Started searching for a pizza place for lunch and noticed this shop. Only a few hundred reviews on…read morethe map software and 30 on Yelp so I wondered if it was a new place. My friend said this place has been here for a while but this is a new name. Anyway, we ordered garlic knots to start and then a works pizza. Both were amazing. The garlic knots were hot and the tomato sauce for dipping was really tasty. The pizza was served hot by the cook himself. Everyone was super friendly and everything tasted great. I'll definately be back.

Amazing service Pizza was good, I'm always happy to fresh…read moreingredients, mushroom and spinach were fresh. The sauce was good and not too sweet or too sour. Crust had some chew to it, it's the kind of crust I'm looking for. Not a huge fan of Neapolitan crust, so this was perfect. The spinach roll and pizza rolls were like garlic knots and different, I preferred the pizza. I wasn't a huge fan of the milkshake. Advertised as extra thick but it wasn't, pretty milky. I would absolutely come back and the service was incredible. Next time I'm going to get the mushroom again, and try out the buffalo chicken pizza.

Their pizza is delicious and always done just the way I order it. Their customer service is also…read moreexcellent and the store is always clean and neat. I live close by so I always pick up my order, which is always ready when they say it will be! I highly recommend Brother's Pizza to everyone!!!

First time order it from them, definitely will not be the last! Ordered a large pepperoni slightly…read moretoasted cheese. Myself and two others here (I did not prompt them) thought it was the best! Allow me to elaborate! Crust was crunchy and chewy, and had a great flavor. Great sauce, and since I had him toast the cheese a little, it was exactly how I like it. But the best part, when I went in the owner was mopping the floor! I don't know about you, but I love a restaurant that is clean!! And this guy seems to be somewhat obsessed with clean! So, in summary: great pizza great crust and it's a clean place to eat! And the guy behind the counter told me they also have sandwiches. I'm sure they're great. I'll let you know.

Ordered for the first time. Pizza was very good, delivered hot and fast. The online ordering was a…read morelittle difficult to navigate causing a miss order but the quality of the food delivered made up for it. Cost was in line with others.

Update as of 2/2026: The past few months I've ordered here…read moreseems to have disappointed for some reason. Either it's cold, or the crust is stale or not enough cheese or too little cheese. Please fix this, this was my favorite pizza spot and I don't know what happened! Previous review from 2025: The pizza is FIRE! I'm from NY and this is the closest I've gotten to NY pizza (other than a place in YBOR). Love it. 10/10z

Love this place. Great NY style pizza. Best in area for sure. Also have great wings. Give them a…read moreshot.

We had medium pizza and 10 wings. Had wings cooked extra…read morecrispy and they were perfect. I'm glad we have found our pizza joint.

We've had their pizza before, and it's always really good...but this time we got to try their wings…read moreduring an NPR wing competition. They were prepared (unlike a couple other places involved in the contest) and had wings ready to go. Had a nice dry rub that was complemented by a house sauce on the side. Backdraughts was one of five bars/restaurants that were competing, and their wings were so good they were not only our favorite...but everyone else's as well. I don't even think it was close as many other people we talked to said theirs were the best. They weren't wrong. Come here for excellent pizza, but def add the wings as well!!

Mediocre. The pizza left a lot to be desired. Ordered a margarita which had red sauce, tomatoes,…read morebasil, and mozzarella. There's plenty of red sauce, but no flavor and the toppings didn't really add anything to the pizza. We also added mushrooms, which also didn't add anything to the pizza. All I could taste was red sauce. Make sure you specify whether you want the personal or the large. This is the only two options they give you two prices and the smaller price is a personal and the larger price is not that much bigger. The bar? Definitely gets a fail. They advertised a spiced pear Margarita. It was not a spiced pear. It was a spicy pear, which is a completely different drink. A spiced pear would imply, nutmeg, cinnamon, anise, and such. However, it was definitely spicy, as in habanero. So please don't make the same mistake we did. Wasn't with a special drink there was also a drink. That was some kind of espresso chime martini. That may not be the name of it so don't quote me on that. But, you couldn't taste chai. All you tasted was coffee. There was also supposed to be hazelnut in there, which you also couldn't taste. Whoever writes the menu for these particular cocktails, doesn't understand that the most dominant flavor is listed first, and then the accentuating flavors are listed in the order in which they are expected to taste. The martini we tried had no chai and no hazelnut. It was all espresso. Once again, very disappointing. The service was OK but not stellar. Although I got the impression that there was only one waitress serving all the tables inside and outside, so I'm not sure I can actually blame her. It's just a shame that the food and the service for both not great on this particular occasion.

Ordered the eggplant Parmesan with a side of salad. We were served garlic rolls that were very…read moretasty but a little doughy. The salad was fresh and the eggplant Parmesan was outstanding. The sauce was very good. We even shared it and I couldn't finish. The service was great. Everyone was very friendly. The lighting could be a little brighter and the floor could and should be swept. Will we come here again you bet !

All the employees are so friendly and courteous. We really enjoy their shrimp marinara. Also they…read moremake the best Sicilian pizza.

My apologies to Justin for not doing this sooner. The 1st I'd ordered from here it was a little…read moredifferent than what I was expecting. It was a thicker crust but a very good crispy n airy crust not too doughy. I left a Google review saying that I usually prefer a more typical NY style thinner crust but this was a nice change of pace n it was excellent and very cheesey. He remembered that the next time he took n order from me sent me a thinner crust pizza which I wasn't expecting n didn't want. I never reached out to complain, the next he contacted me because he's a guy that takes pride in his business. I let him know I wasn't pleased with n he immediately gave me a credit on my next order. Next time I had a couple.more.oeopoe to feed so I used the credit n ordered another pizza to go with it. These were 2 of thee best pizzas I've had in years!!!! I highly recommend you try this place if you haven't already. Tell Justin that George sent you n he'll make them his best for you. P.S. I ordered them well done cause that's how I like it. P.P.S. I took a minute to answer the questions n accidentally hit yes when they asked if it was divey. I couldn't go back to change it.

Hard to find good pizza here. this had a great crust that was crunchy and chewy without being…read moredoughy. He hand tossed the dough ,the final presentation was very good and best of all my wife gave it the thumbs up.

First time dining at this location and it was a pleasant experience!!! We were sat immediately upon…read moreentry and had excellent service by Kerri!!! All food was served promptly and tasted excellent!!! Very nice atmosphere inside which also was entertaining. Definitely recommend, especially for families or a date night spot!!

Still as good as ever!! Ordered the Garlic Parm and Med Buffalo wings. They are a generous size. We…read morealways take advantage of their free delivery.

This joint is our new favorite pizza place! We've only ordered delivery so we haven't been to the…read moreactual restaurant but the delivery driver is extremely nice and they are super fast! Their garlic knots are delicious and their antipasto salad is one of our favorites! Their pizza is delicious! I'm typically not a big pizza fan, but they have a ton of different options and unique choices. So far their barbecue chicken has been my favorite, but I'm definitely looking forward to trying their Mediterranean pizza. They are also pretty nicely priced, especially for the amount of food that you can. We couldn't recommend this place enough!

Decent for a cheese pizza. Kinda greasy. Not a fan of…read moreCaden's I wouldn't get their grilled chicken again kind of rubbery. Sauce okay, crust okay overall not awful. Husband thought the bbq sauce was too peppery.

We decided to order a large Neapolitan and take the leftovers home for dinner. It was around…read more$35.00 for a large pizza and two drinks ($23.95 for the BIG pizza and $3.50 drinks). It wasn't the best or worst pizza I've ever had. However, this pizza was freshly made and fully loaded! Our waitress, Kim, was very attentive, kind, and funny. The restaurant was very clean and nicely decorated. It was a bit dark but very comfortable. The atmosphere was great with awesome music. I highly recommend it!

I just came here to have dinner with Sir Hubbers…read more I was early, ordered the Mussels in White Sauce & they were spoiled. I spit them out. They were so bad I left cash on the table and left. I'm now praying I do not get sick. Attention Chef: "If I do get sick, you will most certainly be hearing from me, and you better be praying you don't." DO NOT RECOMMEND.