm a big guy with a healthy appetite and I'll easily get three meals from an x-l. Always best to support local, small business, those chains are horrible and not as cheap as you think when you compare portion sizes! read more

I recently moved to a new part of town although my favorite pizza place is nearby we gave Brooklynn best a shot. I found it to be underwhelming. I chose a chicken Parmesan that came with a salad and pasta. The pasta was rather gummy and Their red sauce was too better for my liking. My husband got a pizza which he enjoyed. Although their dresset options were limited, the cannolis were a perfect finish and I like that it included 3 in an order. I'll probably stick to my tried-and-true but this is an OK back up option. read more

best pizza in the tampa area it's the most authentic and true to NYC i've ever tasted outside of NY! this place knows what they're doing! the garlic knots are THE BEST but you can't go wrong with anything on the menu everything is superb the sauce is superior pizza hut and chain restaurants have nothing on brooklyns best! read more

They are consistently good , always use them for my kids get togethers and everyone will ask where the pizza came from. My personal favorite is garlic rolls welldone, a meal in itself. There wings are good as well garlic/parm wonderful says my wife the critic. Would recommend a try read more

I didn't even continue with ordering from this place because the lady was disgustingly rude taking my order. get a new person who takes order and put that woman In the kitchen where she's not talking to customers read more

Amazing pizza! Wonderful staff. A must try, definitely recommended. My new pizza place for sure!

Had guests at our home two weeks in a row. We ordered delivery each time and really enjoyed the pizza. They use fresh toppings and just the right amount of all toppings we chose. read more

This was by far one of the best pizzas I've had since moving to Florida. Highly recommend

I've had pizza many of times up in NY. This is not NY style pizza when it comes to flavor. So this place is not far from where I live. Free garlic knots with Yelp check in and purchase. Was quick and staff was friendly. For me that's where the positives stop though. Pizza was really lacking flavor. Not sure how it is possible that there wasn't a strong sauce, cheese and/or crust flavor. Just extremely bland. I need to try something else here. I'm not yet turned off by this place. The garlic knots were good. Just needed a little salt and pepper. I hope my next visit will prove my first visit wrong. read more

Awesome wings and pizza cooked perfect not burnt on bottom like most ! Fast delivery!

Such a convenient place to get great pizza! I really like the friendly staff and the pizza is great too!! read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - OMG Best Pizza from Brooklyn's Yet! My hubby picked it up just as it was coming out of the oven!!! I'm so happy right now! So yummy!! - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

Found this pizza joint when we first moved here. They are so good! Taste just like NY style Pizza and cheessteaks! Even though their cannolis are frozen they are the best! They even deliver for $1.00! Great staff! read more

Brooklyn Best is my old standby. I order delivery from here at least once or twice a week. I wish they had online ordering but the ordering process over the phone is pretty efficient. They have a lady taking orders who does a very good job. The chicken quesadillas are my favorite and they are the same every time. In fact all the food I've tried is consistently the same and good. My kids enjoy the chicken tenders and the mozzarella sticks. Apart from quesadillas I enjoy their Greek salad, gyros, and garlic parm wings. I can't comment too much on the Pizza and its style as I've only had it once or twice and i'm not a pizza connoisseur. In the context of delivered food I haven't come across anyone better in the area. Keep up the good work. read more

Love the calzones, Best in town! Come hungry as they are huge! Always fresh and delicious read more

Apparently, Brooklyns is under new ownership/management so we came at just the right time. I have family that lives in Holiday, so my wife and I went down for a visit. We ordered a pizza and a calzone, everything tasted fresh and delicious!!! They serve all sorts of food, but make sure to try the dessert! The wait staff was super friendly, the inside was recently renovated and had a great "New York" feel. The dining area was nice and spacious, and was kept very clean. My only wish is that there was a location near my hometown in Michigan LOL read more

Brooklyn Best Pizza - This calzone was one of the best I've ever had. - Pizza Near Me - Holiday, Florida

See all

The pizza was immaculate! The bread knots were superb! The salad was amazing! The ranch was very tasty!

My 1st time there. What a screw up. Messed up order totally. Bunch of kids working there answering the phone. Does not confirm order before they cook it. Picked it up. Got home. Grand kids ready to eat some meat lover pizza. Then find it full of veggies. VERY LITTLE MEAT. Kids dont eat veggie PIZZA. Called to tell them. They said oh well. We can credit for next time. WHAT ABOUT TONITE??? MY GRANDKIDS ARE READY TO EAT NOW!!!!!!!!!!! NOT NEXT TIME!! I will not let them remake one now. Because who knows what they put on it next. I want money refunded! Plan and simple. They could have offered to have the rite one delivered. NEVER GOING THERE AGAIN!!! I will go to CiCi. At least i know what to expect from them. I had to give them 1 star. It should be a -5 star rating. read more